You are here

Pulling federal high-speed rail funds would be 'disastrous': California

[WASHINGTON] California's High-Speed Rail Authority on Monday urged the Trump administration to abandon plans to withhold US$929 million in funding and seek to claw back US$2.5 billion the state has already received for a rail project, calling the effort "disastrous" and "unlawful."

Brian Kelly, chief executive of the authority, told the Federal Railroad Administration in a letter that seeking the return of funds already spent by California would be "disastrous policy" and could put 2,600 people out of work. He formally asked the agency to reconsider ahead of a March 5 deadline.

The administration last month moved to end funding after California Governor Gavin Newsom said the state would scale back the planned US$77.3 billion high-speed rail project after cost hikes, delays and management concerns, but would finish a smaller section.

Mr Kelly told the FRA that withholding the US$929 million awarded by the Obama administration in 2010 "would be unwarranted, unprecedented, and legally indefensible, and it would gravely harm a historic project."

The FRA said in a letter last month it wanted to halt funding because the state had "failed to make reasonable progress." It cited Mr Newsom's announcement to scale back the project.

Your feedback is important to us

Tell us what you think. Email us at

Mr Kelly on Monday asked the FRA to reconsider its "rash and unlawful action" and discuss its concerns with the state authority. The FRA decision will not be finalised until it reviews California's protest.

The US Transportation Department, which oversees FRA, had no immediate comment because it had not seen the letters from California.

The traffic-choked state had planned to build a 836.8km system in the first phase that would allow trains to travel at up to 354 kmh from Los Angeles to San Francisco and begin full operations by 2033.

Mr Newsom said last month the state would instead complete a 191.5km high-speed link between Merced and Bakersfield in the state's Central Valley.

"There simply isn't a path to get from Sacramento to San Diego, let alone from San Francisco to (Los Angeles). I wish there were," Mr Newsom said last month.

Mr Kelly told FRA that Mr Newsom is not abandoning high-speed rail but "proposing billions of dollars in additional state funding to expand the initial construction project in the Central Valley."

He added that ending funding "would cause massive disruption, dislocation, and waste, damaging the region and endangering the future of high-speed rail in California."

The Obama administration awarded California US$3.5 billion in 2010 and California voters in 2008 approved nearly US$10 billion in bond proceeds.

In March 2018, the state forecast project costs had jumped by US$13 billion to US$77 billion and warned costs could be as much as US$98.1 billion.


BT is now on Telegram!

For daily updates on weekdays and specially selected content for the weekend. Subscribe to