SingTel refutes claim of A$713m tax avoidance
Others also lambast report claiming over A$80b in foregone tax from ASX 200
Michelle Quah
SINGAPORE Telecommunications (SingTel) has hit back at a report claiming that the telco had dodged more than A$700 million in taxes due to the Australian government.
The Singapore telecommunications giant says the report wrongly applied the Australian corporate tax rate of 30 per cent to its entire group profits, not all of which are liable for Australian tax.
Others have since come out to denounce the report, which has garnered much attention and was widely reported Down Under.
The report, "Who pays for our common wealth? Tax practices of the ASX 200", looks at the tax practices of the ASX 200 - the largest companies listed on the Australian Securities Exchange (ASX).
Produced by United Voice and the Tax Justice Network - a coalition of unions, churches and charities - it purported to find that nearly a third of ASX 200 companies have an average effective tax rate of 10 per cent or less. It claimed that overall, the effective tax rate of ASX 200 companies over the last decaded was 23 per cent, leading to more than A$80 billion (S$89.03 billion) worth of forgone tax from 2004 to 2013.
Among the companies it highlighted was SingTel - it claimed the telco dodged A$713 million in taxes during the 10-year period.
SingTel - which is listed on both the Singapore Exchange and the ASX, and has operations in Australia through Optus - has come out to clarify such claims.
"The article has simply and incorrectly calculated tax foregone in Australia by applying the Australian 30 per cent corporate tax rate to the accumulated total of SingTel Group profits," a SingTel spokesman said.
Australia levies a flat 30 per cent rate of tax on corporate income; however, non-resident companies, such as SingTel, are required to pay income tax only on Australian-sourced income, and not on income derived from all sources.
The SingTel spokesman went on to say: "SingTel's Australian subsidiaries undertake all their legal and governance responsibilities diligently, including their Australian tax obligations."
The report has also come under fire from other sources. The Australian columnist Stephen Bartholomeusz says the report was "built on a complete absence of the facts".
"The report is remarkable for the shallowness of its understanding of corporate taxation and, indeed, of the entities it points the finger so accusingly at," he adds.
Mr Bartholomeusz says the authors of the report don't seem to know the difference between a company and a trust (a trust doesn't pay tax), and that they have applied Australian tax rates to non-Australian income earned incurred by non-Australian resident companies such as 21st Century Fox and SingTel.
He concludes by saying that this sort of "shambolic and misleading analysis in the United Voice/Tax Justice report ... is less than constructive, is damaging to the companies and trusts concerned, undermines taxpayer trust in the tax system, and confuses the debate".