Will banks' courtships end in marriage?
Singapore banks weigh true cost of taking a minority stake under the new digital banking licence setup
Singapore
THE dating frenzy amid the digital banking buzz in Singapore has also hit the three banking incumbents in Singapore, with the lenders understood to have been in talks with digital banking aspirants.
While indicative first dates may have been put on the table, there remains a more salient question of just how keen Singapore banks are to come together with non-banking entities, in the first place.
To be clear, Singapore banks do not need to apply for a digital banking licence. Since 2000, Singapore banks have been able to set up digital bank subsidiaries, either by themselves, or with joint venture partners where the Singapore banks retain control.
But one difference sticking out for now is that Singapore banks are free to take a minority stake under the new digital banking licence setup.
The speed-dating between banks and non-bank entities comes as there are a few elements that have to be considered for these new entrants into banking.
For one thing, there are only five licences up for grabs, with the terms suggesting that any new player must bring in a sustainable business model that targets an underserved segment.
The maximum of five new digital-bank licences to be issued in time will comprise up to two digital full-bank licences, and up to three digital wholesale bank licences. They must all meet the same capital requirements as local banks.
At the first stage, the digital non-wholesale bank - that is, the digital full bank - will operate as a restricted bank. This restricted digital full bank will have an initial paid-up capital of S$15 million. Aggregate deposits will be capped at S$50 million and individual deposits will be capped at S$75,000. To add, the bank can only accept deposits from a small group of persons such as business partners, staff, and related parties.
Once the Monetary Authority of Singapore lifts restrictions, a graduated bank will need to meet the minimum paid-up capital requirement of S$1.5 billion, and face the same liquidity requirements as local banks. The S$50 million cap in deposits will be increased then, too.
Aspiring digital banks are looking to get their hands on cheap deposits, but in order to do so, they need to cross the credibility hurdle. Being backed by a credible name can bolster confidence among retail depositors, BT understands.
Wong Nai Seng, South-east Asia Leader for the Deloitte APAC Centre for Regulatory Strategy, told BT that well-managed partnerships between banks and non-banks can generate multiple benefits for a new digital bank.
"The banks can contribute their financial knowledge and expertise in risk management and compliance. They can also provide a ready pool of talented staff to help jump start the operations of a digital bank."
Still, for just a minority stake, banks would need to weigh the costs beyond the actual dollars, specifically if they are there to just fulfil the compliance standards behind banking, and lend their buttoned-up face of credibility.
"I think many of these new players underestimate the (compliance) standards," said a senior banker at a Singapore bank, pointing out that many of these new entrants are in for a rude shock at how onerous the rules behind banking can be.
Another senior banker from a large foreign bank here noted the same, arguing that digital upstarts are knocking on banks' doors looking to partner up so that due diligence in the areas of anti-money laundering and know-your-customer standards can effectively be "outsourced" to the traditional lenders.
He noted the examples seen in China, where traditional lenders are effectively having to do the same to partner up with digital banks that have successfully garnered enough of a customer base to drive a harder bargain with traditional lenders.
"The traditional banks (in China) have no choice now," said this banker, though adding that China is unique as regulations are tightening, moving in some ways in a different direction for digital banking in other regional markets.
OCBC has said it has no plans to build a standalone digital bank, and is open to partnerships. In response to a Bloomberg report on a potential partnership between OCBC and Singtel, Citi analyst Robert Kong said the upside for the bank remains in finding a partner that would help it penetrate regional markets. "We do not see much upside in a standalone digital bank solely to service Singapore, given the strict scope and capital requirements laid out by the MAS," said Mr Kong in a report.
"The value of a strong partner would be in the extensive customer base it allows OCBC to tap. OCBC has the technology, the balance sheet and the operations and risk management expertise to support the establishment of a standalone digital bank much as its peers have already done," he added. "OCBC falls short in terms of extending its customer reach, particularly in the case of Indonesia, which is considered a core growth market."
When asked how UOB would approach the digital banking licence, UOB's chief Wee Ee Cheong said during the bank's Q2 results briefing that the bank is confident in serving customers in Singapore "without the digital initiative" at this point in time.
UOB has also launched a standalone digital bank, TMRW, in Thailand, and is expected to launch the same in Vietnam or Indonesia in the next few months.
"Anytime, we can always bring that (business model) in," said Mr Wee, referring to TMRW being launched in Singapore.
A UOB spokesman would only say this week that the bank remains "open to collaborating with like-minded partners to create solutions relevant to the needs of consumers and businesses".
DBS, which has a standalone digital bank in India and Indonesia, said the bank has been focused on "reimagining banking". "This includes seamlessly integrating banking into the lives of customers, making banking invisible. We constantly review various options that will enhance this customer proposition," said a spokesman.
READ MORE:
TRENDING NOW
Motoring tycoon Peter Kwee is back in court: Here are his previous legal battles
Demand, tech capabilities position Apac and AI as Skyscanner’s next growth frontiers: CEO Bryan Batista
Beyond the greenback, Vietnam’s big borrowers turn to Asian-currency bonds
Nvidia’s outlook cut to stable by Moody’s on governance concerns