When budgeting goes wrong
Setting a fixed amount to spend every day may make you spend more than you bargained for
THIS month and the next, I need to figure out how to spend $80 worth of NS45 Safra vouchers - a one-off hongbao given out early last year to thank all national servicemen for their contribution to defence. They expire on March 31. The next month may very well see consumer spending across the island tick up as others like me, who have procrastinated spending the vouchers till the last moment, rush to cash in.
I will probably end up spending them at NTUC to buy some necessities like shampoo, washing powder or vegetables and fruit. But I am also tempted to use the vouchers to eat out at a restaurant - something I don't usually do because I find it too expensive. But by having a fixed amount to spend, I am encouraged to do so regardless of the value I perceive from the meal.
When we speak about budgeting, we usually talk about setting a fixed amount to spend every day, week or month. But sometimes, knowing this amount can have perverse consequences. Instead of spending only when they need to, people willingly spend to their self-set limits, spending more than they otherwise would.
In an experiment three years ago, financial advice software provider HelloWallet sent users a personalised email on Friday evenings alerting them to how much they can safely spend over the weekend. The idea is that when people go out on Saturday and Sunday, they blow their salary on things they shouldn't, and if they are reminded of their budget, they won't do so.
The experiment backfired. "What we found is that we systematically increased spending on the weekend; it had the opposite effect because we were basically giving people permission to spend," HelloWallet CEO Matt Fellowes told Bloomberg in a recent interview.
And herein lies the lesson for employers, policymakers and individuals trying to achieve cost savings through budgeting: having the right incentives is critical. Good ideas in theory can have unintended consequences in practice.
Where personal finance is concerned, setting a strict amount to spend every day might not be helpful for real life, when spending fluctuates depending on one's circumstances. If a close friend gets married and you didn't budget for the hongbao, for example, you may very well fail to hit your savings goals for the month. Yet, giving the hongbao is necessary.
What might instead work better is to focus on the question of "why am I spending" instead of "how much should I spend".
One can understand one's spending habits by tracking expenses closely, and thinking about whether these expenses are truly necessary.
Another important question to ask is "what am I saving for". Achieve clarity on these goals, and you can gain power over your finances. To all readers, Gong Xi Fa Cai!
TRENDING NOW
Motoring tycoon Peter Kwee is back in court: Here are his previous legal battles
Demand, tech capabilities position Apac and AI as Skyscanner’s next growth frontiers: CEO Bryan Batista
Beyond the greenback, Vietnam’s big borrowers turn to Asian-currency bonds
Nvidia’s outlook cut to stable by Moody’s on governance concerns