OK Lim’s lawyer questions witness from Unipec over testimony relating to terms of trade
THE defence counsel for former oil tycoon Lim Oon Kuin on Wednesday (Jun 7) accused a witness from Unipec Singapore of lying on the stand and raising “material inconsistencies” between the witness’ court testimony and an earlier statement given to the Singapore police.
The testy exchange in the State Court centred on whether Lim, boss of the failed Hin Leong Trading (HLT) group, involved himself in the “nitty-gritty” of trade deals.
Senior Counsel Davinder Singh of Davinder Singh Chambers, acting for Lim, said to Unipec Singapore’s deputy general manager Peter Li Yue: “I am going to suggest to you that you have lied in this court about ... the kind of terms you discussed with Mr Lim.”
Unipec Singapore is a wholly-owned unit of China’s energy-based trading company Unipec.
Li said in court that for deals involving his firm and HLT – specifically trades involving gas oil and diesel products – his discussions with Lim over the phone or face-to-face were on the “main terms”, which included pricing, quantity, quality and delivery date.
And while other non-key terms – specifically the performing vessel assigned to transport the goods – were most of the time not discussed with Lim, Li said it “doesn’t mean it was never discussed”.
Singh said: “That’s not what you told the CAD.”
In Li’s interview with Singapore’s Commercial Affairs Department (CAD) back in July 2020, he had said that the discussion with Lim were at a “very high level”, and included terms such as pricing or delivery dates.
When asked by the CAD how he conducted physical oil trading on a daily basis, Li had replied that if a counterparty was interested, the parties would discuss the terms of the deal, such as delivery date and pricing. His replies in that interview were put in writing by the CAD, and, as is customary, he had checked the statement for accuracy afterwards. The word “vessel” was struck out of the statement, either by Li himself or upon his request after he checked the statement.
Singh put it to him: “You did not say ... ‘sometimes’. You took pains to delete ‘vessel’ because vessels were never discussed in the first instance.”
Li’s response in Mandarin as translated by a court interpreter was: “This is a very wrong way of describing it. I deleted this (word) because this (vessel) is not a main term to be discussed. I never said ‘it was never discussed’.”
Singh responded: “Your evidence that you discussed vessels with Mr Lim at any time is a lie.” “Disagree,” Li replied.
Li testified that after he discussed the key terms of a trade deal with Lim, the discussion was typically followed up with two other HLT executives; these included Serene Seng, the trading firm’s former manager of corporate affairs who was also head of the contract department, in charge of deal completion.
Seng, 61, who worked at HLT for nearly 30 years and who retired three years ago, had earlier testified that in relation to the Unipec transaction, she was called into Lim’s office and instructed by him to prepare the documents for a discounting application “first”, before the deal which she described as “not genuine” was even closed.
When the hearing resumed on Wednesday after the lunch break, and as the witness waited outside the court room, Singh told Judge Toh Han Li that the matter on whether the vessel used for the shipment was discussed with Lim was “material”. He added that this was because Seng had earlier testified that Lim had also provided the name of the vessel in his instructions to her.
“Our position is that this could never happen, because Mr Lim doesn’t get involved in the nitty-gritty and operational matters,” Singh said.
The Unipec transaction is one of two transactions central to the three charges – two involve cheating and one, forgery – that Singapore prosecutors have proceeded on, out of a total of 130 charges levelled against Lim. The other transaction involves a contract for the sale of oil to China Aviation Oil (CAO).
Prosecutors have accused Lim of cheating HSBC by representing to the bank, through HLT’s employees, that the company had entered into these two contracts with CAO and Unipec Singapore – contracts that were “complete fabrications”. The prosecutors also charge that, as a result of these “deceptions”, HSBC was dishonestly induced into disbursing some US$112 million to HLT.
Wednesday was the 24th day of the criminal trial that begin on Apr 11. The hearing before Judge Toh Han Li continues, and will take place over several dates till Jul 20.