Elon Musk loses bid to end US SEC ‘muzzle’ over tweets

A FEDERAL appeals court on Monday (May 15) rejected Elon Musk’s bid to modify or end his 2018 securities fraud settlement with the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) that required a Tesla lawyer to approve some of his tweets in advance.

The 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan rejected Musk’s claim that the SEC exploited his consent decree to conduct bad-faith, harassing investigations that violated his First Amendment free speech rights under the US Constitution.

Musk’s decree resolved an SEC lawsuit accusing him of defrauding investors with an Aug 7, 2018, tweet that he had “funding secured” to take his electric car company private.

It required an advance review of tweets that might contain material information about Tesla. Musk and Tesla each also paid US$20 million in civil fines, and Musk gave up his role as chairman.

In the appeal, Musk’s lawyers called the pre-approval mandate a “government-imposed muzzle” that amounted to an illegal prior restraint on his speech.

But the three-judge appeals court panel said the SEC had opened just two subsequent inquiries into Musk’s tweets, and those tweets “plausibly violated” the decree’s terms.

GET BT IN YOUR INBOX DAILY

Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox.

Sign UpVIEW ALL

The panel said the SEC’s “limited, appropriate inquiries, in this case, have not made compliance with the consent decree ‘substantially more onerous’” for Musk, as he had argued.

It also said Musk chose to allow screening of his tweets, and had no right to revisit the matter “because he has now changed his mind”.

Alex Spiro, a lawyer for Musk, said in an email: “We will seek further review and continue to bring attention to the important issue of the government constraint on speech.”

The SEC declined to comment.

Monday’s decision upheld an April 2022 ruling by US district judge Lewis Liman in Manhattan.

Liman called Musk’s arguments a “bemoaning” of requirements he no longer wanted to adhere to now that Tesla had “become, in his estimation, all but invincible”.

Musk bought Twitter for US$44 billion in October and runs rocket and spacecraft manufacturer SpaceX. He is the world’s second-richest person, according to Forbes magazine.

In February, a San Francisco jury found Musk not liable for investor losses over his “funding secured” tweet. REUTERS