Cathay unseats Singapore Airlines as stock winner on travel revival

A REVERSAL in fortunes for shares of Cathay Pacific Airways and Singapore Airlines (SIA) may extend further, as Hong Kong’s flagship carrier springs back to life after years of pandemic restrictions.

A jump in “buy” recommendations in July for Cathay has pushed the ratio of bullish views to the most in more than a decade, thanks to cheap valuations and the prospect of a return to profit. Meanwhile, a flurry of downgrades since June due to valuation concerns has hurt sentiment for SIA.

The outlook for the battered Hong Kong carrier started to turn around following its profit forecast for the first six months of 2023. It is set to end a run of losses that were incurred as the airline buckled under the city’s harsh travel restrictions.

Cathay’s shares have started to outperform its rival’s in recent weeks, and may rebound further if its earnings – scheduled for Aug 9 – unleashes further positive momentum.

Cathay’s post-pandemic earnings power has been “underestimated” and there is “room for upward Street earnings revisions”, JPMorgan Chase & Co analysts including Karen Li wrote in a Jul 24 note.

The carrier preserving its leading market share in Hong Kong is a key positive, making it well-positioned to benefit from mainlanders’ long-haul transit flight demand, Li added.

Shares of Cathay have rallied 21 per cent since the start of June, making it the best performer among Asia peers and the first time that it has beat SIA for two consecutive months since December 2022. SIA, meanwhile, has risen 11 per cent in the period, even as its year-to-date gains have trounced Cathay.

Wall Street analysts have already taken a cue. JPMorgan and HSBC Holdings raised Cathay to the equivalent of “buy” from “neutral” last month, citing earnings growth on resilient travel demand. Meanwhile, Citigroup downgraded the Singapore carrier to “sell” from “buy” last month, saying the company’s positive earnings outlook is priced in.

Cathay is trading at a price-to-book ratio of 1.3 times, cheaper than SIA at 1.5 times, according to Bloomberg data. Analysts’ 12-month target price suggests 18 per cent upside for the former from its last closing price, while the latter is already trading above the consensus projection.

SEE ALSO

SIA’s elevated profitability won’t last forever

In new era of supersonic travel, a Singapore-London flight could take just five hours

There are some signs that Cathay’s rally may take a breather. Its shares were in overbought territory this week based on the 14-day relative strength index. The put-to-call ratio, which measures the level of interest in bearish options relative to bullish contracts, has started to edge higher after touching March lows.

But analysts betting on an earnings revival are optimistic. “We expect the carrier to deliver more positive surprises in the near-term as consensus estimates appear muted,” said DBS analyst Jason Sum. “We do expect more upside from here on.”