Bruised, Herbalife swings back at an accuser

Published Wed, Jun 3, 2015 · 09:50 PM

    New York

    THIS Wall Street brawl began with a billion-dollar bet.

    Then, William Ackman, the investor who landed the first blow with his bet against Herbalife, escalated the fight. He called the multibillion-dollar nutritional supplements company a "pyramid scheme", likening its practices to those of the mafia and the Nazis. Mr Ackman also lobbied federal authorities to bring Herbalife to its knees, an outcome that would reap a windfall for his hedge fund.

    That effort, it turns out, was only the first round. Now Herbalife, with deep pockets and well-connected political operatives and former prosecutors, is looking to turn the tables with its own no-holds-barred appeal to the government.

    Over the past year, Herbalife's lawyers have met in person five times with FBI agents, Securities and Exchange Commission investigators and federal prosecutors, according to people briefed on the meetings, partly to defend the company and partly to condemn Mr Ackman. Armed with stock charts, the lawyers argued that Mr Ackman's hedge fund, Pershing Square Capital Management, used false statements to manipulate Herbalife's stock downward.

    One of Herbalife's latest overtures came in April after Mr Ackman made a startling claim about Herbalife's senior management, saying, "We know they have been or are looking to hire criminal defence counsel." Mr Ackman attributed his assertion to an unnamed yet "reliable" source.

    Within 48 hours, Herbalife's lawyers phoned prosecutors from the US attorney's office in Manhattan to argue that his claims were not only false, they were illegal, people briefed on the call said. That same day, the lawyers called the SEC and in a follow-up letter to Andrew J Ceresney, the SEC's top enforcement official, they exhorted him to investigate Mr Ackman's source.

    This behind-the-scenes lobbying, detailed for the first time in interviews and in confidential documents reviewed by The New York Times, shows that after two years of Mr Ackman's walking the halls of Congress and entreating prosecutors, Herbalife is taking a section from his playbook. The counteroffensive - carried out by Democratic operatives, three public relations firms and two law firms stacked with former prosecutors - signals a critical moment in the battle. At this latest juncture, each side has now spent tens of millions of dollars shaping the public narrative - and the federal investigations.

    Justice Department investigators have subpoenaed and interviewed people who helped Pershing Square publicly attack Herbalife, according to the people briefed on the matter. Pershing Square, which denies wrongdoing, has produced documents for the government, but it has not received a subpoena.

    The investigators also contacted Herbalife and its distributors about Mr Ackman's accusations. Herbalife, which denies wrongdoing, faces inquiries from prosecutors, the Federal Trade Commission and the SEC.

    Yet the duelling narratives from Herbalife and Mr Ackman have thrust prosecutors and regulators into an uncomfortable position. The authorities are cautious about picking sides, according to people briefed on the matter, and privately conceded that the hurdles to mounting a case against either side were steep.

    Without government action, a resolution of the fight between Mr Ackman and Herbalife is unclear. And as each side pulls the levers of power, escalating the animosity while muddying the facts, investors and consumers may struggle to separate fact from spin.

    While the authorities investigate each side's claims, Herbalife has taken its campaign to Washington, where it rallied members of Congress to scrutinise Mr Ackman. The company also recently donated US$40,000 to a non-profit group, Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington, or CREW, that has called on lawmakers to investigate Mr Ackman. But after receiving a call from a reporter, the group pledged to refund the US$40,000 to avoid the "appearance of a conflict". "We have a responsibility to our customers, employees, members and shareholders to defend ourselves vigorously in the face of Bill Ackman's disingenuous campaign and attempts at stock manipulation," said Alan L Hoffman, a spokesman for Herbalife.

    Mr Ackman has denied Herbalife's claims, arguing that he had a reasonable basis to criticise the company. He has pledged to donate personal profits to charity, though his investors would still benefit if his bet succeeded.

    "Herbalife has taken a page out of the playbook of Enron, MBIA and other companies who have attacked short-sellers when serious questions of wrongdoing have been raised," Mr Ackman said in a statement. (Short-sellers bet that a company's stock will lose value, as opposed to those who are "long" a stock, betting that its value will rise.)

    Mr Ackman has hired lobbyists to attract the attention of lawmakers, including Senator Edward Markey, when Mr Markey was a member of the House. In January 2014, months after his staff had met with Mr Ackman, Mr Markey wrote letters to the FTC, the SEC and Herbalife.

    Soon after, the FTC said it had opened an investigation into Herbalife. Emboldened, Mr Ackman turned up the heat, stating last June: "I think the government is going to start arresting people." He also accused Herbalife distributors of committing "mail fraud, wire fraud, all kinds of crimes". Those events were a turning point for Herbalife. The company expanded its corps of lawyers at Gibson Dunn and Sidley Austin. It also hired Mr Hoffman, a former federal prosecutor who had served as deputy chief of staff to Vice President Joe Biden. At the White House, Mr Hoffman worked alongside Terrell McSweeny, who is currently an FTC commissioner.

    Herbalife hired Pamela Jones Harbour, a former FTC commissioner, as head of compliance. The company is adding seasoned lobbyists to its ranks, too, including Randall Popelka, a former official in the George W Bush administration, and Eric Rosen, a lobbyist for Heather Podesta, a Democratic insider. It also retained outside public relations experts, including Hilary B Rosen, a Democratic strategist.

    The new team adopted a different strategy: Take on Mr Ackman as though he were a political opponent.

    Weeks after Mr Markey's letter, for example, a lawyer for Herbalife sent a letter of its own to the SEC.

    The lawyer, Barry R Goldsmith, a partner at Gibson Dunn and a former senior SEC enforcement official, argued that Pershing Square knew of Mr Markey's letter in advance because the hedge fund had posted an earlier version of the letter online. Mr Goldsmith implied that Pershing Square may have altered its bet against Herbalife before the letter's public release, saying that Herbalife discovered a series of trades that were "consistent with Mr Ackman's ongoing efforts to manipulate Herbalife's stock", according to a copy reviewed by The New York Times.

    Whoever placed the trade most likely reaped millions of dollars in paper gains after Mr Markey's letter pummelled Herbalife's stock.

    "We had no prior knowledge the letters were coming out, and didn't trade on advance information," Mr Ackman said in an email statement, adding that Pershing Square learned of the letter from a reporter.

    Over the past year, Herbalife rolled out a multimillion-dollar ad campaign and commissioned opposition research from Sard Verbinnen, a public relations firm. On Monday, Herbalife made public therealbillackman.com, a website that includes videos highlighting Mr Ackman's investment mistakes, in response to Mr Ackman's own website, factsaboutherbalife.com. NYT