How likely is it that par products' bonus rates will be affected?
One gauge is to compare insurer's allowance of provision for par fund's non-guaranteed benefits with total assets
Singapore
FROM time to time, participating (par) insurance policyholders complain that the bonuses they receive or the final payouts are much lower than the projected returns listed in the benefit illustrations.
In the face of the impending risk-based capital framework (RBC 2), how likely is it that par products' bonus rates will be affected?
One quick gauge of how much financial resources a life insurer has available to support bonus payouts is to look at its policy liabilities less minimum condition liability, also referred to as its allowance of provision for non-guaranteed benefits of a par fund, said an actuary who declined to be named.
By comparing this buffer against shocks for insurers to honour guaranteed benefits, with their total assets, the crude measure will show how much reserve the insurers have left to fund future non-guaranteed benefits, including future reversionary bonuses and terminal bonuses.
Based on 2013 regulatory filings available on the Monetary Authority of Singapore's (MAS) website, Prudential, for example, had a reserve buffer of S$6.27 billion. Its total assets for that year were S$13.6 billion. The higher the proportion of this buffer out of the insurer's total assets, the more excess the insurer has available to fund future non-guaranteed obligations.
This would also mean that the chances of being forced into a bonus restructure or bonus rate cut when RBC 2 is implemented are lower.
Trailing behind were Aviva Singapore, Tokio Marine Life, Manulife Singapore, AIA Singapore, Great Eastern Life, NTUC Income, HSBC Insurance and AXA Life Singapore.
Between 2011 and 2013, five of the nine insurers - AIA, Aviva, Manulife, Prudential and Tokio Marine Life - managed to maintain their proportion of allowance buffer at one-third of their total assets at least.
The data showed that Tokio Marine Life's allowance buffer slid three consecutive years to about 40 per cent of its total assets in 2013, from 44 per cent in 2011.
AXA Life had the least of such a reserve buffer at 7 per cent in 2011, 11 per cent in 2012, and 8 per cent in 2013.
AXA Life said the level of provision for non-guaranteed benefits depends on a few things, including the length of time a life insurer has been selling par business (the ageing of the par fund) as well as the level of guaranteed compared to non-guaranteed benefits in the plans sold by a life insurer.
It said that, since 2009, it has been growing its provision for non-guaranteed benefits as a proportion of total assets "at a faster rate than most of the major par life insurers".
"In the case of our par plans, we see guaranteed benefits as important for our customers, particularly learning from previous experiences where insurance customers have generally seen actual benefits lower than projected benefits, primarily due to falling investment returns in the 1990s to 2000," AXA Life said. "We now try to have a higher degree of guarantees in our par plans as a proportion of total benefits. By definition, today, we have less of a need to have very high proportions of provision for non-guaranteed benefits as a percentage of total assets."
The insurer said the amount of reserves it sets aside are "monitored regularly".
"The reserves we set up in the past according to our business needs do not say much about the reserves we will set in the future and do not impact our ability to strengthen our reserves if we are required to," said AXA Life, which added that one cannot refer to past provisions made by an insurer and draw conclusions about an insurer's ability to make future provisions should regulatory requirements change.
Even so, AXA Life noted that non-guaranteed benefits are commonly backed by equities or higher-yielding and riskier assets, and this may have an impact on future benefit designs of life insurers, which in turn affect how insurers put aside provisions.
NTUC Income's chief actuary, Lau Sok Hoon, said: "Focusing on the reserves that insurers set aside to fund future non-guaranteed benefits does not reflect their ability to pay bonuses nor the overall returns to their customers. It also ignores what they set aside to fund guaranteed benefits." She added that policyholders should look at both guaranteed and non-guaranteed benefits to determine the overall returns that an insurer pays out.
In its September 2014 report on Singapore's par business, actuarial services provider Milliman said it expected greater volatility in terminal bonuses, as companies might be expected to use them to manage the distribution of more volatile sources of surplus, including investment returns from equities.
Data from 2005 to 2012 showed a steady decrease in regular bonuses and a gradual movement in bonus philosophy from regular to terminal, it said. "This shift could indicate that companies view the level of guaranteed benefits as becoming too expensive in the current interest rate environment, so are distributing a greater proportion of the profits through terminal bonuses which are not guaranteed in advance."
The report added that there could also be an element of managing policyholders' reasonable expectations, to demonstrate that future bonus rates can be cut and are not guaranteed to persist at current levels.
Having said that, MAS has issued guidelines that require the insurer to declare its bonuses fairly and equitably, to meet the "reasonable expectation" of the policyholder, to prevent abuses.
Returns filed by life insurers over eight years from 2006 to 2013 showed that, generally, par funds have grown, with the par funds ranging from S$431 million to S$24 billion in 2013.
Richard Holloway, managing director of Milliman's South-East Asia and India life insurance consulting team, said post-global financial crisis, par business has grown as consumers see value in the guarantees that par products provide.
He added that par funds also grew as a result of the combination of new business, premium income on existing business and investment income, with these factors outstripping claims and expenses.
Under RBC 2, life insurers might be more inclined to move to non-par products that are not as capital-intensive, but insurers and other observers have noted that such a development would be detrimental to the sector.
READ MORE: Par policies could yield lower bonuses with new risk-based capital framework
TRENDING NOW
Ex-Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang carried a secret for more than a year. It led to his downfall
Higher rates, weaker spending: Is the Philippines entering stagflation?
Nuclear potential, data centre boom may be addressed in new Asean energy master plan
Demand, tech capabilities position Apac and AI as Skyscanner’s next growth frontiers: CEO Bryan Batista