Tale of 2 stocks: Sembcorp jumps 37% on demerger, Sembmarine dives 27%

Fiona Lam
Published Tue, Jun 9, 2020 · 09:50 PM

    Singapore

    INVESTORS on Tuesday cheered Sembcorp Industries (SCI)'s decision to sever ties with its troubled marine unit, but were less enthusiastic about the prospects for Sembcorp Marine (SMM).

    SCI shares soared 36.6 per cent or S$0.56 to finish Tuesday at a four-month high of S$2.09, with nearly 90 million shares traded.

    Its marine arm, however, had a bruising session as the stock dived to S$0.49 just minutes after the opening bell. Shares of SMM ended the day 27.1 per cent or S$0.23 lower at S$0.62, representing a 16-year low, About 135.4 million SMM shares changed hands.

    SCI and SMM were the most heavily traded stocks by volume on the Singapore bourse on Tuesday.

    On Monday, both companies had unveiled a proposed S$2.1 billion recapitalisation for SMM and a deal that would separate SMM from its parent.

    Some analysts believe the two-part plan will be a boon for both firms, even though SMM's share price is set to see some short-term pressure.

    CGS-CIMB analyst Lim Siew Khee, for instance, expects a price drop of about 30 per cent in the marine giant's stock given its highly dilutive 5-for-1 rights issue.

    Nevertheless, she believed the deal could still be beneficial to existing SMM shareholders as the recapitalisation and debt repayment could resolve the firm's funding risk.

    SCI's share of the rights will be paid for by setting off a S$1.5 billion subordinated loan from SCI to SMM. SMM expects its pro forma FY2019 net gearing to improve to 0.45 times, from 1.82 times as at Dec 31, 2019.

    RHB analyst Leng Seng Choon too said the "sharply lower" gearing is a "big positive", as it will help the marine and offshore engineering group better engage potential customers and meet banks' loan covenants.

    "We see potential for further restructuring beyond the proposal just announced," he added. He is keeping his "buy" call on SMM, although he has cut his target price (TP) to S$1.13 from S$1.28 due to the "tough business environment".

    UOB Kay Hian, meanwhile, described the proposal as a lifeline for SMM. The company's prospects of a quick return to profitability are "remote", it said, and the rights issue is necessary for SMM to get through the current downturn.

    UOB Kay Hian slashed its TP for SMM to S$0.25, from S$0.81 previously, to take into account the potential 10.46 billion new shares from the rights issue. It kept its call at "hold".

    "Securing new orders remains extremely difficult, while its repairs and upgrades business has been affected by disruptions in global shipping and cruises.

    "As a result, we believe (SMM's) H1 2020 results will be extremely weak," UOB Kay Hian said.

    Meanwhile, analysts bumped up their targets for SCI. CGS-CIMB upgraded its call on the stock to "add" with a higher TP of S$2.49, up from S$1.76.

    "We think the market has undervalued SCI's stub (energy and urban development businesses), and the stock could re-rate on the new CEO's reviewing and restructuring as well as a year-on-year improvement in FY21 earnings without SMM losses and post-Covid sentiment," Ms Lim wrote.

    RHB maintained its "buy" call on SCI but bumped its TP up to S$2.11 from S$2.00 previously. OCBC, which also rates the stock a "buy", raised its fair value estimate to S$2.00 from S$1.63.

    UOB Kay Hian said a key benefit of the demerger for the conglomerate is that a more focused strategy on energy and urban development will enable SCI to trade at valuation multiples that are comparable to the utilities sector, rather than being weighed down by the marine arm.

    OCBC pointed out that the energy and utilities segment provides relative stability and also has synergies with the urban solutions business. The marine segment, on the other hand, has been and was likely to remain a key drag for the group.

    A "big move" relating to the marine business has been "long-awaited", OCBC's research team said.

    The proposed transaction will also result in Temasek Holdings having a direct stake in SMM.

    The state investment firm's interest in SCI will remain unchanged, but Temasek could end up with anywhere from 29.9 per cent to 58 per cent of SMM, depending on shareholders' take-up of the rights issue.

    CGS-CIMB's Ms Lim said Temasek having direct control in SMM "paves the way" for a consolidation with Keppel Offshore & Marine.

    READ MORE: Sembcorp is right to cast off its marine unit; both entities will be the better for it