You are here
For some Nordic banks, boring may be better than bonuses
[STOCKHOLM] Just seven months ago, Sweden's Handelsbanken was worth almost US$20 billion less than Deutsche Bank. This month, it eclipsed Germany's flagship lender.
Its market value has held up as concerns over negative interest rates and bad debts, along with spiralling macro-economic worries, have seen other European lenders slide this year.
Handelsbanken epitomises a more conservative Nordic banking style that prioritises cost control over revenue growth. It pays no annual bonuses to executives and has a decentralised model that gives branch managers control over lending, which it says helps reduce bad loan risks.
It had an efficiency ratio - a measure of a bank's operating costs as a percentage of its revenue - of 45.3 per cent in 2015. By comparison, Deutsche Bank had 115.3 per cent and BNP Paribas 82.9 percent.
Former Swedish Finance Minister Anders Borg has lauded its approach, calling for more "boring" banking based on borrowing and lending over the risk-taking and expansionist policies in the global industry that helped cause the 2008 financial crisis. "I wouldn't use the word boring, but we don't want any surprises," Handelsbanken finance chief Ulf Riese told Reuters.
"The one risk we do like to take is credit risk because we know our customers so well and have such a local presence."
Nordic banks' relatively conservative approach to risk and cost control has sheltered them somewhat from the turbulence across the continent; while the European banking index had dropped more than 20 per cent this year, as of 0800 GMT on Friday, the six major Nordic banks were down on average about 8 per cent.
Handelsbanken has fallen just 1 per cent this year, giving it a market value of about US$24.5 billion on Friday, topping Deutsche Bank's US$23.8 billion. At the beginning of August it was worth around US$28.5 billion against Deutsche's US$48 billion.
The six Nordic lenders - also including Sweden's Nordea , Swedbank and SEB, Norway's DNB and Denmark's Danske Bank - made a combined net profit of 13.2 billion euros (US$20.7 billion). Handelsbanken reported the biggest profit in its 144-year history.
They have all slashed costs as they sought to recover from the crisis and navigate negative interest rates; Sweden and Denmark were among the first countries to introduce such rates.
Danske for example has reduced the number of branches to about 300 in 2015 from almost 800 in 2008 while Swedbank plans to cut costs by a tenth this year compared with 2014.
Many have moved parts of their operations from city centres to the cheaper suburbs and invested heavily in digitalisation, allowing them to cut staff. Nordea held one in seven customer meetings online in the fourth quarter.
"We have argued for a long time that Nordic banks, Swedbank and Nordea in particular, have been the canaries in the coal mine," said Adam Barrass, banking analyst at Berenberg bank."They have shown the path that you should follow in a negative rate environment or as net interest margins get squeezed." "Nordics banks have been self-aware enough to realise that to keep returns high, you can't just rely on growth in a balance sheet recessionary scenario - rather, you must focus on costs."
Banks in the region have also benefited from not having the bloated investment banking operations that many European lenders have had to restructure at great expense in the face of tougher regulation that reduced profitability.
But some executives and economists see potential risks on the horizon; home prices in the region have risen sharply over the past two decades, raising fears of housing bubbles that could burst, while household debt levels are among the highest in Europe. In Sweden, they stand at around 170 percent of disposable income.
For now though, Nordic lenders are regarded as among the most stable in Europe. Sweden has some of the toughest capital requirements in Europe, forcing banks to set aside more profits rather than shifting it to shareholders. This has brought down their borrowing costs.
Handelsbanken has a smaller proportion of bad loans than the industry average in Europe. Rating institute Moody's upgraded its long-term credit rating to Aa2 in 2015, the highest rating in Europe of all comparable banks.
The bank, which made a 2015 operating profit of 20.5 billion Swedish crowns ($2.4 billion), has no revenue growth target.
Handelsbanken staff join a scheme that awards them an equal share of the bank's profits - the same for kitchen staff at the bank's head office as for its CEO - which cannot be accessed until they reach the age of 60. "We think of the bank as our bank and that it is our own money at stake," said Mr Riese.