P2P insurance does not make one an insurer

Published Mon, Jun 5, 2017 · 09:50 PM

    THERE'S a new fad in town and it's called the peer-to-peer (P2P) insurance platform that looks like an insurer and behaves quite like one, except that, to the regulator, it isn't.

    Take the month-old startup Bandboo, a blockchain-enabled unemployment-insurance platform where its members pool money to insure one another and split the claims when a fellow member loses his/her job.

    In explaining its business model and products, common insurance terms including premium, claim and insurance, are used liberally. The startup also compares itself with a traditional insurer but adds that its block chain technology promotes transparency, something the latter lacks.

    Thing is, Bandboo's platform is not determined as an insurer by the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS), which first screens the startup. This is because it does not insure individuals and works on the premise that its members share risks and split the payout amount when a fellow member makes a claim. And because it does not assume the insurance risks of individuals by making good any shortfall when claims exceed pooled contributions, nor arrange insurance contracts between the individuals and external insurers, the platform is not viewed as an insurer.

    It is worth noting that MAS requires such P2P platforms to disclose clearly their unregulated status and to let consumers know that they have no access to typical safeguards such as the Financial Industry Dispute Resolution Centre (Fidrec) or the Policy Owners' Protection (PPF) Scheme.

    To that end, Bandboo has stated this clearly on its website. But even with such disclaimers, confusion remains for some consumers.

    To the laymen out there, such P2P platforms are naturally seen as insurers. With that, the misleading view that they come under the purview of MAS and that there are safeguards in place.

    Upon comparison, the layers of regulatory compliance the insurance industry is subjected to are massive and costly.

    Insurers in the life or general business segments are watched over by MAS and have to adhere to mandatory capital requirements under the risk-based framework to ensure they are financially sound in the event of a failure. They also have to be a PPF Scheme member that is on top of the capital adequacy requirement. This scheme aims to protect existing and future policyowners should a life or general insurer, which is a member of this scheme, winds up.

    When asked, Bandboo had said that besides plans to buy insurance from reinsurer, the premiums collected from members are placed in an escrow account held by a trust. It said the funds are held in the client trust account and cannot be withdrawn unless proper authorisations have been granted.

    Advocates of disruption and new business models would argue that platforms like Bandboo need room to develop so as to serve the needs of consumers that are not traditionally covered. The space provides a lower entry barrier and maybe even licence to be creative. Overly limiting rules on these startups would only suffocate them and, in some cases, snuff them out before they even have a chance to take flight.

    Others, however, say the "policy inconsistency" could prove to be a potential problem. They question if such space paves the way for fraudsters to come to Singapore and set up a company, claiming, for instance, to be a fintech insurance startup but only to make away with consumers' monies when they gain traction and grow sizeable, given that they are not regulated. In such an event, whatever recourse there is for consumers could be too little, too late.

    While both camps touch on valid concerns, the sure thing is that a grey area exists as newer business models come into the market. And this would only likely grow bigger in future.

    Given that the lines are increasingly blurred, consumers, on their part, need to be conscious of the fact that there are businesses that can market themselves with insurance terms but are not deemed insurers and thus, not bound by the Insurance Act.

    As with all transactions, consumers would do well to note that the bottom line is this: go in with your eyes open.

    READ MORE: Questions raised over new unemployment insurance platform