You are here

China's crackdown on kindergartens disastrous for their stocks

Beijing has lately put various sectors in its crosshairs, which has unnerved investors in a country rife with regulatory risk

Hong Kong

FIRST came the clampdown on shadow banks. Then it was gaming companies and drug-makers. Now education firms are in the Chinese government's crosshairs, roiling stocks and reminding investors how quickly their fortunes can change in a country rife with regulatory risk.

RYB Education Inc and Bright Scholar Education Holdings Ltd both took record plunges in US trading; Vtron Group Co and China Maple Leaf Educational Systems Ltd sank in Shenzhen and Hong Kong after the government unveiled new rules that prohibit companies from financing for-profit kindergartens via the equity market.

The losses echoed declines in Chinese peer-to-peer lenders, game-makers and pharmaceutical companies after regulators raised scrutiny of the industries this year.

While policy makers say the new rules are aimed at protecting consumers, they have taken investors by surprise. This is adding to the jitters in a US$5.8 trillion stock market already grappling with a trade war and the weakest economic expansion since 2009. China's benchmark Shanghai Composite Index has tumbled 19 per cent this year, one of the steepest declines worldwide.

Steven Leung, executive director at UOB Kay Hian (Hong Kong) Ltd, said: "The education sector had massive growth potential and was once red-hot among equity investors. It's a pity that the government is stepping up regulation. What's more annoying for a lot of sectors which rely heavily on the government is that you can't expect a timeline, and many sudden changes in policies are a surprise."

Chinese parents spend an average of US$42,892 on their children's education, almost double that of their counterparts in countries like Canada and the UK, said a 2017 report from HSBC Holdings Plc.

The potential for growth propelled shares of schooling firms to record highs as recently as June, with recently-listed China New Higher Education Group Ltd and China Education Group Holdings Ltd more than doubling in value in six months. Both fell at least 4.5 per cent in Hong Kong on Friday.

In new guidelines for the industry published late on Thursday, China's government said it wants to build more public kindergartens, and called for public institutions to educate half the nation's kindergarteners by 2020.

Credit Suisse Group AG analysts Alex Xie and Thomas Chong wrote in a note: "Policymakers were concerned about excessively profit-driven education that may cause social issues."

The move comes just a few months after Chinese regulators stopped approving new game licences, a decision that erased billions of market value from companies such as Tencent Holdings Ltd and NetEase Inc. The government is restructuring how it reviews video games amid concerns about addiction, myopia and other ills among the country's youth. Tencent said this week it was unable to provide further clarity on the approvals process, which has been the biggest drag on its revenue this year.

Only a year ago, RYB Education was at the centre child-abuse allegations, suspicions of which led to a teacher being fired from one of its schools and detained by the authorities. While Beijing police later said it found no evidence of impropriety, the stock never recovered after the investigation sparked fury on Chinese social media. BLOOMBERG

BT is now on Telegram!

For daily updates on weekdays and specially selected content for the weekend. Subscribe to