You are here
Is China preparing to start a huge currency war?
[SHANGHAI] China has entered the global monetary-easing fray, along with more than a dozen other economies, after its central bank surprised investors by cutting reserve requirements 50 basis points to spur lending and combat deflation. But Beijing may be raring for an even bigger and more perilous fight - in the currency markets.
Reducing the amount of cash that banks are required to set aside (to 19.5 per cent), as China has just done, is largely symbolic - a don't-panic-we're-on-top-of-things reassurance to international markets and local property developers. Still, the move is also an inflection point. China is in all likelihood about to loosen monetary policy considerably to support economic growth. If global conditions worsen, China's one-year lending rate, now at 5.6 per cent, could head toward zero.
At the same time, something else is afoot in Beijing could have even greater global impact. The central bank is cooking up measures to widen the band in which its currency trades. People's Bank of China officials say it's about limiting volatility as capital zooms in and out of the economy. Let's call it what it really is: the first step toward yuan depreciation and currency war.
As China grapples with its slowest growth in 24 years, President Xi Jinping is under pressure to stimulate the economy. Yet that would run afoul of his pledges to curb runaway debt and credit (the latter jumped about $20 trillion from 2009 to 2014). What better way to gin up growth without adding to China's bubbles than by sharply weakening the exchange rate? A cheaper yuan would boost exports and buy Xi more time to recalibrate growth engines away from excessive investment and debt. "The real economy desperately needs a weaker yuan," says economist Diana Choyleva of Lombard Street Research.
The question is, does the rest of the world?
Any significant drop in the yuan would prompt Japan to unleash another quantitative-easing blitz. The same goes for South Korea, whose exports are already hurting. Singapore might feel compelled to expand upon last week's move to weaken its dollar. Before long, officials in Bangkok, Hanoi, Jakarta, Manila, Taipei and even Latin America might act to protect their economies' competitiveness.
China may be feeling increased urgency as it looks around the Asia-Pacific region. On Feb. 3, Australia surprised markets with a 25 basis-point rate cut, a step that Christy Tan at National Australia Bank says "stoked speculation of a currency war." That move, she says, might have been what prompted the PBOC to suggest that it's "preparing possible responses" to shifting financial dynamics.
For China, Japan represents the biggest provocateur. The 30 per cent drop in the yen under Prime Minister Shinzo Abe is slamming Chinese industry. Key beneficiaries of the policy such as Toyota and Sony (both projected huge profits this week) are lowering prices to gain market share abroad, effectively exporting deflation. Abe also gives Beijing political cover to devalue. It would be hypocritical, after all, for US Senators Lindsey Graham and Charles Schumer to bash China for currency manipulation and not Japan.
There's obvious danger in so many economies engaging in this race to the bottom. It will create unprecedented levels of volatility in markets and set in motion flows of hot money that overwhelm developing economies, inflating asset bubbles and pushing down bond rates irrationally low. Consider that Germany's 10-year debt yields briefly fell below Japan's (they're both now in the 0.35 per cent to 0.36 per cent range). In a world in which the Bank of Japan, the European Central Bank and the Federal Reserve are running competing QE programs, the task of pricing risk can get mighty fuzzy.
What's more, Asia's currency rivalries may be self- defeating. As Raghuram Rajan, governor of the Reserve Bank of India, told Bloomberg Television, "If you're not increasing domestic activity but depreciating your exchange rate, you're essentially drawing demand from the rest of the world." Risks abound for China. Devaluing, Mr Choyleva says, could expose the economy to foreign-currency debt, and "the market has no idea about the true size of this exposure." The real fireworks, though, would be in Asian markets. A competition to ease monetary policy is one thing. A currency war with the world's biggest trading nation could turn into a crisis.