Sembcorp is right to cast off its marine unit; both entities will be the better for it

Anita Gabriel

Anita Gabriel

Published Tue, Jun 9, 2020 · 09:50 PM

IT has taken a pandemic to push industrial conglomerate Sembcorp Industries (SCI) into doing what was long overdue.

On Monday, the conglomerate unveiled a proposal that could see the firm fund the bulk of Sembcorp Marine's (SMM) S$2.1 billion recapitalisation exercise and then completely wean off the loss-making marine unit.

Travis Lundy, an analyst at Quiddity Advisors who publishes on SmartKarma, called the proposal a "very carefully-constructed technical move" by SCI to avoid increasing its short-term credit exposure to SMM.

Under the deal, SCI will not cough up any cash to take up SMM's massive rights issue. Instead, it plans to set off the S$1.5 billion subordinated loan it had extended to the rig builder a year ago to fund its rights entitlement and some.

SMM will use S$1.5 billion of its rights issue proceeds to repay the outstanding principal on the loan to its parent SCI by converting the loan into equity on its balance sheet.

SCI will also spin off its stake in the recapitalised SMM to its shareholders, including its largest owner Temasek Holdings, via a distribution in specie.

Temasek is also backstopping S$600 million of SMM's rights issue.

The real competition

"Sembcorp Marine is being cast away... by its parent," remarked Mr Lundy.

That's not necessarily a tragic outcome as SMM is being "cast" to Temasek - a shareholder with a lot more clout and capital.

The investment firm could end up owning between 29.9 and 58 per cent of SMM depending on the rights' take-up rate.

Temasek's potential entry into SMM is fuelling hopes that the much-talked-about mega merger between SMM and Keppel Offshore & Marine may finally happen.

After all, how many giant rig builders does Singapore need when the real competition is in China?

The deal will also leave SMM, which is hurting from a dearth of new jobs in a pandemic-led oil slump, with less debt and more cash for working capital as it charts a separate course from SCI for the first time in over two decades.

"We view the sharply lower gearing (as) a big positive, as this will help SMM better engage potential customers and also better meet banks' loan covenants," pointed out RHB Research.

SCI shareholders, meanwhile, can rest easy now that a privatisation of SMM by SCI - an idea that has long been bandied about - is out of the picture.

This is not 2002, when SCI had launched a privatisation of SMM by way of a scheme of arrangement but was rebuffed by shareholders.

Then, SMM was stronger financially - with a net cash position - and the outlook for rig builders was rosy.

Today, uncertainties abound. When, for instance, will the oil market turbulence end?

When will SMM, which has been in the red since 2018, start making money again?

In contrast, the proposed deal's value proposition for SCI is abundantly clear. SCI's stunning gain of 37 per cent to S$2.09 on Tuesday post-announcement is an indication of how positively the market views the deal.

SCI is poised to be liberated from the shackles of its cyclical marine business and transformed into a defensive utilities and urbanisation play.

Big boon

The conglomerate's years-long pivot to power generation, water, renewables and green energy solutions plus sustainable urban developments may finally get the investor attention it deserves.

That would be a big boon for a stock that has suffered a major beating since it got the boot from the MSCI Singapore Index last month.

When all is said and done, the key question is: Will both firms be better off post-recapitalisation and de-merger versus the status quo?

The answer is a resounding yes.

READ MORE: Tale of 2 stocks: Sembcorp jumps 37% on demerger, Sembmarine dives 27%