Asean Business logo
SPONSORED BYUOB logo

Gig economy taking off but labour observers flag insurance and CPF concerns

Key issues include workplace insurance and retirement savings

Annabeth Leow

Annabeth Leow

Published Mon, Aug 27, 2018 · 03:53 AM

    Singapore

    THE gig economy may be taking off, but labour and economy experts here are more concerned about traditional self-employed workers, such as private tutors and taxi drivers.

    Unemployment and lower wages are not the main issues for the freelancers tapping digital apps and platforms for work, said industry watchers. They cited instead old bugbears such as patchy insurance coverage.

    "Freelance work in the gig economy can be quite risky, and as such, for the most part, particular groups of individuals might be drawn to it," National University of Singapore economics professor Basant Kapur told The Business Times. He said that these include young people living with their parents; older folks with adequate housing and healthcare; and those "who have accumulated sufficient working experience and contacts to be able to strike out on their own".

    Lessons from other countries have shown that the trend is not so much about the gig economy as "alternative work that breaks the old model of permanent employment in favour of task-based, contract-based, and outsourced work", according to labour economist Walter Theseira, an associate professor of economics at the Singapore University of Social Sciences.

    Concerns flagged by labour observers have centred on issues such as workplace insurance and Central Provident Fund (CPF) retirement savings. A tripartite workgroup on self-employed workers released recommendations in February that included mediation for payment disputes, a contribute-as-you-earn model for healthcare savings and occupation-specific competency frameworks.

    While noting that the problem pre-dates the gig economy, Dr Theseira said: "Since the CPF system is what we rely on for social security, this means such workers are effectively uncovered unless they also hold a formal employment job, or unless they make voluntary contributions...

    "The majority of own-account workers are not in the highest income groups, and certainly 'gigs' are not high-income, so this is an ongoing policy issue."

    Michele Chao, a tax partner at Deloitte Singapore, said that the challenge could extend to housing, as many Singapore residents tap their CPF accounts for property purchases.

    "Potentially, without the stability of income and CPF contributions, home ownership may no longer be affordable," she said. "In this respect, we may see a trend of such individuals who may have to continue to live with their parents or may have to stay in rental properties in Singapore."

    Ride-hailing firm Grab has touted how its private-hire drivers and food delivery riders are covered by free personal accident insurance on the job. It also offers drivers the option of extra coverage so they can still draw an income if they wind up in hospital.

    But Sabrina Sia, global employer services leader at Deloitte Singapore, suggested: "Although some companies like Grab do provide personal accident insurance to their drivers and the passengers, the government could do more to encourage or provide tax incentives to companies that engage such self-employed individuals, to provide them with medical and personal accident coverage."

    Yet manpower watchers are less worried that gig work might mask unemployment or under-employment by padding jobs and wages figures.

    "We already have a fairly dynamic labour market compared to many other countries, because employment conditions are more flexible," said Dr Theseira. "Another factor to consider is that surveys from the US show a substantial fraction of those engaged in the gig economy do so to supplement income from another job. This means that the impact on unemployment would then be more muted."

    Maybank Kim Eng economist Chua Hak Bin, too, said that flexible job arrangements "can also help cushion the economy in a downturn, when some workers face retrenchment".

    Deloitte's Ms Chao told BT: "Due to the relatively low barriers to entry, individuals may decide against seeking formal employment and choose to be self-employed as an alternative to generate income in order to be self-sufficient or in times when they have difficulties finding suitable employment."

    Meanwhile, Yaamini Pillay, manager for commerce contract at recruitment consultancy Robert Walters Singapore, said: "The relationship between inflation and unemployment has traditionally been an inverse correlation . . . If interim workers expect prices to rise, they will demand higher wages so that their real wages are constant when they shift into a permanent role in the future."

    The Ministry of Manpower reported that close to three-fifths of own-account workers - a sub-set of self-employed workers, without employees of their own - earned more than S$20,000 last year, compared with less than half of such workers in 2016.

    Still, Dr Theseira cautioned: "A key problem when it comes to assessing wages in the gig economy is that we don't know to what extent wages reflect real value versus subsidies for growth from firms . . . The net effect is that we can't tell whether the wages paid are sustainable in the long run. An excellent example is the private-hire industry, where effective wages have fallen with the end of aggressive driver incentives since Uber left the market."

    The most visible workers in the gig economy may be food delivery riders with companies' distinctive cooler bags strapped to their backs, and private-hire drivers at ride-hailing firms.

    And their numbers have grown. Deliveroo had some 6,000 food delivery riders in Singapore as at end-July - more than double the 2,860 on staff in December 2017, according to its financial results - while rival Foodpanda had 3,000 riders here. Official figures put the pool of licensed private-hire drivers at around 22,000, in early July.

    Own-account workers numbered 202,900 in mid-2017, or a decade-high 9.3 per cent of the labour market, according to manpower survey data. By the year's end, the number of such workers was up to 223,500.

    But Dr Theseira noted that most self-employed people are in "traditional roles" like real estate or insurance agents. While "there have been no comprehensive studies conducted in Singapore yet on the growth of the gig economy", the two special surveys conducted by the Manpower Ministry "do not provide evidence there is any meteoric rise in the gig economy in Singapore, or in own-account workers more generally", he said.

    Still, Dr Chua said that the landscape could change based on industry events. "The last few years saw the fall of taxi drivers and rise in private-hire car drivers with the rise of ride-hailing apps. But with Uber's exit and stricter licensing requirements for private hire car drivers, we expect an increase in the number of taxi drivers, as indicated by ComfortDelGro, and fall in private-hire car drivers as the returns fall with lower 'bonuses'," said Dr Chua, referring to the driver incentives that ride-hailing firms dangled amid hotter competition in the past.

    He added: "Tighter regulations on Airbnb and the more recent property (cooling) measures will also likely cut the number of real estate agents."