You are here

Tesla's profit blowout undoes much of Musk's damage to stock

"Our earnings profile has flipped dramatically. We can't thank you enough for your support. We would not have achieved this historic quarter without it." - Tesla CEO Elon Musk (above) and CFO Deepak Ahuja said in a letter to shareholders

San Francisco

TESLA blew away expectations with just the third quarter of positive earnings in its history, bolstering Elon Musk's bid to make selling electric cars a financially sustainable business.

The profit and cash that Tesla generated sent its shares surging to levels last seen in mid-August, when the chief executive officer was still in the midst of a short-lived gambit to take the company private. The stock sold off in the intervening months, after Mr Musk's claim that he had "funding secured" for such a deal proved faulty and landed him in legal jeopardy.

All the while, Tesla was achieving long-awaited breakthroughs to boost production of Model 3 sedans. Buyers - many of whom had been waiting more than two years to take delivery - quickly made it one of the top-selling sedans in the US

Tesla is still far from being a full-line carmaker, and it has followed up past quarters of profitability with strings of more losses. It is still nowhere close to generating revenue and earnings to contend with the likes of Toyota Motor Corp or BMW AG. But even investors who have been among the most vocally bearish about the company have started to change their view as Mr Musk lures away buyers of Camry and 3-Series sedans.

Your feedback is important to us

Tell us what you think. Email us at

"It is the most encouraging sign of sustainable profitability that we've seen in three years," said Gene Munster, a managing partner at venture capital firm Loup Ventures. "Tesla did all of this despite the distractions around Elon himself, and the positive report reverses some of the damage that's been done."

Tesla reported adjusted net income of US$2.90 a share, soundly beating analysts' average estimate for a small loss. Free cash flow was about US$881 million, a turnabout from the billions of dollars that Tesla was burning on a quarterly basis while it was struggling to ramp up the Model 3.

And even as deliveries took off, Tesla managed to maintain more than US$900 million in customer deposits, showing that there is still plenty of pent-up demand for the company's cars.

Mr Musk capped the quarterly report with a drama-free earnings call, which is far from a given for him. He opened by calling on executives responsible for efforts ranging from artificial intelligence and autopilot to workplace safety, leaving less time than usual for the question-and-answer session with analysts.

The shares advanced 11 per cent to US$319.39 in European trading as at 11.05 am in Germany. Tesla last close above this level on Aug 24.

The quarter "marks an inflection point", said Joe Dennison, associate portfolio manager of Zevenbergen Capital Investments in Seattle. Strong demand for pricier all-wheel-drive and high-performance versions of the Model 3, plus Tesla's plan to start selling the car in Europe early next year, should support profit margins, he wrote in an e-mail.

The results bode well for the car industry's wider rollout of electric vehicles, Daimler AG chief financial officer Bodo Uebber said after the German maker of Mercedes-Benz reported results.

"We're happy that Tesla achieved a good result," he said. "It's good for the industry, and we are generally optimistic about our own electric-car strategy."

Tesla reaffirmed its forecast for profit and positive free cash flow in the fourth quarter, adding credibility to Mr Musk's prediction a quarter ago that the company will make those feats routine going forward.

The CEO couched those comments in August by saying that "force majeure" events could prove him wrong. One such circumstance that the company will have to muddle through in the coming quarters will be trade tensions involving China. BLOOMBERG

BT is now on Telegram!

For daily updates on weekdays and specially selected content for the weekend. Subscribe to