You are here

This isn't start of deep bear market

While the US yield curve may be flashing a warning sign and should be watched, other indicators are not foreshadowing a US recession.

Share markets are due for a correction or pullback after rallying strongly since their December lows and worries about inverted yields curves and the growth outlook could provide the trigger. But US and global recession still looks to be a fair way off and 2019 is expected to be a reasonably good year for shares.

THE past week has seen a renewed intensification of concerns about global growth. Bond yields have plunged and associated growth worries have weighed on share markets. This analysis looks at the global growth outlook, why shares are vulnerable to a pullback and why it's unlikely to be a resumption of last year's downtrend.

But first some perspective. At their lows back in December global shares had fallen 18 per cent from their highs, with US shares down 20 per cent and Australian shares down 14 per cent and many were convinced that recession was around the corner. Since then share markets have staged an impressive rebound with global shares rising 18 per cent, US shares up 21 per cent and Australian shares up 14 per cent. So the 2 per cent or so fall in shares seen in the past few days is a bit of a non-event.

Late last year investor sentiment had become very negative. Since then many of the fears that had depressed shares have faded: The Fed has become more dovish and less threatening to the US growth outlook; other central banks have actually eased notably in China and Europe; the Chinese authorities have shifted from cutting debt to stimulating growth; the US partial government shutdown has ended; the US and China look to be heading towards a trade deal; and fears around recession faded. And so shares rebounded.

However, after the 20 per cent plunge as seen in US shares last year it's unusual to have a deep V rebound like that since December. Shares had become technically overbought and some measures of investor sentiment have become complacent. More fundamentally, there are several "worries" that could impact share markets - notably around growth. And this is being reflected in plunging bond yields & an inverted US yield curve. This has all left shares vulnerable to a short-term pull back.

Market voices on:

The problem now is that while some of the worries from last year have faded, global growth looks to be continuing to slow. Particularly disappointing in this regard were March business conditions - PMIs which showed falls in the US and Europe - and continuing weakness in Japan (and Australia).

The weakness in growth indicators along with the "great retreat" back to dovishness and monetary easing by central banks aided by falling inflation has seen a renewed plunge in bond yields.

This has seen US yields fall to levels not seen since 2017, German and Japanese bond yields go negative again and Australian bond yields fall to a record low.

The decline in US bond yields has added to growth fears by pushing various measures of the yield curve to flat or negative. A negative, or inverted, US yield curve - ie when long-term bond yields fall below short-term rates - has preceded US recessions so it's natural for investors to be concerned. The gap between the US 10-year bond yield and the two-year bond yield has now fallen to just 0.22 per cent. Between the 10-year bond yield and the Fed Funds rate, the gap has fallen to just 0.02 per cent, and it is -0.02 per cent between the two-year bond yield and the Fed Funds rate.

But there are several things to allow for before getting sucked into the current frenzy around an inverted yield curve. First, the yield curve can give false signals.

Second, the lag from an inverted curve to a recession has been around 15 months. So even if it becomes decisively inverted now recession may not come till mid next year. Historically the share market has peaked three to six months before recessions, so it's too far away for markets to anticipate. After US yield curve inversions in 1989, 1998 and 2006, US shares first rallied more than 20 per cent.

Third, various factors may be flattening the US yield curve which may not be indicative of an approaching US recession including the Fed's new-found dovishness, negative German and Japanese bond yields holding down US yields, the realisation that central banks won't be dumping their bond holdings and high investor demand for bonds post-Global Finanical Crisis (GFC) as they have proven to be a good diversifier - rallying every time shares have a major fall.

Fourth, other indicators suggest that US monetary policy is far from tight - the real Fed fund rate is barely positive, and the nominal Fed fund rate is well below nominal GDP growth and both are far from levels that have preceded US recessions.

Finally, we have yet to see the sort of excesses that precede US recessions: wage growth is still moderate, inflation is benign, there has been no boom in consumer spending, investment or housing construction, and private debt growth overall has been modest. It may also be argued that President Trump will do whatever he can to avoid recession next year as US presidents don't get re-elected when unemployment is rising.

So while the US yield curve may be flashing a warning sign and should be watched, its shortcomings need to be allowed for and other indicators are not foreshadowing a US recession. This is important because the historical experience tells us that what happens in the US is critical to how deep share market falls get. Deep ("grizzly") bear markets are invariably associated with US recession. Our view remains that US recession is not imminent and last year's share market falls are unlikely to be the start of a deep bear market.

More broadly, global growth is likely to pick up into the second half reflecting policy stimulus and reduced trade war fears. Signs of green shoots in terms of global growth include Chinese credit and investment, US data for retail sales, capital goods orders and consumer confidence and eurozone industrial production.

But what about the risks around global trade, Brexit and the Mueller inquiry? These could cause a share market pullback but none looks significant enough to cause a resumption of last year's falls:

  • US and China trade negotiations continue to see argy-bargy but look to be on track to a significant deal in terms of reducing trade barriers and protecting intellectual property as it's in both sides' interests (particularly Mr Trump's who doesn't want a trade war depressing the economy and shares and ruining his 2020 re-election prospects). But a deal with China would beg the question of whether Mr Trump will then turn his attention to trade with Europe starting with car tariffs.

However, our assessment is that he probably won't: America's trade deficit with Europe is small compared to that with China; public and congressional support for a trade war with Europe is low; most of Mr Trump's advisers are against it; the EU would retaliate and this would badly affect states that support Mr Trump that export to Europe; it would be a new blow to confidence and share markets ahead of Mr Trump's 2020 re-election campaign.

  • The Brexit soap opera continues to create huge risks for the UK but it's a second order issue globally. Forty-six per cent of UK exports go to the EU but only 6 per cent of EU exports go to the UK, so Brexit means far more for the UK economy than it does for the EU.

Given the threat to the UK economy, the issue around the Irish border and that the 2016 Brexit vote was around immigration and sovereignty but not free trade with the EU, a soft Brexit or no Brexit (after another referendum) is more likely than a hard or no-deal Brexit. What happens in the eurozone though is far more significant than Brexit.

  • Finally, despite the hopes of Democrats, it looks like the Mueller inquiry has failed to come up with a smoking gun significant enough to see Mr Trump removed from office.

Share markets are due for a correction or pullback after rallying strongly since their December lows and worries about inverted yields curves and the growth outlook could provide the trigger. But US and global recession still looks to be a fair way off and we continue to see this being a reasonably good year for shares. The continuing fall in bond yields is not necessarily inconsistent with rising share markets (in 2016 shares bottomed in February and bond yields didn't bottom till July/August) but it does highlight that the post-GFC environment of constrained growth and inflation and low rates remains alive and well.

  • The writer is head of investment strategy and chief economist, AMP Capital