You are here

France defies EU partners with "no austerity" budget

[PARIS] France laid down the gauntlet to EU partners on Wednesday with a 2015 budget setting out how it would bring its borrowing back to within EU limits two years later than promised, a retreat it blamed on a fragile economy.

Without specifically naming France, German Chancellor Angela Merkel quickly stressed that rebuilding sound public finances could not be taken lightly.

The announcement from Paris came hours after news that Italy too planned to ease the pace of painful deficit reduction to try to counter another year of recession. "We have taken the decision to adapt the pace of deficit reduction to the economic situation of the country," French Finance Minister Michel Sapin told a news conference. "Our economic policy is not changing, but the deficit will be reduced more slowly than planned due to economic circumstances - very weak growth and very weak inflation." Under the French budget plan, the public deficit is set to fall from 4.4 per cent of output this year to 4.3 per cent next year, 3.8 per cent in 2016 and 2.8 per cent in 2017 - below the European Union-mandated threshold of 3 percent.

Previously, France had promised EU partners it would bring its deficit below 3 percent by next year, a deadline that had already been extended from 2013. France's spending watchdog doubted even the new targets could be reached. "No further effort will be demanded of the French, because the government - while taking the fiscal responsibility needed to put the country on the right track - rejects austerity," the budget statement said.

Austerity or not, Merkel said sustainable economic growth could only be built on the foundation of solid public finances. "We are not at the point where we can say the crisis is fully behind us. Therefore, it is now important for everyone to fulfill their commitments and obligations in a credible way,"she told a business conference in Berlin.

There was no immediate comment from other EU governments but Germany's main exporters' association, the BGA, accused France of putting the euro and the wider regional economy at risk. "If that country doesn't figure a way out of the downward spiral, the euro and therefore Europe are at risk," BGA president Anton Boerner said, according to the text of a speech due for delivery at a conference in Berlin.

President Francois Hollande is resisting pressure from some in his Socialist Party to ease off even more emphatically on cutbacks but also has to contend with an approval rating at a record low 13 per cent. A week ago, conservative former president Nicolas Sarkozy, the man he beat in the 2012 election, announced he was making a return to frontline politics.

Sapin, who this month conceded the 2015 deficit target was untenable, reaffirmed forecasts that the euro zone's second largest economy would grow at a modest 1.0 per cent next year, rising to 1.9 percent in 2017.

Despite the government's decision to lower its sights, the country's independent public finances watchdog, the High Council of Public Finances, said the revised projections still looked optimistic as far as 2016 and 2017 were concerned.

The government described its effort to shave 50 billion euros off projected public spending volumes between now and 2017 as "unprecedented" - while acknowledging the total volume of public spending would still rise by 0.2 per cent over the period.

That would imply public debt ticking up to a peak of 98.0 per cent of output in 2016 before a slight fall in 2017. French public spending and the total tax burden - among the highest in the world - would fall only modestly as a result.

A wave of debt issued during the financial crisis will need to be refinanced next year, pushing bond issuance back to a record 188 billion euros, the public debt agency said.

The structural deficit, a figure closely watched by EU budget watchdogs as it strips out the effects of the economic cycle, will fall less than hoped by France's partners, from 2.2 per cent of output in 2015 to 1.4 per cent in 2017.

Barclays' France economist Francois Cabau said the government would try to sell the overshoot to Brussels on the questionable use of a new methodology of calculation.

Incoming European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker is now under pressure to react firmly enough to avoid a further loss of confidence in the bloc's already battered budget rulebook. Among his options are sanctions including hefty fines.

The European Commission, where Sapin's predecessor Pierre Moscovici has just been named Commissioner tasked with keeping tabs on respect for EU budget rules, declined immediate comment in the wake of the budget bill presentation in Paris.

Advocates of budgetary rigour led by Germany believe the time has come for France to taste some of the fiscal austerity and painful structural reform already undertaken by its southern neighbours in the wake of the 2009-2012 debt crisis.

But Paris can count on allies in Rome, Athens, Dublin, Madrid and elsewhere to support its argument that further austerity would be counterproductive, snuffing out the fragile start of recovery across the euro zone.

Italian Finance Minister Pier Carlo Padoan said on Tuesday he expected a third straight year of recession in 2014. While Rome would honour a pledge to cut its deficit to the 3 per cent EU target in 2014, bringing the budget into balance in structural terms would be delayed by a year until 2017, he said.

Hollande has charged Sapin and Prime Minister Manuel Valls with imposing spending caps on individual ministries and Sapin said he would recoup a further 4 billion euros in French public asset sales to pay off debt.

In a bid to return some cash to the pockets of low-earners, the budget will also cancel the existing lowest income tax band - a move to be funded with tax proceeds elsewhere.

Despite its fiscal woes, France continues to borrow at historically low rates - the yield on its benchmark 10-year bond was unchanged around 1.289 per cent in early Wednesday trade.

In an interview with Les Echos newspaper, former conservative Prime Minister Francois Fillon - a possible presidential candidate in 2017 - warned nonetheless that France was "on the verge of serious financial accident". - Reuters