Singapore listcos disclose fuller emissions data, but how useful are the numbers?
Wong Pei Ting
PIECES of the puzzle depicting the carbon footprint of Singapore’s largest listed companies are coming together, with 27 of the 30 Straits Times Index (STI) constituents having released some form of data informing their Scope 1, 2 or 3 emissions.
But the picture remains fuzzy, as the data is riddled with disclaimers, holes and inconsistencies — leaving little room for investors to compare one company with another, or benchmark companies against their past performance.
For one, there is little explanation behind companies’ selection of the operational control approach in determining carbon emissions boundaries.
The Science Based Targets initiative recommends that a company’s boundary is consistent with the one used in its financial accounting and reporting. But most of the STI companies applied an operational control approach, instead of equity share or financial control approaches, without explaining why. Some companies have even set their 2030 net-zero targets this way.
Property developer City Developments (CDL), for example, reported emissions only for its Singapore operations and 6 “key subsidiaries”. It did not address whether the 6 covers all outfits under its operational control, but CDL listed more than 70 wholly-owned subsidiaries in its annual report from the same reporting period.
Companies also did not show consistency in their reporting of Scope 1, 2 and 3 emissions. By definition, Scope 1 emissions are from direct, controlled sources, while Scope 2 emissions are from purchased energy consumption. Scope 3 emissions are indirect emissions, often by suppliers or partners.
Over at Frasers Logistics & Commercial Trust (FLCT), the emissions disclosures for Scopes 1 and 2 were for its commercial properties only. The Scope 3 disclosures, meanwhile, were related to emissions from its industrial properties only. Its sustainability report did not give reasons for the way it spliced up and presented the data.
Emission figures for peers do not appear comparable. Take the Scope 3 emissions reported by DBS. The bank’s footprint of 17,482 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent (tCO2e) far exceeded that of UOB (630 tCO2e) and OCBC (278 tCO2e).
DBS counted emissions from a wider variety of sources, including outsourced data centres (14,331 tCO2e), ground transport (1,551 tCO2e) and business flights (837 tCO2e), while UOB and OCBC only counted corporate air travel.
Some companies went as far as to take stock of all 15 of the distinct reporting categories that the Greenhouse Gas (GHG) Protocol, the leading authority and international standard-setter on corporate GHG accounting, stated could count towards Scope 3.
Thai Beverage did that, leaving out 4 categories that are irrelevant to its business, and reported more than 1.4 million tCO2e in Scope 3 emissions for its last fiscal year ended September 2021.
Having done the comprehensive exercise, the company could single out the “fuel and energy related activities” category as a large contributor, as it said it will commit to roll out more solar rooftops and biogas projects in the coming years to combat fossil fuel use.
These showed that bigger numbers do not necessarily mean a browner business. Rather, it can signal a company’s commitment to take properly stock of their carbon inventory and align with a 1.5-degree-Celsius warmer scenario.
Indeed, Scope 3 is still a work in progress for many companies. Half of the STI constituents has not disclosed this information as at Jun 17. A few addressed the missing figure in their reports, saying they are still in the process of mapping it out.
Among them is UOL , which said it will start accounting for Scope 3 emissions in its next sustainability report, with an intention to cover embodied carbon – the carbon footprint of a building or infrastructure project before it becomes operational. Other property developers on the STI did not address if their disclosed figures covered this.
As for Scope 1 emissions, several real estate investment trusts (Reits) defined this scope narrowly — as emissions relating to diesel usage. This raises a question of whether fugitive emissions from fire retardants and refrigerants at their properties or emissions from company cars were forgotten or differently categorised.
Keppel DC Reit , a pure-play data centre Reit, reported 863 tCO2e for its Scope 1 emissions for 2021; and CapitaLand Integrated Commercial Trust , the largest Reit here, reported 321 tCO2e over the same period.
Mapletree Commercial Trust and Mapletree Industrial Trust skipped ascribing a number to Scope 1 altogether, with the justification that diesel is only topped up for “back-up purposes”. MCT said diesel makes up “less than 1 per cent of energy used throughout the year”, while MIT called emissions from this activity “insignificant”.
One Reit manager told The Business Times that Reits have little under Scope 1 as most are externally managed and do not have their own employees.
If this is the case, Scope 3 would be more meaningful. Yet, only 1 of the 7 Reits in the Index – Keppel DC Reit – delved into more extensive categories, including data from areas such as business travel and downstream leased assets.
Scope 2 is thought of by most as the most straightforward of the 3 scopes, as it can be easily calculated based on the consumption outlined in energy bills.
But even this number can differ depending on the method of calculation used. There is the “market-based” method, which reflects emissions from electricity chosen by the company; and the “location-based” method, which reflects the average emissions intensity of grids on which energy consumption occurs.
Market-based emissions are generally smaller as they may take into account contractual instruments bundled with their energy purchase, which can include renewable energy certificates (RECs).
UOB’s market-based Scope 2 emissions were low, at 1,020 tCO2e in the last fiscal year, because of such RECs, while the location-based emissions that it reported on the side amounted to 66,630 tCO2e.
UOB could therefore claim to have achieved carbon neutrality for its footprint in 2021 by retiring 6,000 tonnes worth of carbon offsets, as it only had to make up for the 1,020 tCO2e residual emissions from Scope 2 and a total of 4,960 tCO2e Scope 1 and 3 emissions.
There were, nevertheless, a few bright spots in the reporting.
To list a few examples, OCBC has started reporting Scope 1 and 3 emissions; and ComfortDelGro started accounting for biogenic emissions from its biodiesel consumption under Scope 1. Singapore Exchange and Jardine Cycle & Carriage also released their emission numbers for the first time.