Beauty salon sues Hao Mart over alleged breach of Taste Orchard sublease; Hao Mart denies liability for purported losses
Beauty salon operator Belovie is the first sub-tenant to sue Hao Mart in the High Court
[SINGAPORE] Beauty salon operator Belovie, a former sub-tenant of the Taste Orchard premises, has sued master tenant and supermarket operator Hao Mart for an alleged breach of the lease agreement.
It is asking for damages to be assessed.
Belovie said it was allowed to operate its beauty salon at Taste Orchard – the former premises of OG Orchard Point – for three years under its sub-tenant agreement inked in June 2024 with Hao Mart, based on its statement of claim filed in January.
But it was given a written notice in September 2025 to vacate its shop space by Dec 31 that year, as Hao Mart’s master lease had been discontinued, and that it was required to hand over the premises to landlord and department store operator OG by the deadline it gave Belovie.
There were no allegations that Belovie had breached, defaulted, or not complied with the agreement, the claimant said, so Hao Mart’s action constituted repudiation, that is, refusal to fulfil the sub-tenancy agreement.
Belovie said it had spent about SS$445,607.70 in fitting out and preparing its salon at Taste Orchard, but was deprived of the full tenure without fault on its part.
Additionally, it has incurred contractual sums – including the security deposit, fit-out deposits, administration fees, stamp duty, service charges, advertising fees and utility deposits – as well as additional rental costs at replacement premises and a host of other costs arising from the relocation.
Belovie added that it has incurred losses arising from the abortion of arrangements entered into in reliance on continued occupation.
“The defendant is therefore liable to make restitution to the claimant in such sums as the court assesses,” Belovie argued.
It claimed its business experienced a sharp and immediate decline after the news broke that Hao Mart’s master lease had been discontinued and sub-tenants were asked to vacate the premises.
It said beauty salons are dependent on customer confidence, continuity of location, stable footfall and the ability to offer pre-paid treatment.
Patrons became unwilling to sign up for new packages or extend packages due to the uncertainty over the continued operation of the beauty salon at the premises, Belovie said.
Footfall plunged following the news of master lease having been discontinued.
“As a result, the claimant suffered a significant reduction in revenue and profitability even prior to vacating the premises,” the statement of claim read.
During its move to another premises at Citygate Mall in Beach Road and re-establishing its business, profit also took a hit, it said. This, together with business disruption, is a foreseeable consequence of its tenancy being prematurely discontinued, Belovie contended.
Hao Mart denies breaching sub-tenancy pact
In a defence and counterclaim dated Feb 24, Hao Mart denied being liable for Belovie’s alleged losses.
It said any contractual sums paid by Belovie were in accordance with the salon’s obligations under the sub-tenancy agreement and for its own commercial purposes, and not due to any alleged breach by Hao Mart.
It also denied that the claimant suffered “wasted expenditure” due to the sub-tenancy agreement, as it was able to use the equipment, movables or furniture acquired for its salon at Taste Orchard.
Hao Mart also rejected Belovie’s claim that it is entitled to recover any expectation loss, which includes additional rental costs at the replacement premises or losses arising from the cancellation of memberships or arrangements.
“Such losses, if any, are too remote, speculative, and not foreseeable,” it said.
Hao Mart added that it is not liable for any consequential losses, which were not caused by any breach on its part. Instead, it said the losses were incurred as a result of the master lease being terminated by OG and the issue of the possession order.
In addition, Hao Mart said Belovie was aware it did not own Taste Orchard, and had leased the premises from OG under a master lease.
The claimant had thus entered into the sub-tenancy agreement “knowing and accepting that there was a risk the lease could be terminated for whatever reason”.
Hao Mart said that it was “an implied term” of the sub-tenancy agreement that it had the “legal right” to terminate the agreement “with reasonable notice” if the master lease is terminated for whatever reason.
Furthermore, Hao Mart also accused Belovie of breaching the sub-tenancy agreement by failing to pay rent from October to December 2025 – after the notice to vacate was given – as well as failing to reinstate the occupied premises before handing over possession to the defendant.
It said that despite exercising its right to terminate the sub-tenancy agreement, Belovie remained “obliged” to perform these obligations under the agreement till it delivered possession of its premises on Dec 31, 2025.
The claimant’s failure to reinstate the premises also exposed Hao Mart to a possible claim from OG for reinstatement costs, it added.
As a result of Belovie’s breach of the sub-tenancy agreement, Hao Mart said it has in turn suffered loss and damages, including three months’ unpaid rent amounting to S$86,100.
It therefore seeks to claim from Belovie the unpaid rent including goods and services tax; damages for reinstatement costs, if any; interest; costs and any relief deemed fit.
In addition, Hao Mart has issued a third-party notice to OG for a contribution of costs, in the event it is found liable for Belovie’s claims.
Hao Mart said this is based on an oral agreement between both parties that OG would share valid costs of the termination of Taste Orchard’s sub-tenancy agreements.
In response to queries from The Business Times, OG’s lawyers from Dentons Rodyk said: “The allegations and claims made against OG are baseless in its view, and OG will defend them vigorously in due course.”
Belovie is the first sub-tenant to sue Hao Mart in the High Court, and this case is the fourth lawsuit for Hao Mart arising from the leasing of Taste Orchard; it is seeking to consolidate the four actions.
The supermarket operator sued a wholly-owned unit of PropNex and its salesperson over alleged misrepresentation in the leasing of the Taste Orchard premises in August.
In October, it was itself sued by OG over alleged breach of the master tenant agreement, but it is making a counterclaim in that case.
It launched another claim against OG and the husband of a shareholder of the department store operator in January, over the mortgage of the supermarket owner couple’s Good-Class Bungalow.