‘Expensive’ India lures investors avoiding China risks

INDIA’S ability to turn its economic expansion into corporate profits makes it a better prospect for investors than Japan or China, according to the latest Bloomberg Markets Live (MLIV) Pulse survey.

The powerful rallies in Indian and Japanese equities as China’s market has slumped have reset Asia’s financial market landscape, providing global investors with three competing poles for regional allocations.

Even with China’s attractively low stock valuations, and Japan’s progress in improving corporate governance, almost half of 390 MLIV Pulse survey respondents selected India as the best investment among the three Asian giants. The survey is a vote of confidence in India as the world’s largest democracy is headed to general elections carried out over seven phases from Apr 19 until Jun 1.

“There are many reasons to prefer expensive India equities over cheap China ones such as better transmission of GDP growth into earnings growth,” said Kieran Calder, head of equity research for Asia at Union Bancaire Privee in Singapore. A “better track record of delivering consistent earnings growth and supportive geopolitical environment” further bolster the case for Indian shares, he said.

Key stock indexes in both India and Japan have climbed to records this year following a rally driven by rapid economic growth in the case of India, and the gradual return of inflation, along with corporate reforms in Japan. Indian equities now trade at around 23 times next year’s expected earnings, exceeding even the US, and outpacing the 17 for Japan and about nine for China, according to data compiled by Bloomberg based on MSCI’s indexes.

The main gauge of Chinese equities has tumbled about 40 per cent from its peak set three years ago as deflation and a rolling property crisis have weighed on the economy. More than half of the survey respondents said they expected China’s equity market to underperform India and Japan’s over the next 12 months.

GET BT IN YOUR INBOX DAILY

Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox.

Sign UpVIEW ALL

Indian equities attracted US$25 billion in net inflows for the year to March, compared with just US$5.3 billion for China, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. The tailwinds behind Indian shares include the growing population and optimism the growing middle class will feed into higher corporate profits.

“India is the best market to own,” said Vikas Pershad, portfolio manager at M&G Investments in Singapore. Indian equities are likely to play a large role in regional benchmarks, he said.

Indian shares now make up 18 per cent of the MSCI Emerging Markets Index. China’s 25 per cent weighting is well down from its high of more than 40 per cent a few years ago.

Infrastructure in India was highlighted as a particular bright spot in the survey by 41 per cent of the respondents. The government of Prime Minister Narendra Modi has more than tripled its infrastructure allocation from five years ago to more than 11 trillion rupees (S$179 billion) for the 2025 fiscal year. Modi is projected to invest 143 trillion rupees to modernise critical infrastructure in the six years to 2030.

India’s infrastructure and capital goods bellwether Larsen & Toubro is trading at a price-earnings ratio of about 30 times. At the same time, other firms such as PNC Infratech and JSW Infrastructure are still trading at or below their 10-year average valuations.

The South Asian nation has also fast emerged as an alternative to China for global manufacturing, with the likes of Apple beefing up its production facilities in the country.

Modi’s party faces a national election this year, and he has made India’s accelerating economy a major part of his pitch. He is expected to return as prime minister with a strong majority to deepen infrastructure investment and manufacturing. Should he lose, it may derail the infrastructure and manufacturing push. Investors do not seem concerned though, with more than four-fifths of respondents saying the impact of the elections on markets would be negligible or does not concern them.

Japanese value stocks, typically larger and well established firms that trade at relatively cheap metrics, were also identified by more than a third of respondents as an attractive investment.

One of the main reasons for the rally in Japanese equities has been the corporate reforms pursued by the Tokyo Stock Exchange (TSE).

“Japanese companies are dealing with the TSE’s request seriously,” said Fumie Kikuchi, a research analyst at GMO in Singapore. “It means a lot that now corporate management speaks the same language that investors do.”

In China, meanwhile, slowing economic growth, the spectre of deflation and the ongoing real-estate crisis are likely to deter investors, according to Adrian Zuercher, head of global asset allocation and co-head for global investment management Apac at UBS Global Wealth Management.

“There is very little incentive to allocate to China,” he said. “We are still in a deflationary environment, and as long as we don’t seem to be trending upwards – which would create more revenue growth – there is very little appeal.” BLOOMBERG