China tightens reins on edtech in new blow to private tutors

    • New restrictions unveiled by China limit the fees and operating times of private tutoring services for primary and middle school students.
    • New restrictions unveiled by China limit the fees and operating times of private tutoring services for primary and middle school students. PHOTO: REUTERS
    Published Thu, Dec 29, 2022 · 07:39 PM

    CHINA will further tighten oversight over its battered online education sector, in a clear signal that Beijing is not yet prepared to unshackle the private tutoring arena despite loosening curbs on tech giants. 

    Edtech companies plunged after the Ministry of Education published a new set of restrictions that limit the fees and operating times of private tutoring services for primary and middle school students.

    Firms offering non-curricular tutoring will be required to end physical classes by 8.30 pm and online sessions by 9 pm, while limiting one-time charges to 5,000 yuan (S$968.14) and mandating a special trust account with state-designated banks for pre-paid fees.

    Scholar Education Group fell as much as 30 per cent in Hong Kong on Thursday, the biggest drop since last July, when China first rolled out sweeping curbs that decimated a once-thriving US$100 billion sector.

    New Oriental Education dropped 9.3 per cent at one point, with similar or sharper declines from peers including Virscend Education Co, China Education Group and Hope Education Group.

    The new policies further pummel private education services, which have struggled since the government’s surprise move last year to ban those companies from making profits, raising capital, or going public.

    BT in your inbox

    Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox.

    The latest restrictions from Beijing, which has labelled the sector “broken” and “hijacked by capital”, appear in line with President Xi Jinping’s broader objective of reining in China’s increasingly powerful private sector.

    Thursday’s proclamation echoed some of the phraseology employed during 2021’s clampdown. Among other things, tutoring firms that want to list shares will be subject to a strict regulatory review to avoid “barbaric growth” of the industry.

    In a document issued by 13 agencies, including the nation’s top securities regulator, the government pledged to address outstanding issues in the quality, safety, standards and pricing of tutoring services to alleviate household financial burden.

    Tutoring firms will be required to meet the new regulatory standards by June 2023 or face “serious consequences”.

    “It is necessary to clarify the non-curriculum tutoring organisation’s domestic and overseas market standards and processes, to strictly control the gates, and to do a good job in regulatory supervision and guidance to prevent barbaric growth,” the agencies said. 

    The curbs come even as the Xi administration has shown a willingness to dial back a longstanding clampdown on tech giants to galvanise economic growth, including by resuming game licences for Tencent Holdings and Netease.

    Nearly three years of punishing zero-Covid restrictions have hobbled swathes of the world’s No 2 economy, and a sudden reversal towards reopening suggested officials are keen to push for a recovery.

    China’s education technology sector grew into a US$100 billion juggernaut as companies catered to parents seeking to give their children every advantage.

    That explosive expansion drew billions from the likes of Alibaba Group Holding and Tencent, as well as global investors like Temasek and Tiger Global Management.

    But a backlash mounted against firms that employed hard-sell tactics to guilt parents into paying high sums for after-school tutoring.

    Many experts criticised the proliferation of costly online classes for a variety of social ills, from poverty and disillusioned youth to a rapidly falling birth rate.

    All that coincided with Beijing’s growing desire to assert control over an economy increasingly powered by data-rich Internet firms, which culminated in the Internet industry crackdown of 2021. 

    Many of China’s most prominent online tutoring firms have since either shut, downsized or pivoted to alternative businesses, including livestreaming. BLOOMBERG

    Share with us your feedback on BT's products and services