FTX collapse: 5 angles for investors to consider in this crisis

    • FTX and its entities filed for protection under the US Chapter 11 regime. As a result, any court suit or arbitration claims made by investors against these FTX entities would likely be suspended in favour of the insolvency framework. 
Even if investors have a judgment sum or arbitration award against FTX, that could at best be a ticket to queue up in the insolvency process.
    • FTX and its entities filed for protection under the US Chapter 11 regime. As a result, any court suit or arbitration claims made by investors against these FTX entities would likely be suspended in favour of the insolvency framework. Even if investors have a judgment sum or arbitration award against FTX, that could at best be a ticket to queue up in the insolvency process. PHOTO: AFP
    Published Mon, Nov 28, 2022 · 05:50 AM

    THERE have been previous downturns in the crypto assets markets, but the present crypto winter is arguably unprecedented in terms of the scale involved. The collapse of the world’s second-largest cryptocurrency exchange has sent shockwaves across the world and many investors are unsure where to turn to. 

    FTX Trading and its entities filed for protection under the US Chapter 11 regime. As a result, any court suit or arbitration claims made by investors against these FTX entities would likely be suspended in favour of the insolvency framework.

    Even if investors have a judgment sum or arbitration award against FTX, that could at best be a ticket to queue up in the insolvency process.

    At the same time, there are reports that the funds of FTX have been substantially depleted, with approximately US$1 billion of customer funds unaccounted for. The mysterious hack which drained US$650 million worth of crypto assets from FTX wallets in the immediate hours after the Chapter 11 filing did not help. Bahamas-based FTX Digital Markets (FDM) filed for bankruptcy protection in the US on Nov 16 this year.

    One may not be too hopeful of getting substantial returns, if any at all, from queuing up in the insolvency process. No doubt the situation is dire, but that does not necessarily mean that there are no more options for investors.

    1. US class action 

    A class action lawsuit has been launched in Florida by investors against FTX’s former chief executive Samuel Bankman-Fried (SBF), who is not known to have personally filed for bankruptcy himself. Interestingly, several third parties including celebrities alleged to have helped promote FTX are also joined as defendants to the class action.

    The suit alleges that FTX was a Ponzi house of cards which “shuffled customer funds between their opaque affiliated entities, using new investor funds obtained through investments in the yield-bearing accounts and loans to pay interest to the old ones and to attempt to maintain the appearance of liquidity”. The promoters were alleged to have helped FTX raise funds and drove users to invest in FTX’s accounts.

    It remains to be seen how the class action will transpire, and there could be more such class actions to come still. There could be strategic advantages in initiating action in different states. For example, the laws in some states may have robust disclosure rules or could present unique opportunities to compulsorily acquire information from items owned by SBF or via his affiliates.

    2. Recourse against affiliated parties?

    The leaked balance sheets of Alameda revealed that out of its US$14.6 billion assets, Alameda’s single-largest asset was US$3.6 billion worth of “unlocked FTT”, akin to a reserve pool of native tokens issued by FTX. There was in addition approximately US$2.16 billion worth of assets that are “FTT collateral”. FTT constitutes at least US$292 million of Alameda’s US$8 billion liabilities. At the same time, FTX the exchange had approximately US$9 billion in liabilities with just over US$1 billion in liquid assets.

    FTT tokens are effectively akin to digital money printed by FTX, the value of which is uncertain. At the same time, FTT is an illiquid asset, with FTX and Alameda being the largest holders of these tokens.

    In these circumstances, with FTX issuing FTT and giving loans in FTT to Alameda, only to use FTT itself as collateral for those loans, the end result was ostensibly a hyperinflation of FTT and a gross overvaluation of FTX.

    In total, FTX directed approximately US$10 billion in client funds to Alameda to help bolster its investments. At least US$1 billion of those funds is reportedly still missing since the collapse.

    The circumstances give rise to serious questions around the potential responsibility of those who may have charge over these transactions and arrangements. In this regard, investors may consider pursuing action against affiliated parties where there is evidence of wrongdoing involved, in claims of interference of the investors’ economic rights, inducement of FTX’s breaches of contract owed to investors, and negligence.

    3. International arbitration 

    Clause 38.12 of the FTX user terms provide for any dispute to be resolved by international arbitration seated in Singapore and administered by the Singapore International Arbitration Centre (SIAC), while clause 27.8 expressly provides for the increasingly popular and internationally recognised SIAC emergency arbitration mechanism to be used.

    Investors could, with the consent of the defendants that they are seeking recourse from, look to resolve their disputes via international arbitration. This is a private and confidential process where only the parties to the dispute can participate in, without the scrutiny of the media and non-parties. Parties have flexibility to agree on the process and rules in the arbitration. An international arbitration award is internationally enforceable in over 150 countries worldwide under the New York Convention.

    4. Investor state considerations

    FDM, the parent company of FTX, is a Bahamas entity. It is unclear to what extent the Bahamas authorities had the opportunity to look into the problematic financial statements and questionable transactions orchestrated around FTX entities pre-crisis. The events that happened post collapse unfortunately did not help make things clearer.

    FTX released a statement stating that their accounts have been frozen by the Bahamian authorities, but withdrawals by Bahamas-registered accounts should be allowed.

    This created a loophole where investors reportedly attempted to seek the help of Bahamians to withdraw funds, including paying owners of Bahamian accounts to withdraw funds, and bribing FTX employees to change the investors’ “know your customer” information in Bahamas. The Securities Commission of the Bahamas later issued a statement to contradict FTX’s statement, noting that the transactions could be unauthorised.

    The Bahamas provisional liquidator appointed by the Bahamas Supreme Court has also publicly commented that FTX was not authorised to file for bankruptcy in the US, taking the position that the assets of all FTX affiliates fall under the umbrella of FDM, which is a Bahamian entity and should consequently be administered under Bahamian law.

    FTX, in court documents filed in the US, accused the government of Bahamas of ordering SBF to hack FTX’s systems to transfer hundreds of millions of dollars of crypto from FTX to a wallet controlled by the Securities Commission of The Bahamas. The Bahamas Securities Commission denied these allegations and asserted its right to preserve digital assets to safeguard the interests of FDM’s creditors.

    5. Freezing of assets

    About US$650 million worth of crypto assets was mysteriously hacked and dissipated away from FTX. It is possible with the assistance of forensic on-chain analysts to trace the movement of digital assets on the blockchain. It is also possible to obtain worldwide freezing orders against the wallets of these unidentified hackers to attempt to put a stop to any further dissipation.

    There is a precedent from the Singapore Courts where freezing orders have been granted against unknown actors who were alleged to have carried out or participated in the theft of Bitcoin and Ethereum valued to be in excess of US$7 million. The Singapore Court orders prohibited unknown actors from dealing with the stolen cryptocurrency assets. Likewise, the England Courts have recently granted restraining orders against unknown hackers who had misappropriated digital assets from the victim’s crypto wallet.

    The writer is a partner in the international arbitration and litigation team at Withers KhattarWong.