Lower oil prices failing to bring usual benefits to US economy

JPMorgan Chase estimates price fall may have cut 0.3 of a percentage point off growth rate

Published Fri, Jan 22, 2016 · 09:50 PM

    Washington

    IT HAS been a truism of the US economy for decades: When oil prices rise, the economy suffers; when they fall, growth improves. But the drop in oil prices in the last two years has failed to deliver the usual economic benefits.

    As oil prices fell to levels not seen since 2003 - sagging below US$27 a barrel on Wednesday before rebounding to about US$30 on Thursday - many pundits now say they do not expect lower prices to bolster the US economy significantly in 2016.

    "We got this wrong," John Williams, president of the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, told an audience in Santa Barbara, California, this month.

    Lower oil prices historically were a cause for celebration in the developed world, including the US. The effect was akin to a tax cut for consumers who could fill their petrol tanks for less money. And since much of that oil was imported, the windfall was generally larger than the damage to domestic oil producers.

    Every dollar gained by consumers was a dollar lost by producers, but when the dollars were lost by foreign producers, the US economy should have benefited.

    But this time is different. The losses from lower prices are larger and quicker than expected as energy companies cut back on investment and lay off workers, while the gains are smaller and slower to materialise as consumers save some of their windfalls.

    Economists at JPMorgan Chase, who predicted last January that lower oil prices would add about 0.7 of a percentage point to the economic growth rate in 2015, now estimate that lower prices might have shaved 0.3 of a percentage point off the growth rate.

    This year, JPMorgan predicts that lower prices will help expand economic activity by just 0.1 of a percentage point, while economists at Goldman Sachs said they expect an effect "around zero".

    The decline in oil prices is causing other problems, too. It has contributed to the correction in global equity markets; the Standard & Poor's 500 stock index is down 10 per cent this year.

    And lower prices are weighing on inflation, jeopardising the Federal Reserve's plans to raise interest rates about one percentage point this year.

    "I think the Fed has to take seriously the possibility that we could enter into another economic downturn, and it urgently needs to make contingency plans for that scenario," said Andrew Levin, an economics professor at Dartmouth and a former adviser to Fed chairwoman Janet Yellen. "There's a feedback between financial markets and the economy. You might think markets are irrational, but even if they are, that spills over into the real economy."

    Many other economists doubt that the US is on the verge of a recession, as job growth and consumer spending remain healthy. But most now concede that the vast expansion in domestic oil and gas drilling in recent years has changed the way energy prices affect the economy.

    The Fed's Mr Williams said fracking operations were easier to set up and shut down than other kinds of extraction, so the industry's response to falling prices was quicker than analysts had expected.

    And there is little sign of an imminent reversal. The price of oil - as measured by a benchmark barrel of West Texas Intermediate - has fallen to below US$30 from more than US$105 in mid-2014.

    The International Energy Agency said this week that steady production and falling demand could send prices lower. "Unless something changes, the oil market could drown in oversupply," the agency said.

    Some analysts see evidence that US consumers are saving because they are scared or still struggling to pay down high levels of debt. Others are more optimistic. They argue that consumers hesitated because they were not sure lower prices would last, and that spending will rise as lower petrol prices endure.

    Consumer spending has started to rise more quickly, James Bullard, president of the Federal Reserve Bank of St Louis, noted in a speech last week, describing it as "mild evidence" that falling prices are lifting US growth. "For the macroeconomy as a whole, the relatively low crude oil prices the US is enjoying today are likely a bullish factor," he said.

    But he added that lower prices might be causing a different, longer-term economic problem by contributing to the erosion of inflation expectations.

    The Fed aims to keep prices rising about 2 per cent a year. It also seeks to maintain public confidence that it will meet that goal, which it regards as critical because expectations play an important role in determining the pace of inflation.

    But inflation has generally remained well below the Fed's goal since the financial crisis, and there is growing evidence that expectations are falling too.

    A survey by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York found that consumer expectations of inflation in three years' time had declined to 2.8 per cent from 3.3 per cent over the past two years.

    The Fed acknowledged that decline for the first time in its most recent policy statement. Just a few weeks ago, investors put the chances above 50 per cent that the Fed would raise rates again in March. But now that probability has fallen below 30 per cent. NYT