Green goals take a back seat in Denmark's e-car policy

Published Wed, Sep 30, 2015 · 09:50 PM

Copenhagen

DENMARK is planning to almost triple the price of electric cars, including Teslas, and cut pollution taxes on diesel vehicles, according to provisions in the 2016 budget draft.

The government is defending the measures by saying they will help businesses save money and create more jobs. "Things have to be done with reason," Finance Minister Claus Hjort Frederiksen told reporters in Copenhagen on Tuesday.

As the world looks on in disbelief at Volkswagen's emissions scandal, Denmark is pushing through a policy that will undo the previous adminis-tration's efforts to steer consumers towards environmentally friendly vehicles.

Mr Frederiksen plans to phase out tax exemptions on electric cars and impose Denmark's blanket 180 per cent levy on all models, regardless of their emission levels. That means the price of a Tesla Model S is set to increase from about 650,000 kroner (S$130,150) to around 1.8 million kroner.

Marcus Asplund, an economics professor at the Copenhagen Business School, says the tax will inevitably lead to fewer sales of Teslas. But he also says the previous tax policy had given Teslas - ultimately a luxury car - a competitive advantage over rival models such as BMW 5s.

Prof Asplund says he and his wife are now discussing whether to place an order for a Tesla before the new tax becomes effective.

The levy marks Denmark's latest shift away from measures that had once put it at the forefront of innovative policies designed to promote renewable energy. Earlier last month, the government revealed it was abandoning ambitious carbon dioxide emissions targets and dropping plans to become fossil-fuel free by 2050. The new policy was revealed the same day US President Barack Obama made a global appeal for urgent action to fight climate change.

Denmark plans to raise just short of 30 billion kroner on car taxes in 2016, while the Tax Ministry estimates that treating electric cars such as their gasoline and diesel equivalents will add 450 million kroner a year in revenue.

A total of 1,240 electric cars were sold in Denmark during the first half of 2015, up 97 per cent from a year earlier, according to the latest figures from the European Automobile Manufacturers Association. Most of those were Teslas.

"The former government may have promised to keep electric cars exempt from car taxes, but they just forgot one thing: finding the money to do so," Mr Frederiksen said.

According to other provisions contained in the budget draft unveiled on Tuesday, the Liberal government also plans to drop a tax on Nitrogen-Oxide (NOx) emissions, which are generated from burning fossil fuels and are most commonly associated with diesel cars.

Cutting the so-called NOx tax, which was introduced by the previous government to reduce pollution, will save businesses an estimated 240 million kroner in 2016, according to the Tax Ministry.

The loss in revenue to state coffers is equivalent to 0.04 per cent of annual receipts. But the timing of the move, coming at the height of the Volkswagen scandal, makes the political cost potentially higher.

"Removing the NOx tax is both stupid and expensive," said Maria Reumert Gjerding of the opposition Red-Green Alliance. BLOOMBERG