UniCredit Bank’s US$37m claims against Glencore over Hin Leong’s transaction dismissed

Tay Peck Gek

Tay Peck Gek

Published Fri, Oct 21, 2022 · 01:18 PM
    • Hin Leong's founder Lim Oon Kuin has been charged with over 100 forgery-related offences involving billions of dollars of loans that were disbursed as a result of fraud he allegedly perpetrated against both local and international banks in Singapore.
    • Hin Leong's founder Lim Oon Kuin has been charged with over 100 forgery-related offences involving billions of dollars of loans that were disbursed as a result of fraud he allegedly perpetrated against both local and international banks in Singapore. PHOTO: BT FILE

    UNICREDIT Bank has lost its claims to recover US$37 million from Glencore Singapore in a transaction related to liquidated oil trader Hin Leong as Singapore’s High Court ruled that Glencore did not defraud or deceive the bank into issuing the letter of credit.

    Neither did the defendant conspire with Hin Leong to cause harm to the European commercial bank, nor was it unjustly enriched, Justice Andre Maniam wrote in a judgment published on Friday (Oct 21).

    UniCredit has contended that Glencore, having simultaneously bought back the goods it had sold Hin Leong, the natural resource company was fraudulent when it did not inform the bank about the buyback transaction.

    UniCredit granted Hin Leong an irrevocable letter of credit with a value of US$37.2 million to finance the purchase of some 150,000 metric tonnes of high-sulphur fuel oil from Glencore in late 2019. However, the company deceived the bank in the process about the sale status of the goods, keeping it under wraps from the bank that the oil had already been resold to Glencore.

    Hin Leong was put under interim judicial management in April 2020 and subsequently went into liquidation in March 2021. UniCredit thus found itself without repayment from Hin Leong, without the goods and without security over the goods.

    UniCredit, as Justice Maniam ruled, has not proven that Glencore and Hin Leong had a common intention of not performing the rights and obligations under the sale contract. Glencore had transferred its title to the goods to Hin Leong, and Hin Leong paid for the goods by getting UniCredit to issue the letter of credit, for which UniCredit paid Glencore.

    “Hin Leong could have resold the goods in various ways. Here, it was a simultaneous resale of the goods back to the seller, Glencore,” noted the judge, who added that a simultaneous sale-and-buyback arrangement may involve a genuine sale, and a genuine buyback.

    Glencore was not under any obligation to inform UniCredit about the buyback as the letter of credit did not require it to do so, stated the judge.

    There is nothing unjust in Glencore being paid on the letter of credit as it was legally entitled to that payment, having presented complying documents to UniCredit.