Sias calls on Hyflux to seek clarity on Utico's less favourable revised offer
The revision stems from lapsing of long-stop date in original offer that had a cash component
Sharanya Pillai
Singapore
THE Securities Investors Association (Singapore), or Sias, has called on Hyflux to immediately clarify key aspects of Utico's revised rescue deal, which the investor watchdog dubbed a "bombshell" for holders of Hyflux's Perpetual securities and Preference shares (PnPs).
In a press statement on Thursday, Sias chief executive David Gerald noted that Utico's latest offer to the PnPs is that they will receive shares comprising 5 per cent of Utico and 12.5 per cent of Hyflux as payment, but with no cash component.
This marks a stark change from Utico's original S$400 million rescue package, where PnP holders would have received an upfront cash payment of S$1,500 or 50 per cent of their holdings, whichever is lower.
In a letter to Hyflux on Tuesday, Utico chief executive Richard Menezes said that all cash considerations his firm had earlier offered will be substituted for stock in Utico and Hyflux. The new offer is only valid until June 4.
"This must come as a shock to PnPs, who were expecting to recover 50 per cent of their initial investment in cash under the initial proposal," Mr Gerald said in his Thursday statement.
Given the tight deadline for Utico's new offer, he called on Hyflux to promptly seek clarity on the name of the Utico entity whose shares are to be issued to the PnPs.
Hyflux should also question whether, similar to the previous offer, PnP holders can choose between an upfront option and a deferred option where shares will be issued over a period of time, Mr Gerald said.
If PnP holders do have this choice, Hyflux should further clarify what the offer for each option entails and if it includes a deferred distribution, and if security will be provided for such a distribution, he added.
Utico's revised offer stems from the lapsing of the long-stop date on May 26 in its original offer. This deadline was passed without court sanction being obtained for the proposed restructuring schemes, Mr Gerald noted. In addition, Utico claims that its request for KPMG's report on Hyflux's financials was only met on May 26, instead of Jan 27.
Mr Gerald said in his statement: "Sias is disappointed that it has now come to pass that, despite Sias' reminders, the long-stop date has now lapsed and Utico's revised offer as set out in its May 26 letter is considerably less favourable than Utico's earlier offer."
He said that Sias had requested Hyflux to work on extending the long-stop date since Singapore began introducing measures to deal with the Covid-19 pandemic.
Sias had also reached out to Hyflux on multiple occasions in April and May to seek updates on whether Hyflux and Utico had reached an agreement to extend the long-stop date, what Hyflux's plans were if the deadline could not be extended, and when and how scheme meetings were to be convened, Mr Gerald said.
From here on, Sias wants to be kept updated on Hyflux's negotiations with Utico, Mr Gerald said. He also called on the firm to update its stakeholders on developments regarding Utico or other potential white knights, rather than to leave them "in a state of uncertainty".
"Hyflux is still a listed company on the SGX and it is the duty of the company and its directors to provide timely and transparent updates to its stakeholders, notwithstanding the challenges faced.
"This restructuring commenced nearly two years ago and to-date is nowhere near conclusion. Sias strongly urges that Hyflux takes all steps possible to bring the restructuring to a satisfactory and expeditious end for all stakeholders," Mr Gerald said.
TRENDING NOW
Motoring tycoon Peter Kwee is back in court: Here are his previous legal battles
Peter Kwee’s Ridley Park bungalow on the market with S$100 million asking price
Demand, tech capabilities position Apac and AI as Skyscanner’s next growth frontiers: CEO Bryan Batista
South-east Asia has lost Nvidia’s best salesman