The Business Times

Qantas-VA row over 'takeover' turns ugly

VA chief mulls over suing Qantas CEO for defamation

Published Wed, Nov 20, 2013 · 10:00 PM
Share this article.

[SYDNEY] Virgin Australia (VA) chief John Borghetti yesterday lashed out at "offensive" allegations made by Qantas in an escalating row over foreign ownership, with reports that lawyers had been called in.

It follows Qantas chief Alan Joyce this week blasting what he called a "virtual takeover" of VA by foreign airlines, claiming they were working to destabilise the national carrier.

On Tuesday, Qantas launched an online campaign against a capital raising by Virgin that could leave 72 per cent of the carrier in the hands of Singapore Airlines (SIA), Air New Zealand and Abu Dhabi-based Etihad Airways.

Mr Joyce, who was in Canberra yesterday to lobby politicians, said it would result in an "unfair playing field".

He claimed the foreign backing allowed Virgin to run at a loss by setting uncompetitively low prices to win customers from Qantas, an allegation Mr Borghetti denied.

"To say that Virgin Australia is driven by a strategy of uncompetitively low prices and irrational behaviour is offensive and absurd," he told the company's annual general meeting in Brisbane.

"The airline is run rationally with good management and a view to creating a long-term sustainable and profitable business." He added: "We have embraced change and competition and adapted our business to it."

Mr Borghetti is so furious that he is seeking legal advice on whether there are grounds to sue Mr Joyce for defamation, Fairfax Media reported, although the airline could not immediately confirm this.

In reaction to the legal threat, Qantas said: "We're very comfortable with the observations and statements we've made.

"The question of motive behind Virgin's commercial decisions is one that market analysts and commentators have been asking for some time, and have rightly repeated in light of the latest equity injection," a spokesman added.

SIA, Air NZ and Etihad already own 63 per cent of Qantas' main domestic rival.

Mr Joyce wrote to Prime Minister Tony Abbott and all state governments this week demanding they "fully examine the motives behind the virtual takeover of Virgin Australia by foreign airlines, and to prevent destabilising of the domestic aviation industry, local tourism and jobs".

Qantas said the situation was compounded by the disadvantage it experienced from the restrictions imposed by the Qantas Sale Act when it was privatised in 1995, which limits foreign ownership in the national carrier to 49 per cent. - AFP

BT is now on Telegram!

For daily updates on weekdays and specially selected content for the weekend. Subscribe to

Transport & Logistics


Get the latest coverage and full access to all BT premium content.


Browse corporate subscription here