[NEW YORK] Families of US citizens murdered by drug gangs in Mexico sued HSBC Holdings Plc, claiming the bank can be held responsible for the deaths because it let cartels launder billions of dollars to operate their businesses.
The lawsuit brings fresh scrutiny to the Mexican activities of HSBC, which in 2012 paid US$1.9 billion to resolve a criminal investigation into whether it violated US sanctions laws and laundered at least US$881 million on behalf of drug cartels.
The new case, filed Tuesday in federal court in Brownsville, Texas, recounts a series of murders in 2010 and 2011 in horrific detail, arguing that the bank should be held to account for them under the US Anti-Terrorism Act.
The 1996 law, amended in the wake of Sept 11, allows victims to seek compensation from organisations that provide material support to groups that commit terrorist acts. Although other violent drug-trafficking organizations, such as the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC), have been designated by the US Government as terrorists, the Mexican drug cartels have so far avoided that official label. The Texas lawsuit seems to be the first that's based on the legal theory that the Mexican cartels are terrorist organizations.
Lesley Redelfs was four months pregnant when she and her husband, Arthur, were shot by the Juarez cartel after leaving a children's birthday party hosted by the US Consulate in Ciudad Juarez, where she worked. Jaime Zapata and Victor Avila Jr were special agents for Immigration and Customs Enforcement, driving to Mexico City when they were run off the road by two vehicles filled with hit men from the Los Zetas cartel, who then opened fire. Avila survived. Rafael Morales Jr was abducted on his wedding day, as were his brother and uncle, and the three died of asphyxiation after members of the Sinaloa cartel wrapped duct tape around their heads.
The lawsuit, filed by Richard Elias of Elias Gutzler Spicer LLC, draws on documents made public in 2012 as part of a US Senate investigation. The suit alleges HSBC's internal controls were ignored and that the bank was dubbed by one drug lord as "the place to launder money." The suit also alleges bank employees aided the cartels' laundering.
Mr Zapata's death drew particular public attention after it emerged that an automatic pistol used in the assault was traced to a gun-trafficking ring targeted by a US operation known as Fast and Furious, in which agents from the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives allowed guns to slip into Mexico in an effort to trace the flow of weapons.
HSBC already is among banks facing a lawsuit from families of US soldiers killed or injured by attacks in Iraq on accusations that the firms helped Iran process transfers and finance Hezbollah and other militant groups. Attorneys for banks including HSBC have denied wrongdoing. The plaintiffs in that case are pushing for the release of a report by HSBC's court-appointed monitor, Michael Cherkasky, detailing the bank's uneven efforts to fix its controls. A federal judge in Brooklyn last month said a redacted version of that document should be made public.
The bank and the government have appealed that order, and the judge said Tuesday he is not likely to make the report public until a higher court weighs in.