ESG CHALLENGE

As ESG awareness grows, experts weigh in on where to put your cash

Investors should look beyond the 'E' of ESG, and also take into account companies' social characteristics, including equity and inclusion practices, they say

Michelle Quah
Published Wed, Dec 22, 2021 · 09:50 PM

    Singapore

    THANKS to the recent global climate summit, COP26, the world's focus on climate change mitigation and sustainability has intensified. For investors, the ambitious pledges by governments to avert a looming climate crisis mean a burgeoning of green finance and investing.

    "For investors focused on sustainability, 2021 was a year dominated by the run-up to and takeaways from November's COP26 climate change negotiations," said Tan Jenn-Hui, global head of stewardship and sustainable investing at Fidelity International.

    "But the true test is just beginning now: What actions will countries take to deliver on their pledges, not only in terms of emission cuts but in preserving our biological diversity and ensuring a fair and equitable transition to a low carbon world?"

    Green financing will play a key - though, not sole - role in enabling this transition.

    Cherine Fok, director, sustainability services and KPMG IMPACT, at global professional services firm KPMG in Singapore, pointed out that, while governments have committed to spending up to US$100 billion in climate finance annually, private sector finance will be needed to fund the technology and innovation required to support a comprehensive economic transition that will help the world achieve its net-zero goal.

    The net-zero goal is reached when carbon emissions produced are either offset or absorbed such that the net amount emitted is effectively zero.

    Alexandre Tavazzi, global strategist, head of CIO office & CIO Asia at international wealth manager Pictet Wealth Management, said pledges alone will not bring emissions down to net-zero.

    "To reach the net-zero target would take a massive increase in capital spending that amounts to an annual US$3.5 trillion, or close to 20 per cent of the world's yearly capital investment, more than the annual entire capital spending of the US."

    Gilly Hutchinson, head of ESG Regional Development, Asia, at multinational law firm Linklaters, said this represents a 3-fold increase in transition-related investment over the coming decade: "The investment needed to develop, scale up and deploy clean energy technologies is significant."

    Green investment opportunities

    Copious opportunities are expected for investors focused on environmental, social and governance (ESG) issues. Most of the interest is likely to centre on investments related to renewable energy and decarbonisation, and in electric vehicles (EVs) and batteries.

    Observers warn, however, that these obvious targets may not represent the best bet.

    David Smith, senior investment director, Asian equities, at global asset manager abrdn, said investments related to renewable energy and decarbonisation will be the most enthusiastically pursued in the near term.

    "China dominates this space, particularly (in terms of) solar (energy), and so for Asia-focused investors this is an area of interest. But it can be a volatile space and investors need to be active in the way they evaluate the value chain."

    He believes investors should also look to other areas, such as enabling technologies, storage, grid technology, EV components and energy efficiency. "Focusing on one narrow area risks missing a broad opportunity set," he added.

    Martin Hennecke, Asia investment director at multinational wealth management business St James's Place Wealth Management, noted particularly high growth in EVs and associated industries such as battery production, but added: "This doesn't mean that these areas should be attractive for investors. In fact, the areas receiving the most positive news coverage, and that are anticipated to grow by everyone, might turn out to be higher risk and less rewarding for investors than anticipated for two reasons.

    "First, if the positives are known by everyone and well covered in the media, attracting great interest, prices/valuations of companies operating in this space may already reflect this and trade at high levels. Second, new entrants are being attracted into the market as well to cash in on investor interest, which can pressure profit margins even in high growth markets."

    He said investors should not overlook areas that might attract less interest yet still play an important positive role, while offering potentially more attractive risk-return profiles when fundamental balance sheet and due diligence analysis has been professionally performed.

    "From an investment side return and risk perspective as well, wide diversification is recommended and in a way that includes considerations on markets, sectors and especially companies that have been receiving relatively less investor attention and are lesser known."

    Helena Fung, head of sustainable investment, Asia-Pacific, at FTSE Russell, a subsidiary of London Stock Exchange Group, said: "Over time, we expect investors to widen their definition of environmentally sustainable investments and take a broader view of the contribution that issuers make towards identifying less carbon intensive solutions."

    Investors should also look beyond the "E" in ESG.

    Craig Cameron, portfolio manager of the Templeton Global Climate Change Fund, at multinational asset manager Franklin Templeton, believes the market still under-appreciates the social characteristics of companies: "(We) expect this to receive greater focus from investors in future, potentially becoming a meaningful source of differentiation among companies."

    KPMG's Fok agreed, saying that the social topics of equity and inclusion practices, in particular, will attract much attention, especially as the pandemic widens the social gap across income sectors and countries.

