ESR-Reit, ALog Trust object to proxy advisors' criticism of process in proposed merger

Jude Chan
Published Mon, Jan 24, 2022 · 08:51 AM

    THE managers of ESR-Reit and Ara Logos Logistics Trust (ALog Trust) have hit back at criticism over the lack of transparency in their processes leading up to the proposed merger of the 2 real estate investment trusts (Reits).

    This comes after proxy advisory firms Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS) and Glass Lewis raised concerns about the deal process. Both also recommended that unitholders of ALog Trust vote against the proposed merger.

    ESR-Reit and ALog Trust have proposed a scheme of arrangement that would see ESR-Reit's trustee buy all the units of ALog Trust for a scheme consideration of S$0.97 per ALog Trust unit.

    ISS called the process surrounding the related party deal "questionable".

    "A robust sale process would offer comfort to unitholders that alternatives were evaluated and deemed inferior, but the available disclosure appears to indicate exclusive negotiations with the ESR-Reit sponsor," it added.

    In a separate report, Glass Lewis noted that ALog Trust had "not publicly disclosed any substantive information regarding the process that was followed to arrive at the proposed merger".

    "We cannot (therefore) comment in detail regarding the depth and thoroughness of the pre-signing review undertaken by the ALog Trust manager here, including the length of the relevant negotiations with representatives of ESR-Reit and the extent to which alternative transactions were earnestly considered," it added.

    In a media briefing on Monday (Jan 24), Karen Lee, chief executive of ALog Trust's manager, said criticisms over the deal process were "grossly unfair".

    "We know that there has been quite a lot of focus around our process," Lee said. "I need to emphasise and make this very clear to everyone here that we have been as transparent as we can be. We think the comments made are unfair."

    "A merger is a strategic collaborative process, undertaken between like-minded entities to jointly come together to maximise future value upside in a win-win transaction. We are represented by reputable financial advisors and legal counsels, and we are confident that the process undertaken is in line with market practice," she added.

    Lee also pointed out "precedent cases" in the market where sponsors have merged Reits under them through similar processes.

    For instance, in 2020, CapitaLand had merged CapitaLand Mall Trust with CapitaLand Commercial Trust to create CapitaLand Integrated Commercial Trust, while Frasers Property merged Frasers Logistics & Industrial Trust with Frasers Commercial Trust to create Frasers Commercial & Logistics Trust.

    "Interestingly, no questions on processes were raised for the previous Reit mergers we have observed so far," Lee said. "What we have done here, the process is similar. We are not doing anything that deviates from normal market practice."

    One dissimilarity with past Reit mergers, however, is that ESR-Reit and ALog Trust did not yet share the same sponsor at the time the merger was proposed.

    The "mothership deal" - the acquisition of ALog Trust's sponsor Ara Asset Management by ESR-Reit's sponsor ESR Cayman - was only completed on Jan 20, 2022.

    In response to a question of whether there would have been less scrutiny over the deal process if the ESR-Reit-ALog Trust merger had been proposed after, chief executive officer of the ESR-Reit manager Adrian Chui pointed out that a conflict of interest between ESR-Reit and ALog Trust now exists following the completion of ESR Cayman's acquisition of Ara Asset Management.

    "The conflict has started. So if tomorrow there is a third-party asset that is made available that both of us want to go and buy, don't you think that we're bidding against each other?" he said.

    "That is the reason why we had to start (the process of the proposed merger between ESR-Reit and ALog Trust) when the announcement of the so-called mothership deal - Ara's acquisition by ESR Cayman - came. We started to look and think: 'We better try to do this deal right now'," Chui said.

    Chui said the group was "very surprised" over criticism of the deal process.

    "If you look at all the other 5 Reit mergers that have been successful... ours is actually the most compelling and straightforward because we are in the same sector, have overlapping mandates, and share the same common sponsor," he added.

    The Reit managers had on Jan 22 announced an upward revision in the scheme consideration for the proposed merger - from S$0.95 to S$0.97 - following the issuances of the 2 proxy reports.

    ALog Trust unitholders would now receive S$0.097 in cash and 1.7729 in ESR-Reit units for every ALog unit, up from S$0.095 in cash and 1.6765 in ESR-Reit units previously.

    "ESR-Reit's revised merger scheme values ALog Trust at (around) 5 per cent higher than its October 2021 proposal," said RHB analyst Vijay Natarajan in a Jan 24 report.

    Based on the 1-month volume weighted average price of S$0.4716 per ESR-Reit unit up to Oct 14, 2021 - being the last trading day prior to the announcement of the proposed merger - the consideration per ALog Trust unit would be S$0.933.

    This is 5.3 per cent higher than the value of S$0.886 previously.

    Calculated based on ESR-Reit's last closing price of S$0.465 per unit on Oct 14, 2021, the revised scheme consideration would be 5.4 per cent higher.

    "We strongly believe the proposed merger is a necessary step in creating a single larger entity which can tap into enormous growth opportunities," Natarajan added. "In addition, the size and scale of the larger entity is critical and better positions it in the face of interest rate hikes from lower cost of capital along with good diversification benefits."

    In separate reports, Natarajan recommended that unitholders of both ESR-Reit and ALog Trust vote in favour of the revised deal.

    Units in ESR-Reit tumbled 2.2 per cent or S$0.01 to close at S$0.445 on Jan 25, while units in Alog Trust closed 1.69 per cent or S$0.015 lower at S$0.875.