You are here
These are the worst-case scenarios for China in the trade war
[BEIJING] China's economic growth could tumble, debt surge and foreign companies flee in a deepening trade war, economists warn as a week of escalating tensions forces them to ponder worst-case scenarios.
Bank of America Corp, Morgan Stanley and UBS Group AG say China's expansion may slow below 6 per cent under such a scenario for the first time in almost three decades. The 5.8 per cent pace seen by chief Greater China economist Helen Qiao at Bank of America would create "a more dire growth environment than the number suggests".
Analysts are assessing the damage to China's role as the world's supply hub as tariffs drive manufacturers overseas. They're also warning of a spiralling of debt that's already closing on 300 per cent of output as the government cushions the blow with additional spending. Fresh curbs on Huawei Technologies Co's access to the US market and American suppliers underscore the threat of economic containment China that is having to contend with.
"The potential long-term cost is huge," said Larry Hu, chief China economist at Macquarie Securities Ltd in Hong Kong. "They must know that Japan fell into the lost decade partly because the Bank of Japan overstimulated the Japanese economy after the Plaza Accord."
The escalating clash with the US is exacerbating existing economic judders, with data released on Wednesday showing the expansion lost momentum in April even before President Donald Trump raised additional tariffs on US$200 billion of Chinese imports to 25 per cent from 10 per cent. The weakness raises the stakes for President Xi Jinping to avert a prolonged economic confrontation at a possible meeting with Trump at the Group of 20 summit in Japan next month.
The economy is set for a bumpy ride in the short term, with additional tariffs on US$200 billion of Chinese products shaving 0.3 percentage points this year, according to economists surveyed by Bloomberg News. An additional 0.6 percentage point will be sliced off expansion in the year after all goods are hit by US tariffs - as Trump threatens from June, according to the survey's median estimate.
What Bloomberg's economists Say:
China's economic outlook would be badly damaged should the US act upon its threat of further tariff increases. Raising the rate to 25 per cent on US$200 billion in Chinese exports would increase the impact to 0.9 percentage point in the year ahead. Increasing tariffs on the rest of Chinese imports, as flagged by President Trump, would mean a drag of around 1.5 percentage points. - Chang Shu, Chief Asia economist, Bloomberg Economics
A full-blown escalation with blanket 25 per cent tariffs imposed by both sides would push China's growth below the lower bound of the 6 to 6.5 per cent growth target set for this year by the second half of 2019, and to 5.5 per cent next year, according to Morgan Stanley.
Citigroup sees the cumulative impact of US tariffs eliminating as many as 4.4 million jobs even before Mr Trump slaps tariffs on those remaining Chinese exports of about US$300 billion.
"The outlook is bleak," said Chen Long, an economist at research firm Gavekal Dragonomics in Beijing in a May 14 note. "Equities are likely to correct further, potentially wiping out most of the market's year-to-date gains. Bond yields will fall again, after the recent pick-up. And the renminbi is likely to soften," he said, referring to the yuan by its other name.
Mr Xi is poised to deliver the stimulus needed to prevent a steeper growth plunge, likely causing debt to rise more sharply after a two-year campaign to rein it in. Blanket tariffs on Chinese products render the balance between short-term growth and debt sustainability "unattainable", according to Societe Generale SA. As debt climbs, that may reignite concerns over systemic financial risks.
It's the potential for longer-term damage to China's economic model though that most concerns economists should Mr Xi become embroiled in a protracted economic war.
US tariffs on Chinese products have already set in motion a profound shift in global supply chains that won't be easily reversed. That threatens to accelerate the departure of manufacturers that already are reeling from rising labour and other costs.
Production leaving China
Japanese office equipment maker Ricoh Co said on Thursday it is moving some production from China to Thailand to avoid trade war risks and Taiwan's Kenda Rubber Industrial is investing in Vietnam for the same reason. Big consumer brands Samsonite International SA, Macy's Inc and Fossil Group Inc have all said on recent calls with analysts that they are continuing to move production and sourcing out of China.
"Both foreign multinational companies and Chinese private enterprises are more actively seeking alternative manufacturing bases," said Klaus Baader, global chief economist at Societe Generale. "A lower trend growth in investment, coupled with more restricted access to foreign know-how, would mean permanent damage to long-term productivity growth."
Restrictions on Chinese investment in the US, especially in technology-related areas, risk stalling the transfer of technologies and foreign know-how, slowing China's move up the value chain, said Zhuang Bo, chief China economist in Beijing at research firm TS Lombard.
Even worse may await should Mr Trump add export tariffs or ban shipments of key technology components to China, especially semi-conductors, said Alicia Garcia Herrero, chief Asia-Pacific economist at Natixis SA in Hong Kong. That would strangle the Chinese economy, she says.
Altogether, an economic war with the US "blows China up," said Michael Every, head of Asia financial markets research at Rabobank in Hong Kong. "China would be cut off from Western markets, ideas, technology, and US dollar-flow long, long before it's ready to replace the US for real."