    In terms of products, Linklaters partner Denise Fung pointed out that, within Asia, China leads in terms of volume of ESG bond issuances, followed closely by South Korea, Japan and India. "Although European markets currently lead global sustainability-linked loan volumes, green and sustainability-linked loans are also attracting noticeable attention in Asia, and the trend looks set to continue on an upward trajectory."

    Dissonance hurts potential

    Investors must also be aware of the challenges that lie ahead.

    Paul Tan, partner & head of litigation for South-east Asia at Singapore law firm Cavenagh Law, told The Business Times that the current lack of consistent or harmonised definitions of green activities, monitoring and compliance means green financing will take some time to realise its true potential.

    Chua Soon Ghee, senior partner at global management consulting firm Kearney, added that robust and regulated mechanisms are needed to ensure money flows efficiently to where it is needed.

    FTSE Russell's Fung said: "Technological developments around climate change, both in terms of impact measurement and real economy solutions, are new and developing.

    "Many of the models that are being used to quantify climate risk are based on estimates and there are often variations in the accuracy of models. Missing data for private companies, in particular, which are not subject to the same disclosure frameworks as listed companies, is an area of complexity.

    "In addition, while there has been significant focus on taxonomy by individual regulators, complemented by regional activity, for example in Asean and Europe, creating interoperable and harmonised frameworks for green activities and investments which encourages and incentivises cross border capital flows still requires more work."

    Rong Ren Goh, portfolio manager of the fixed income team at Prudential's Asian asset management business Eastspring Investments, agrees: "There is no standardised definition of a 'good' or 'bad' ESG investment, where interpretations can vary widely among ESG data providers or asset managers with proprietary evaluation frameworks.

    "ESG data sets remain incomplete and inconsistent, and at times could be inaccurate, which could impair informed analysis," he said, adding that this could improve in time thanks to the recent establishment of the International Sustainability Standards Board.

    Rong said regulation and policy will also help to align private-sector incentives with net-zero commitments made by national governments. An efficient and transparent carbon-pricing model, to effectively cost emissions, would also be a key part of the solution.

    St James's Place Wealth Management's Hennecke is of a similar view: "The development of carbon markets, including voluntary carbon trading, can play an important role.

    "There is still some work needed for harmonisation of regulatory standards, especially with recent growth and new developments taking place in this space globally, but it's looking positive so far, particularly in China where carbon exchanges were launched only this year."

    Greenwashing pitfalls

    Another challenge is the continued presence of greenwashing.

    Kearney's Chua defined greenwashing as when a company's declaration of environmentally friendly initiatives and measures are either untrue or exaggerated.

    "The related challenge and pitfall is that of actually measuring carbon impact and achieving net-zero pledges - most companies are still trying to measure their own emissions and usage (Scope 1 and 2), and will have big challenges in measuring the carbon impact of their suppliers (Scope 3). We expect some of these pitfalls to be addressed in the coming years as there is greater scrutiny, maturity and sophistication built up in the ESG sector."

    Linklaters' Fung noted that investors and regulators across the region, including in Hong Kong, Singapore, Taiwan, and Japan, have signalled their concerns that the mis-selling of green investment products poses a significant challenge to true sustainable investing.

    Cavenagh Law's Tan said there are risks for companies as well, which may be liable for claims in misrepresentation or mis-selling if their publicity material or prospectuses are unclear or misleading.

    "These risks are magnified because there isn't yet consistent and uniform and mandatory regulation of ESG funds or standards. In this regard, the MAS (Monetary Authority of Singapore) has announced that it will roll out regulatory expectations on disclosure standards that retail funds in Singapore with an ESG investment objective must meet - I think this is a major step in the right direction. It will hopefully give companies some certainty as to their obligations, but also investors some measure of confidence."

    In the meantime, investors ought to acquaint themselves with the risks and make an effort to examine an investment target's track record. "It is important to consider a company's trajectory over time on a range of ESG issues rather than just looking at one point in time. This helps investors to understand which companies are truly demonstrating an understanding of the issues and taking action to improve their business - be that on carbon emissions, gender diversity or board independence," said Franklin Templeton's Cameron.

    The quality of business leadership is also important, and investors can watch out for a few indicators, said KPMG's Fok. "The first is the extent of working knowledge of the frameworks and ratings most relevant to the company and how the company is currently tracking it. The second is the ability of business leaders to articulate the company's leading climate issues and how they are linked to strategy. The third is the robustness of processes and controls for the collection and communication of climate-related data. Finally, investors have to look for any disconnect between the company's statements and conducts."

    Smith of abrdn added that investors also need to be aware of rapidly changing policy agendas globally: "Whilst the direction of travel around decarbonisation is clear, the path to the goal will zig and zag, particularly as policy approaches change."