The Business Times

HSBC's 'rotten' traders accused of gaining from secret info

Published Tue, Jun 15, 2021 · 11:17 AM

[LONDON] HSBC Holdings Plc faced accusations from an ex-client that its "rotten" traders used confidential information to make a profit, at the start of a London trial examining allegations of front running at the bank's foreign exchange desk over 15 years ago.

The bank's currency team deliberately traded ahead of client orders during a period far earlier than HSBC has previously admitted to, currency investment firm ECU Group Plc said. HSBC dismissed the claims as "incredibly stale." The trial will consider "a disgraceful period in HSBC's history," Richard Lissack, a lawyer for ECU said Monday, that serves as a "chronological prequel" to the episode regarding which the bank paid hundreds of millions of dollars to resolve investigations by UK and US authorities.

The accusations come after the bank's former global head of foreign exchange, Mark Johnson, was jailed for using his advance knowledge of a big client order to trade ahead of it. His deputy Stuart Scott successfully fought extradition to America after British judges ruled that much of the alleged misconduct took place in the UK ECU says HSBC manipulated rates between 2004 and 2006 that affected billions of dollars of orders.

The trading desk during that time appears to have seen client orders "as an opportunity for enrichment," Mr Lissack said, calling the culture "rotten." The lender acknowledged it defrauded two clients by front running in 2010 and 2011 and agreed to pay about US$100 million in a deferred prosecution agreement with the US Justice Department. HSBC has paid at least US$900 million in fines to global regulators over currency rigging.

HSBC said in its own court filing that the claim was time-barred. The suit was a "cynical and opportunistic attempt to resurrect these stale claims," the bank's lawyer Kenneth MacLean said.

An HSBC spokesman referred to the legal filing and declined to comment further.


Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox.


The trading of around 40 orders on behalf of ECU doesn't show that the desk deliberately rigged the market, Mr MacLean said in the bank's documents prepared for trial. When traders bought currency ahead of the orders, it wasn't intended to affect the market price. The practice was standard "pre-hedging" that benefitted its loan customers, HSBC said.

The trial is set to consider whether HSBC improperly rejected concerns about front running from ECU in 2006, when the bank wrote to ECU's Chief Executive Officer Michael Petley saying there was no misconduct in the transactions.

At the start of the trial, Mr Lissack complained that HSBC had chosen not to provide any testimony from any of its former traders.

"Not one will come before the court to say I did not do what I'm alleged to have done," he said.



BT is now on Telegram!

For daily updates on weekdays and specially selected content for the weekend. Subscribe to

Banking & Finance


Get the latest coverage and full access to all BT premium content.


Browse corporate subscription here