H1 corp earnings a big let-down

Analysts warn that defensive S'pore stocks like Reits and telcos may come under pressure as headwinds continue

Published Mon, Aug 15, 2016 · 09:50 PM

    Singapore

    PLEASANT surprises were few and far between in the most recently ended quarter of corporate earnings in Singapore. Results in the season largely disappointed, particularly in the troubled offshore and marine industry, analysts said, adding that the outlook for the rest of the year was gloomy especially for sectors such as banks.

    As at 7.13pm Friday, 394 Singapore-listed companies had released their financial results for the six months ended June 2016, figures compiled by The Business Times showed. About two-thirds of them or 260 companies were in the black for the half-year and the remaining 134 were loss-making.

    There were 117 companies that chalked up lower profits for H1 this year compared with the year-ago period, and another 48 that fell into the red from having been profitable the previous year. These easily outnumbered the 106 firms that notched up a rise in net profit year-on-year and the 36 that went back into the black from losses the preceding year. The median change in net profit was a 4.5 per cent slide.

    Analysts said the lack of topline and bottomline growth in the April through June period this year could indicate that dividend cuts may be on the horizon, especially for offshore and marine firms.

    "The Q2 2016 results season was a disappointing one," said Lee Wen Ching, director at the chief investment office of UBS Wealth Management. "Among the universe of stocks which have reported their results, only 56 per cent were in line with expectations, while 44 per cent missed expectations. Notably, none has surpassed expectations so far."

    She said earnings disappointments were "rampant across various industries, ranging from the offshore and marine sector which continues to be plagued by lower capital expenditure among upstream players, to the aviation sector where competition has depressed yields".

    The outlook for the three local banks has also deteriorated after the fallout from offshore and marine company Swiber, which recently sought liquidation then decided to go under judicial management, she added.

    "Analysts have been trimming their earnings estimates since the start of the year, and we expect this trend to persist in view of the disappointing results in Q2 2016 ... we are expecting no earnings growth for Singapore this year."

    CMC market analyst Margaret Yang said rigbuilders Keppel Corp and Sembcorp Marine have already suffered a "deep cut" in dividends this year and the cuts "could continue if the sector is going to face a prolonged downturn".

    KGI Fraser trading strategist Nicholas Teo also said the oil and gas sector "as a collective group has seen significant haircuts in their reported numbers with possibly more bad news to come... How that mood could transfer to banks, have been widely debated... outlook will remain uncertain, with possibly the likelihood of further downgrades as more data points are released."

    Analysts said the offshore and marine sector downturn could affect their lenders, the three local banks.

    "There are growing concerns as to whether we are at the start of a credit cycle where non-performing loans (NPLs) could rise and earnings could fall due to higher credit costs," Ms Lee said. "Given that the banks form the largest constituents of the Straits Times Index, this could cast an overhang on the index's performance in the near term."

    Ms Yang also flagged higher NPL ratios for the banks along with possible "unexpected provision charges". But she noted that so far this year, the three local banks have kept their dividend payouts unchanged and said their dividend payout ratios were "relatively low" at around 34 per cent to 42 per cent. "That means they have more room to stretch out in order to maintain stable dividends."

    Analysts said defensive stocks such as real estate investment trusts (Reits) and telcos were stable in the second quarter but warned that telcos and other stocks traditionally known for decent dividends may come under pressure due to the challenging economic environment.

    "Telco companies are generally more defensive. But there are risks too," Ms Yang said. "M1 and Starhub's dividend payout ratios are already relatively high, leaving little room for the upsides. Singtel's payout ratio stands at 72 per cent, which is the lowest among the three. The introduction of a fourth telco player, if successful, will make the local market even more competitive."

    She added that "companies with relatively high dividend payout ratios are also facing more pressure to keep the DPS (dividend per share) amid more challenging environments" and that these names include Starhub (92.9 per cent dividend payout ratio) and M1 (80.3 per cent dividend payout ratio).

    Ms Lee said that due to the "revenue headwinds and cost challenges" for Singapore-listed firms, "our stock preference remains tilted towards defensive stocks such as Reits and telcos".

    Still, there were some green shoots, including beneficiaries from the prolonged crude oil slump.

    Ms Yang pointed out that Singapore Airlines, taxi operator ComfortDelGro and airport services group SATS have in fact increased their dividends per share over the past 12 months as lower fuel prices gave a lift to their earnings.

    Mr Teo also said that the property sector has "done better than I'd expected". "Then again, this may have been largely due to reduced numbers anticipated and also because they have been the first sector to have felt the brunt of the domestic slowdown with the slide in the local housing markets. Signs have emerged of some stability there - but still, stability may not necessarily mean any foreseeable uptick in prices."