All but one US top bank pass Fed stress test
Zions Bancorporation comes in below one of the central bank's main capital thresholds
Washington
THE Federal Reserve's annual stress tests found 29 of the 30 largest US banks could withstand a deep recession and still pay dividends, fuelling speculation about which firms will win approval next week to raise payouts.
Zions Bancorporation is the only lender that came in below one of the Fed's main capital thresholds in results released on Thursday by the US central bank that simulated a severe economic slump.
All 30 firms, including Zions, topped the minimum in a separate scenario of rising interest rates. The Fed said capital levels have improved since the 2008 financial crisis and the largest banks are better-positioned to lend and meet their financial commitments.
"The average person who relies on the banking system should be happy," said Dan Ryan, head of PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP's global financial regulation practice, calling the financial system safe. "Next week will tell us whether banks and bank shareholders will be happy."
The Fed runs an annual two-part stress test required under the Dodd-Frank Act to ensure banks have enough capital and cash to withstand shocks that may threaten their survival. The goal is to head off a recurrence of taxpayer-funded bailouts as in 2008, when government rescues averted the collapse of some of the world's largest lenders. Firms that fail a second round of tests released next week may have to forgo stock buybacks and higher dividends.
Total projected loan losses for all 30 banks differed widely between the two scenarios. Under the adverse scenario of rising rates, banks lose US$267 billion on all loans, including credit cards, commercial real estate, and mortgages. Under the severely adverse conditions, loan losses total almost US$100 billion more, or US$366 billion.
Fed supervisors this year scrutinised risks from litigation, counterparty failure, and high-yield loans as they guide banks toward higher capital buffers against financial and economic shocks.
Banks can't pass or fail the test released on Thursday, which doesn't take into account management actions to preserve capital. In the second round of tests released on March 26, regulators will judge whether those actions, such as dividend cuts, keep banks above the minimum Tier 1 common ratio of 5 per cent over nine quarters in harsh economic scenarios.
Investors bid up bank stocks before Thursday's results were released after the official close of trading. The KBW Bank Index, which includes 24 of the largest lenders, rose 2.2 per cent for its best showing since Nov 8 and its highest close since September 2008.
Zions led gainers with a 3.2 per cent increase, JPMorgan Chase & Co added 3.1 per cent and Bank of New York Mellon Corp advanced 3 per cent. They were little changed in after-hours trading.
Fed officials have cautioned that even banks that exceeded all the thresholds in Thursday's test may still find their requests for higher payouts rejected next week if regulators find the quality of the planning is flawed. The scrutiny can extend to management, systems and even boards of directors.
The bar on capital for the largest banks will continue to rise for the next several years, a Fed official said on a conference call with reporters. The official cited international agreements among regulators and the central bank's own increasing demands for better risk management.
The test included five regulatory ratios, and among the six largest US banks, Bank of America Corp (BOA) and Morgan Stanley's levels slid closest to the regulatory minimum in the Fed's worst-case scenario. The firms came within one percentage point of falling below the 4 per cent minimum on the Tier 1 leverage ratio under the "severely adverse" version, with BOA's ratio at 4.6 per cent and Morgan Stanley's at 4.7 per cent.
Plans for higher dividends and buybacks still could pass muster next week because analysts have predicted that the two firms will ask the Fed for less than the full amount they would be mathematically entitled to pay.
BOA's US$2.13 trillion in average total assets shows it could return about US$12.8 billion to investors without falling below the leverage threshold, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. The lender may have requested an average US$7.2 billion payout over the next 12 months, according to four analysts surveyed by Bloomberg.
Morgan Stanley's US$830 billion of average total assets shows it can return about US$5.81 billion before falling below the minimum. The lender may have asked to return US$2.1 billion, according to the estimates.
Qualitative measures are more of a judgment call by the Fed, and in past years, bankers have found their case weakened when results from their own internal calculations differed widely from the Fed's.
This year, BOA estimated in a statement that loan losses in a worst-case scenario would be about 45 per cent less than what the Federal Reserve projected at US$30.3 billion. Wells Fargo & Co, the largest home lender, said its hypothetical loss would be US$26.8 billion, or about half the Fed's result.
The Fed said that in a severely adverse scenario, the minimum Tier 1 common ratio of Zions is 3.5 per cent. That's below the 5 per cent threshold, one of the regulatory measures used in next week's test.
Banks under this test face a deep recession, with US gross domestic product collapsing at a 6.1 per cent annual rate in the first quarter of 2014 and real disposable income falling at a 2.4 per cent pace.
Zions has already notified the Fed it will re-submit its plan after determining that losses triggered by new banking regulations will be less than anticipated. James Abbott, a spokesman for Zions, didn't respond to an e-mail and phone call seeking comment. Bloomberg
TRENDING NOW
What shattered Crystal Jade? How the culinary empire shrank from 120 to just 9 outlets
SGX gold-linked counters lose their shine as the precious metal hits one-year low
‘The next 40 years’: SingLand CEO Jonathan Eu on remaking Marina Square
Alibaba sued for allegedly hiding ties to suspected spy Alice Huang from Megaspeed