Is Jurong Island’s carbon test bed too small and conservative? A*Star institute head thinks not

Research institute executive director Ng Wai Kiong notes the need to derisk investments in scaling up nascent CCU technologies

Published Sun, Apr 28, 2024 · 04:30 PM
    • A*Star’s Institute of Sustainability for Chemicals, Energy and Environment on Jurong Island. The carbon capture and utilisation translational test bed, which was first announced in 2021, is still in the planning stage.
    • A*Star’s Institute of Sustainability for Chemicals, Energy and Environment on Jurong Island. The carbon capture and utilisation translational test bed, which was first announced in 2021, is still in the planning stage. PHOTO: A*STAR

    FOR carbon capture technologies to attract investments and scale up, pilot projects cannot be too large. That is the verdict of Dr Ng Wai Kiong, who is the acting executive director of the first and only research institute on Jurong Island. A smaller scale is less risky for companies involved, he said, and offers the right opportunities for testing.

    The Institute of Sustainability for Chemicals, Energy and Environment that Dr Ng leads is part of the Agency for Science, Technology and Research (A*Star), a statutory board that supports Singapore’s research and development needs.

    The institute was set up in 2022 to work on shrinking the carbon footprint of Singapore’s industrial sector. One possibility is carbon capture and utilisation (CCU). This involves capturing carbon dioxide (CO2), breaking out the C component of the CO2, and combining it with hydrogen to create various types of hydrocarbons – which could then be used as fuel or for other industrial applications.

    A*Star and two other government agencies – the Economic Development Board and JTC – are in the planning stages for a CCU test bed facility to do just that. There is some dispute, however, over how large the facility should be.

    Surbana Jurong’s managing director for energy and industrial Tan Wooi Leong said research that is successful in the lab often fails when attempts are made to scale up. He therefore believes the CCU test bed facility should be an industrial-scale one right from the get-go.

    There is also little time to lose, Tan said, as it typically takes five to six more years – on top of the years required for a pilot to reap findings – to scale up processes to such levels.

    At the risk of losing the oil and petrochemical giants already operating on Jurong Island to other chemical hubs around the world, Singapore should bite the bullet despite the hefty price tag associated with CCU research, Tan added.

    Petrochemical companies, particularly those headquartered in Europe, are under severe pressure to green their operations – which means they may leave if they find greener pastures.

    Industrial-scale tests typically involve substantial infrastructure, specialised equipment and dedicated facilities. Such a set-up could have the capacity to process thousands of kilograms worth of hydrocarbons a day, although the figure can vary significantly depending on the type of hydrocarbon being produced.

    The planned facility for Jurong Island is smaller in comparison. Dr Ng said CCU tests on Jurong Island will stick to a scale of 100 to 200 kg a day. This is still greater than the scale used in labs, which would typically be measured in milligrams and grams.

    At this in-between scale of 100 to 200 kg, he said, tests and validation works can be performed “swiftly”, at two to three times the speed of conventional approaches. While it would typically take a company two to three years to test a new process, the test bed could shorten the process to six to nine months.

    The scale of operations of the test bed would also let companies “optimise their technology under industrially relevant conditions” before making further investment decisions, he added.

    Several other initiatives are being introduced to help support companies using the test bed, all of which should help derisk the testing and scaling up of CCU technologies.

    Prior to the testing phase, companies can also tap A*Star’s Accelerated Catalyst Development Platform. The platform uses machine learning and artificial intelligence to quicken the process of discovering catalysts for CO2 conversion.

    A high-throughput facility at A*Star’s Institute of Sustainability for Chemicals, Energy and Environment, which is working on converting CO2 to useful chemicals and fuels under its accelerated catalyst development platform. PHOTO: A*STAR

    Pointing out that CO2 is a “very challenging molecule”, as its bonds are very strong and breaking them requires a lot of energy, Dr Ng said finding a good catalyst is key to cutting the activation temperature or pressure to a minimum.

    A number of carbon conversion technologies can be tested in parallel under the “plug-and-play modular” test bed. That saves time as well, he said.

    The test bed will operate on a “co-working” concept – some infrastructure, such as specialised reactors, can be shared. This means there will be no need for each company to buy its own specialised reactors to get its prototype going.

    Certain building blocks of the hardware will also be ready for assembly, he said, so companies will not need to order and custom make their own as they go about experimenting with a new process.

    Such an approach has been validated by international experts, Dr Ng added. Plans are “very close” to implementation, and the authorities have been engaging many industrial players.

    CCU is not the only decarbonisation pathway Singapore can explore, of course. An example of another decarbonisation pathway that companies are taking interest in involves the production of hydrogen by cracking ammonia, a carbon-free molecule.

    Dutch tank storage company Vopak and French industrial gas supplier Air Liquide had teamed up in March to study how they might produce and distribute low-carbon hydrogen on Jurong Island through this method.

    Dr Ng said his institute is open to various pathways, adding: “Depending on what their interest is, we can put in the right (building block) so that we can scale it and test it under close to actual plant conditions.

    “With that, (companies) will be given the confidence to move to the next step, which is deployment on the site itself. That’s what we focus on.”