Take apocalyptic market calls with sackful of salt

Published Thu, Jan 14, 2016 · 09:50 PM

    London

    US policy rates will be slashed to minus 5 per cent in the next recession, the S&P 500 will lose something like three-quarters of its value, and a global trade war will probably break out. What's an investor to do? Albert Edwards, a Societe Generale strategist and a perma-bear who recently forecast that scenario, poses the question but not necessarily the answer. Meanwhile Royal Bank of Scotland (RBS) analysts' pithy advice is: "Sell (mostly) everything."

    A dreadful start to 2016 has made investors more receptive to such apocalyptic market forecasts. But as with the Greek oracles, the hard bit is figuring out how to act on the prophesies.

    Take the gloom-laden forecasts Mr Edwards issued in a note dated Jan 13. Even investors who share his pessimism would be hard pressed to know how to trade since there's no real timeframe for when these calamities might occur. And while RBS analysts are somewhat more specific, most asset managers would struggle to follow their recent advice to bail out of pretty much everything apart from high-quality government bonds. Not least since these so-called safe havens proved anything but safe last year, when German bond yields rose 21-fold in less than two months.

    Granted, the global financial crisis showed that voices crying in the wilderness could be right. And investors may find the analysis underpinning some of these big calls is enlightening as they look for risks in these uncertain times. But those who hold very trenchant world views can sometimes be wrong for very long periods - longer than most investors can stomach underperformance. This is probably why Societe Generale issues Mr Edwards' thoughts as an "alternative view".

    And there are some analysts who may want to distinguish themselves by breaking away from the pack and issuing either much rosier or much gloomier forecasts than the consensus. They will happily accept the high probability risk of being completely wrong for the low probability reward of being one of the few to expect the unexpected. Their views may be entertaining, and sometimes even enlightening. But they don't necessarily help investors make money.

    READ MORE: