You are here
US banks' dismal first quarter may spell trouble for 2016
[NEW YORK] It is only April, but some on Wall Street are already predicting a rotten 2016 for US banks.
Analysts say it has been the worst start to the year since the financial crisis in 2007-2008 and expect poor first-quarter results when reporting begins this week.
Concerns about economic growth in China, the impact of persistently low oil prices on the energy sector, and near-zero interest rates are weighing on capital markets activity as well as loan growth.
Analysts forecast a 20 per cent decline on average in earnings from the six biggest US banks, according to Thomson Reuters data. Some banks, including Goldman Sachs Group Inc, are expected to report the worst results in over ten years.
This spells trouble for the financial sector more broadly, since banks typically generate at least a third of their annual revenue during the first three months of the year.
"What's concerning people is they're saying, 'Is this going to spill over into other quarters?'" Goldman's lead banking analyst Richard Ramsden said in an interview. "If you do have a significant decline in revenues, there is a limit to how much you can cut costs to keep things in equilibrium."
Investors will get some insight on Wednesday, when earnings season kicks off with JPMorgan Chase & Co, the country's largest bank. That will be followed by Bank of America Corp and Wells Fargo & Co on Thursday, Citigroup Inc on Friday, and Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs Group Inc on Monday and Tuesday, respectively, in the following week.
Banks have been struggling to generate more revenue for years, while adapting to a panoply of new regulations that have raised the cost of doing business substantially.
The biggest challenge has been fixed-income trading, where heavy capital requirements, new derivatives rules, and restrictions on proprietary trading have made it less profitable, leading most banks to simply shrink the business.
Bank executives have already warned investors to expect major declines across other areas as well.
Citigroup Inc CFO John Gerspach said to expect trading revenue more broadly to drop 15 per cent versus the first quarter of last year. JPMorgan Chase & Co's Daniel Pinto said to expect a 25 per cent decline in investment banking. Several bank executives have warned about declining quality of energy sector loans.
Global investment banking fees for completed merger and acquisitions, and stock and bond underwriting, totaled US$15.6 billion in the first quarter, a 28 per cent decline for the year-ago period, according to Thomson Reuters data.
Volatility in stock prices and plunging commodities prices caused trading volume to dry up during most of the quarter. Trading activity picked up slightly in March but was not strong enough to offset declines during the first two months of the year.
Analysts have been lowering first-quarter estimates over the last month in light of business pressures. They now expect JPMorgan to report adjusted earnings of US$1.30 per share, Bank of America to report 24 cents per share, Wells Fargo to report 99 cents per share, Citigroup to report US$1.11 per share, and Morgan Stanley to report 63 cents per share. Goldman is expected to report US$3.00 per share, the lowest first-quarter earnings since before the financial crisis.
Matt Burnell, a Wells Fargo banking analyst, said in a research note Friday that capital markets weakness may extend at least into the second quarter.
Analysts said there may be some loan growth outside of the energy sector, and a small uptick in net interest margins, a measure of loan profitability, but overall, the tone was less-than-optimistic.
"The first quarter is going to be ugly and we don't think that necessarily gets recovered in the back half of the year,"said Jerry Braakman, chief investment officer of First American Trust, which owns shares of Citigroup, JPMorgan, Wells Fargo and Goldman. "There are a lot of challenges ahead."