Technology, economics raise doubt about carbon capture’s promise in Asia

Michelle Quah

Michelle Quah

Published Mon, Feb 6, 2023 · 05:50 AM
    • Carbon capture facilities, such as this one in China, are gaining in popularity and interest; but what are some of the pitfalls investors in such projects should be aware of? PHOTO: REUTERS
    • Carbon capture facilities, such as this one in China, are gaining in popularity and interest; but what are some of the pitfalls investors in such projects should be aware of? PHOTO: REUTERS PHOTO: REUTERS

    CARBON capture solutions are considered by many governments and corporates to be integral to their attempts to achieving net-zero emissions, but ongoing challenges pose a threat to their advancement and acceptance – and cast a pall on the prospects of investments in such projects.

    In South-east Asia, in particular, such challenges come in the form of land scarcity, cost, a lack of regulatory maturity and competition from low-carbon alternatives. This is in addition to issues that plague carbon capture solutions globally, such as the uncertainty of their climate benefits, and current technology being unproven at scale.

    “Given existing challenges with regard to technological progress and achieving targeted capture capacity, there is considerable uncertainty for investors whether industrial projects with carbon capture, utilisation and storage (CCUS) will be able, in the long term, to compete with low-carbon alternatives in their respective sectors,” said Kathrin Wartmann, associate director of climate risk at ratings and data provider Sustainable Fitch, in a recent report.

    CCUS refers to various technologies that capture carbon dioxide released through industrial processes or fossil fuel power generation. The captured gas is then stored, typically deep underground, or reused.

    Wartmann, who authored the report Carbon Capture, Utilisation and Storage: A Range of Investment Risks, said that while the vast majority of global carbon capture capacity – almost 60 per cent – exists in North America, the Asia-Pacific region is the second-largest market with almost 15 per cent of current global capacity. The region is also expected to witness one of the largest expansions of carbon capture capacity, in the short term.

    Arjun Sethi, partner, regional head and chairman for the Asia-Pacific region at global management consulting firm Kearney, said CCUS has wide applicability to carbon-heavy sectors such as agriculture and transportation, but shines the brightest in providing relevant options to hard-to-abate heavy industries that have few other decarbonisation options, such as cement, iron and steel, and chemical industries.

    “We saw this increasing interest play out in 2021, when at least seven potential projects were established to develop CCUS capacities in Asia. Some examples include planned projects in Indonesia and Singapore, the establishment of the Asia CCUS Network to facilitate collaboration, and a CCUS research partnership with Singapore and Australia,” he said.

    Still, significant hurdles to its development – and hence, uncertainties when it comes to investment in CCUS – abound, both within the region and beyond.

    David Clive Broadstock, senior research fellow and acting division head at the Energy Studies Institute in the National University of Singapore, said: “Many of the considerations being worked through in the South-east Asia region are the same as those currently being addressed in the rest of the world...

    “Among these: What are the most promising technological approaches? Where is the geographic potential for deployment? How can public and government acceptability be secured – and what might stop this from happening? When will commercial viability be achievable, and how may carbon pricing systems impact this?”

    Jackson Seng, vice-president of sustainability and strategy at Schneider Electric, a European multinational that specialises in digital automation and energy management, pointed out: “CCUS technology is still in its early stages, and investments in CCUS will depend on sustainability regulations as well as development of the global carbon market.”

    Broadstock agreed that CCUS technologies are not yet at a level of technological readiness or maturity that they can be deployed at scale; finding suitable land packets and staying on top of differing supply chain logistics issues, depending on the technology in question, are among the challenges.

    Getting the public’s buy-in can also be tricky. “Technologically feasible solutions do not guarantee public acceptability, and there are already discussions in the public domain regarding the concern of carbon leaks in the unlikely, but not impossible, eventuality of a CCUS facility storage failure,” he said.

    Sethi shared Seng’s view that CCUS development would depend in part on regulatory regimes here. “South-east Asian markets lack mature carbon tax and trading regimes that have CCUS-specific regulations, such as permitting requirements, site selection, and liability for stored CO2 (carbon dioxide). Without such mechanisms, CCUS investor confidence in the region will be limited, and scalable growth will be elusive.”

    He said cost is another significant hurdle: “CCUS offer unfavourable economics for developing markets’ industries, as they require significant upfront investments that impede the profitability of key industries.”

    Such challenges pose considerable risks to investors, especially given the often lengthy investment horizon for CCUS projects, Wartmann said.

    “Investors need to consider not only the technical maturity of a specific CCUS project, but also whether the potential availability of a wider range of decarbonisation options or low-carbon alternatives will impact the profitability of the project.”

    Like elsewhere in the world, CCUS projects in this region face the same competition from increasingly cheaper renewable energy. “Many low-carbon alternatives to CCUS are becoming cheaper, and continuing innovation in energy and process efficiency and low-carbon processes are also weakening the economic viability of existing processes or products combined with CCUS,” Wartmann said.

    However, she added, industrial assets – ranging from coal-fired power plants to steel and cement factories – tend to be younger in the Asia-Pacific than in other regions such as Europe or North America. “These assets are often still far away from retirement age, and they might have a stronger economic case to invest in retrofitting the assets with CCUS facilities.”

    Targeted policies to support CCUS investment in the region might be needed to develop the sector.

    “Moving forward, regional cooperation, prudent government leadership, and support from international financial bodies will be key to addressing impediments and unlocking the potential of CCUS in the region,” Sethi said.