You are here

Hedge-fund copycats rally as academics defend embattled strategy

[HONG KONG] Investing products designed to bring hedge-fund strategies to the masses are on course for one of their best months in more than a decade, as the latest research argues the oft-maligned trades have robust foundations.

So-called liquid alternatives mimic the fast money through short selling, leverage and derivatives in order to capture popular sources of market returns known as risk premia. Yet they have underperformed both hedge funds and 60/40 portfolios over the past decade - and look set to do so again this year.

But as the pandemic roller coaster continues, a gauge tracking hedge-fund clones is up 2.3 per cent in November to the highest in nine months. That follows its outperformance in the March maelstrom and the biggest jump in the index's 13-year history a month later in the global market rebound.

The rally comes as a study shows these public instruments can successfully replicate trades beloved by the most sophisticated institutional managers - with much lower fees.

In a paper published last month, researchers from the National University of Singapore (NUS) found liquid alternatives had broadly matched hedge-fund returns, including stock market beta and factors like value and momentum. Their relative strength during the coronavirus slump shows it's "probably premature" to dismiss replication strategies, they said.

Your feedback is important to us

Tell us what you think. Email us at

"We see value in the hedge fund strategy clones constructed in this study, with most of them outperforming their respective region's market benchmarks during the Covid-19 crisis," wrote authors Joseph Cherian, Christine Kon and Ziyun Li.

The HFRI-I Liquid Alternative UCITS Index fell 5.6 per cent in March, compared with a 5.9 per cent drop for a global hedge-fund gauge and 12.5 per cent slump for the S&P 500.

However, while liquid alternatives have a track record of outperformance during major selloffs, in the long term they have struggled to keep pace with hedge funds and have badly lagged the US equity benchmark.

For all the performance worries, Greenwich Associates estimated there were some US$882 billion of institutional assets invested in the sector as at the end of last year. Exchange-traded funds following the strategies hold record assets and have attracted cash every month since March, Bloomberg data shows.

Liquid alternatives are a "good place to park your money while you wait for a better investment opportunity", said Olivier d'Assier, head of applied research for the Asia-Pacific at Qontigo. However, the "window appears to have closed now with optimism rising again thanks to news on upcoming vaccine and the result of the US election", he said.

The liquid alternatives label is used for an array of structures and styles, and within that performance can vary significantly. The NUS researchers found that, during the Covid crash, the clones had an advantage over arbitrage, CTA/managed futures, macro, multi-strategy and event-driven funds in North America, and in long-short equity in Asia.


BT is now on Telegram!

For daily updates on weekdays and specially selected content for the weekend. Subscribe to