Some property stocks defying odds
Those that stand out amid the bleakness are firms that have diversified into investment properties and overseas markets
Singapore
THE FTSE index tracking Singapore property developers has underperformed the benchmark Straits Times Index 4.8 per cent to 5.5 per cent year-to-date (as at Nov 24) - a bleak reflection of the cheerless real estate market.
But closer scrutiny shows very varied stock price performances among Singapore developers, with some outdoing the rest by astonishing margins, while others have plunged tragically.
For those whose prices jumped, this was mostly due to major corporate actions taken during the course of the year, such as the emergence of a new substantial stakeholder in Tuan Sing, Frasers Centrepoint Ltd's (FCL's) acquisition of Australand, United Industrial Corp's (UIC's) privatisation of its subsidiary Singapore Land, and CapitaLand, which similarly took CapitaMalls Asia private in a corporate restructuring exercise.
Year-to-date, Tuan Sing is up 42 per cent, UIC up 18 per cent, and FCL and CapitaLand both up 10 per cent.
At the other end, small-caps such as SingHaiyi have languished after penny stocks fell out of favour with investors following last October's penny stock crash. SingHaiyi has fallen 29 per cent year-to-date. It was also dragged down by a 10-to-one share consolidation following a change in ownership, as is common when investors dump their fractional shares, said Ivan Hooi, an analyst from DMG & Partners Research.
Generally though, the developers with largely Singapore-centric residential operations have languished - such as Hiap Hoe and Ho Bee Land, down 4 per cent and 7 per cent respectively so far this year.
Those focused on the domestic luxury residential segment, such as Wing Tai Holdings (down 13 per cent), have been hit even harder, as loan curbs make large quantums harder for buyers to stomach.
There are some who have taken to leasing their unsold units. In Ho Bee's case, this has affected its revenue and earnings, since leasing has a lower profitability than developmental sales, noted PhillipCapital analyst Caroline Tay in a recent note. She cut her valuation on the company's inventory to reflect the languid demand.
Rather, it was the developers which had diversified into investment properties and overseas markets which generally showed more resilience in their share prices, even as the domestic residential market continued on a downtrend this year, noted Eli Lee, an analyst at OCBC Investment Research.
"Specifically, in the investment property space, domestic prime office and suburban retail rentals remain fairly healthy, and developers with strong execution in these sub-segments also outperformed peers," he said.
CapitaLand, for instance, holds office properties via its Reit subsidiary, CapitaCommercial Trust (CCT), and the office segment happens to be doing exceptionally well now amid a supply crunch. CapitaGreen, one of the few new projects coming onstream from now until end-2015, will also be completed before the year is out, which should give CCT and its parent a boost.
CapitaMall Trust's heartland retail malls also provide some resilience to CapitaLand, while the latter's over S$3 billion privatisation of CapitaMalls Asia - seen as earnings accretive for investors and a rational move by management strategy-wise - has also driven the price up, analysts said.
Another diversified developer is Keppel Land, which recently announced commercial developments in Ho Chi Minh City, Manila and Jakarta, and even New York City with joint venture partners.
But analysts are in two minds about whether to buy into or steer clear of developer stocks. There are those who see such stocks as bargains at current share prices.
"We see fundamental value in blue-chip developers, such as CapitaLand and Keppel Land, now trading at 40-50 per cent discounts to their RNAVs (revalued net asset valuation), but concede that the visibility for near-term catalysts remain clouded," said Mr Lee from OCBC.
DMG's Mr Hooi shares this sentiment, citing both stocks' regional diversification and "undemanding valuations".
But others prefer to wait. One of them, requesting anonymity, said any external risks may cause the share price discount to expand further.
"On the physical property side, prices have not come off as much as I think is comfortable. (Residential) supply is still coming onstream, vacancy rates going up, and you have all the fundamental ingredients of population policy and low interest rates, which work to prevent the government from easing the cooling measures," he said.
"So I see that the risk of that discount expanding is far more than that of the discount contracting."
TRENDING NOW
Motoring tycoon Peter Kwee is back in court: Here are his previous legal battles
Peter Kwee’s Ridley Park bungalow on the market with S$100 million asking price
Demand, tech capabilities position Apac and AI as Skyscanner’s next growth frontiers: CEO Bryan Batista
South-east Asia has lost Nvidia’s best salesman