US brands taking umbrage with theatre, news interviews
They pull sponsorships and ads over content that they find objectionable, beyond the usual sex and violence
New York
A PRODUCTION of Shakespeare's Julius Caesar in New York's Central Park featuring a look-alike of US President Donald Trump as Caesar. The host of an NBC News Sunday night show interviewing a conspiracy theorist who has claimed the Sandy Hook school shooting was a hoax.
Long gone are the days when an advertiser's biggest concern was making sure it did not appear next to pornography online or during the ad breaks on racy TV shows. In this divided post-election world, brands are weighing in on theatre and news interviews, as they grapple with the rapidly spinning wheels of social media, increasingly polarised consumer groups and a new set of potential ills beyond the usual list of sex, violence and crude language.
Delta Air Lines and Bank of America drew headlines this week for pulling their support from New York's Public Theater in response to criticism about its production of Julius Caesar, in which the titular character - made up to look like Mr Trump - is assassinated. Then, on Monday, JPMorgan Chase temporarily halted its ads on NBC News because of Megyn Kelly's coming interview with Alex Jones, who operates the far-right site Infowars and has become more prominent because of his relationship with Mr Trump. In both cases, the advertisers' decisions were cheered by some and deplored as censorship by others.
"A lot of sponsorships that wouldn't have garnered a lot of attention a year ago are now coming under greater scrutiny because people are wondering what that says about a business' political stance," said Kara Alaimo, who teaches public relations at Hofstra University. "Brands are going to be asking a lot more questions moving forward about the content of theatrical productions and potentially even of news outlets, which is sort of the more frightening prospect to me."
Companies face a seemingly daily challenge as they grapple with boycott-ready consumers on the left and right, in addition to issues such as having their ads appear next to fake news and hate speech. At times, it can put them closer than usual to the traditional boundaries between brands and those creating content.
Kristin Lemkau, JPMorgan's chief marketing officer, said on Twitter on Monday that as an advertiser, she was "repulsed" that Ms Kelly "would give a second of airtime to someone who says Sandy Hook and Aurora are hoaxes" referring to a 2012 shooting at a movie theatre near Denver. By Tuesday afternoon, her post had been reposted on Twitter more than 4,000 times and liked more than 11,000 times, accelerated by a report in The Wall Street Journal that said that the company would remove its ads from NBC News television programming and online content until after the interview was broadcast.
JPMorgan's decision was in line with the company's policy against financially supporting fake news, said a person involved with the decision who spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss an internal matter. The company significantly reduced the number of websites and YouTube channels it advertises on early this year as part of that policy, shortly after The New York Times discovered an ad for Chase's private client services on a spam-filled site called Hillary 4 Prison.
While many lauded Ms Lemkau's message, some found the decision unusual. Stephen Greyser, a marketing professor at Harvard Business School, said that he thought it showed the company getting "too close to the editorial content of one programme", while Ms Alaimo said that the bank appeared to be "interfering in news content". Ms Kelly said that while she found the claims by Mr Jones involving the Sandy Hook shooting "personally revolting", he was a newsworthy interview subject.
Brands have been on edge in recent months as people use social media to question them about appearing on a range of websites and shows deemed, sometimes through a partisan lens, offensive. Since November, an anonymous Twitter account called Sleeping Giants has pressured brands into pulling ads from Breitbart News, the conservative news and opinion website. In April, online groups played a role in more than 50 advertisers leaving The O'Reilly Factor on Fox News after reports that Bill O'Reilly had reached settlements with several women who had accused him of harassment.
The furore, which can flood a brand's social media channels with complaints, has resulted in a sense of whiplash for advertisers, particularly online, where ads tend to be placed automatically based on browsing habits and cost rather than content. NYTIMES