Regulator raps Delong chairman, advisers over buyout debacle
Annabeth Leow
Singapore
LAW firm Shook Lin & Bok and financial adviser PrimePartners Corporate Finance have been censured by the Securities Industry Council (SIC) for their roles in a short-lived privatisation attempt by Delong Holdings.
The offeror, which is owned by Delong chief executive and chairman Ding Liguo, was also censured over the bungled buyout bid, according to an SIC statement on Monday.
Mr Ding, through his vehicle Best Grace Holdings, had made a voluntary conditional cash offer of S$7 a share on Sept 27, 2018, valuing Delong at S$771.3 million.
But a concert party of the offer vehicle had already bought a 15.04 per cent stake in Delong at a higher price, the US dollar equivalent of S$7.42 a share, in June that year. As this took place less than six months before the offer, the offeror is obliged to extend the same price to all shareholders.
The planned privatisation was eventually scuppered, just two weeks after the offer was announced.
This prompted the SIC to appoint a five-member hearing committee to look into whether the offeror had breached the Takeover Code, and whether the advisers had failed in their responsibility to ensure that the offeror complied with the Code.
Following a probe, the committee chaired by Prof Hans Tjio established that there had been a breach but ruled that it was not necessary to compensate any Delong shareholders, given what it deemed "the limited impact of the breach".
The non-compliance was spotted soon after offer announcement and the offer was pulled before the offer document was sent out, it noted.
Still, the decision on compensation "should not be regarded as establishing any precedent", the SIC added.
The committee also found that Shook Lin & Bok fell short of the standards expected of a legal adviser.
The firm had advised both the offeror and PrimePartners Corporate Finance, at two earlier meetings, that the offer should be made at the highest price paid for shares in the three months prior to the offer, under a different part of the Takeover Code.
Shook Lin & Bok did not recognise, until contacted by a third party, that the offeror's June purchases triggered a longer six-month reference period, according to the SIC.
The SIC committee found PrimePartners Corporate Finance "relatively less culpable" compared with Shook Lin & Bok, which it said had made "a serious lapse". Nonetheless, the financial adviser should have exercised due care and independent judgement on the advice it was given.
The committee accepted Shook Lin & Bok partner David Chong's offer to abstain from Takeover Code-related work for 15 months, and PrimePartners Corporate Finance's Mark Liew and Yong Chin Vei's offer to do the same for nine months. Both periods began on April 23.
Meanwhile, Mr Ding and his spouse, Zhao Jing, have tabled a fresh buyout offer at the original price of S$7 a share, through Best Grace, having obtained an SIC waiver from the rule that bars an offer from being re-introduced within 12 months of a withdrawal. Best Grace relaunched its offer on Monday, with Stirling Coleman Capital replacing PrimePartners Corporate Finance.
Separately, Shook Lin & Bok said the firm had "enhanced our processes and prudential standards to better discharge our professional duties to our clients".
It noted that Best Grace and affiliates "continue to instruct our firm on the relaunch of the offer... and also various new matters".
The offeror and its concert parties together hold a 81.48 per cent stake in Delong.
Trading in Delong shares was suspended on July 24. The company has applied to resume trading. The counter last traded at S$6.01.
TRENDING NOW
South-east Asia has lost Nvidia’s best salesman
Higher rates, weaker spending: Is the Philippines entering stagflation?
Who is Leo KoGuan, the Singapore-based billionaire backing Nvidia’s Jensen Huang?
Demand, tech capabilities position Apac and AI as Skyscanner’s next growth frontiers: CEO Bryan Batista