You are here

Regulator blocks Vodafone's US$7.7b merger with TPG

Australia's competition watchdog says competition in mobile services would be hurt

The decision of the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) to block the merger sent the shares of TPG Telecom tumbling 14 per cent.


A PLANNED US$7.7 billion merger of the Vodafone Group's struggling Australian business with TPG Telecom was blocked by the regulator in a bungled announcement published early that sent stocks tumbling.

The proposal would "substantially lessen competition" for mobile-phone services in an already concentrated market, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) said in a statement on Wednesday.

TPG is Australia's best - and probably the last - chance to gain a new cellular network operator, ACCC chairman Rod Sims said in the statement.

Market voices on:

A protracted legal battle between the companies and the regulator now looms. TPG and Vodafone Hutchison Australia, Vodafone's unprofitable mobile-phone venture with CK Hutchison Holdings, said they're still committed to a union and will challenge the ACCC's decision in the Federal Court.

Hanging in the balance is a proposal to create a new Australian tech giant selling mobile phone and broadband services, which will be worth an estimated A$10.9 billion (S$10.4 billion). If the deal is blocked, former Australian phone monopoly Telstra Corp and Optus - owned by Singapore's Singtel - would only gain more power, TPG said. The ACCC's decision must be challenged, it said.

The watchdog's decision also scuppers Vodafone's plan to breathe new life into a mobile-phone partnership that has struggled to make inroads in Australia. In almost a decade of operations, Vodafone Hutchison won only 19 per cent of the local mobile-phone market. Nicknamed Vodafail by some, the venture struggled to overcome a reputation for patchy coverage and dropped calls.

There had been speculation that Vodafone would look to exit Australia. The UK phone giant's planned union with TPG was an attempt to salvage something from an entity that some analysts said was essentially worthless.

Vodafone Hutchison chief executive officer Inaki Berroeta said in a statement: "We believe the merger with TPG will bring very real benefits to consumers."

He said the businesses have little overlap and can deliver more for Australian consumers together than they can alone.

The ACCC, which typically publishes its rulings when shares aren't trading, fumbled the statement of its decision, sending TPG stock into meltdown. Scheduled for release Thursday, the decision was briefly visible on the regulator's website on Wednesday afternoon - before it was removed. The ACCC later confirmed its opposition to the deal and blamed a technical error for the inadvertent publication.

ACCC chairman Sims said in a telephone interview: "It's embarrassing." The regulator has opened a probe.

Mr Sims defended his opposition to the deal, saying the proposed tie-up was a "bridge too far".

TPG Telecom tumbled 14 per cent Wednesday, while Hutchison Telecommunications Australia, home to CK Hutchison's stake in the mobile phone company, lost 28 per cent.

Telstra fell 2.1 per cent as investors bet that an independent TPG would represent more of a competitive threat.

Mr Sims said: "TPG has a proven track record of disrupting the telecommunications sector and establishing itself as a successful competitor to the benefit of consumers. TPG is likely to be a vigorous and innovative supplier of mobile services in Australia." BLOOMBERG