OK Lim’s lawyer questions prosecution witness’ recollection of 2 key transactions in cheating, forgery charges
THE second day of the trial involving cheating and forgery charges against Singapore’s former oil tycoon Lim Oon Kuin of the fallen Hin Leong empire saw Lim’s defence counsel cast doubts on the prosecution’s first witness’ recollection of two key transactions related to the alleged offences.
“Can I suggest that you don’t have a very good recollection in relation to these transactions... as within a day you have already changed your evidence on what happened over a particular call,” said Senior Counsel Davinder Singh of Davinder Singh Chambers, who is representing Lim, on Wednesday (Apr 12). He said this in his cross-examination of the testimony provided by HSBC’s senior vice-president of commodity and structured trade finance in Singapore, Chua Pei Pei.
On Tuesday, during deputy public prosecutor Christopher Ong’s examination, Chua testified that there was a discussion over the phone on Mar 19, 2020, with an employee from Hin Leong Trading (HLT) on a transaction between the oil trader and China Aviation Oil (Singapore) Corporation (CAO). Specifically, the discussion was in relation to a financing facility offered to HLT where it could apply to HSBC to discount invoices for the sale of oil to its customers (in this instance, CAO), which is referred to as “discounting application”.
However, on Wednesday, following Singh’s cross-examination, she said the phone discourse was also on a second transaction, this one involving Unipec Singapore.
Both these transactions are central to the three charges – two involve cheating and one, forgery – that Singapore prosecutors have proceeded on, out of a total of 130 charges that they have levelled against Lim.
Prosecutors have accused Lim of cheating HSBC by representing to the bank – through Hin Leong’s employees – that the company had entered into two contracts for the sale of oil with CAO and Unipec Singapore, and submitting two invoice-financing applications on these purported transactions.
Prosecutors allege that the two transactions were complete fabrications, concocted on Lim’s directions, and the invoice-financing applications were supported by forged or fabricated documentation. As a result of these deceptions, HSBC was “dishonestly induced” into disbursing US$111.68 million to Hin Leong, said Ong in presenting the prosecution’s case in an opening statement on Tuesday.
Lim pleaded not guilty to these charges on Tuesday through a Mandarin interpreter.
Since Chua joined the bank in 2015, she has managed HLT as the HSBC’s client for various “trade products” until the firm ran into troubled waters in 2020.
“Is it correct that at that time, Hin Leong was an important customer?,” asked Singh. “Yes,” Chua replied.
“And that it’s a relationship that you - yourself - and HSBC cherished?”, he continued. “Yes, it was one of our priority customers,” said Chua.
HLT is the flagship and giant oil trading arm of the Hin Leong empire founded and built by Lim, better known as OK Lim. The firm collapsed in 2020 as the pandemic decimated energy demand and caused a historic oil crash. HLT was wound up after it buckled under crippling debts of US$4.6 billion owed to some 20 banks. It was then too that irregularities in the sprawling group began to emerge.
“Am I right to say that you are guessing as your recollection has changed in 24 hours?” asked Singh.
“I am trying my best to remember what I can remember. I admit it (my recollection) has changed... but I disagree on the guessing,” replied Chua.
This particular line of questioning stretched over a considerable length of time, particularly as Chua took time to respond to Singh’s questions, which centred largely on her recollection of the phone conversation with the HLT employee.
Through it all, Lim, 81, who wore a dark navy jacket and wore a mask, sat without flinching in a wheelchair. The prosecution is expected to call some 28 witnesses to testify in the trial that is fixed over several dates in April, May and June till Jul 20.
TRENDING NOW
Ex-Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang carried a secret for more than a year. It led to his downfall
South-east Asia has lost Nvidia’s best salesman
Demand, tech capabilities position Apac and AI as Skyscanner’s next growth frontiers: CEO Bryan Batista
Jensen Huang discusses comeback as Nvidia CEO with allies: report