AFTER pledging full support for the embattled regime of Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro, Russia is starting to show signs of doubt about his ability to survive an opposition challenge. While Moscow hasn't given up its public backing of Mr Maduro, it increasingly recognises that the disastrous state of Venezuela's economy is inexorably draining what remains of his public support, said two people close to the Kremlin.
At the same time, the army's reluctance to crack down on its own citizens limits his ability to use force to crush the challenge to his rule, said the people, who asked not to be identified because the issue is sensitive.
"Unfortunately, time isn't on Maduro's side," said Vladimir Dzhabarov, first deputy chairman of the international affairs committee in the upper house of Russia's Parliament. "In a situation of worsening economic crisis, the mood in society can quickly turn against him."
Moscow remains wary of Mr Maduro's US-backed opponents but is acutely aware how few levers it has to rescue a client who's too deep in financial distress for the Kremlin to bail him out and too far away for Russia to deploy significant military force to shore him up.
For years, Russia along with China has been a major backer of Mr Maduro, with ties dating back to 1999 when his predecessor Hugo Chavez came to power. It extended billions of dollars in loans and investments, most by state-owned oil giant Rosneft PJSC, and is scrambling to protect its interests as US President Donald Trump steps up efforts to oust the Venezuelan leader, crippling the country's economy with sanctions.
Despite the history of support, Moscow has ruled out providing new money to an ally that's had to have past debts restructured.
Russia, which is also a major arms exporter to Venezuela, is "very, very worried" about the political situation in the country, Dmitry Shugaev, head of the Federal Service for Military-Technical Cooperation told Kommersant newspaper. "But we are not inclined to curtail cooperation."
The latest warning sign for the Kremlin was the recognition by key European powers of National Assembly leader Juan Guaido as president after Mr Maduro refused to call new elections. This followed the defection of an air force general and Mr Maduro's failed bid to ship 20 tonnes of gold out of the Latin American nation to raise much-needed cash.
Though lesser officials have backed the Venezuelan leader, Russian President Vladimir Putin has made no public statement in support of Mr Maduro since the crisis erupted beyond a phone call to him on Jan 24.
Venezuela is of limited strategic importance to Russia, though it offers symbolic significance in demonstrating Mr Putin's reach into a region seen as Washington's backyard. Russia doesn't have the capacity to send forces there as it did to support Syrian leader Bashar al-Assad.
Talks between the Venezuelan government and opposition are the only way out of the crisis "otherwise, there'll simply be the sort of regime change that the West has engaged in many times", Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov said in Tajikistan on Tuesday.
While Russian officials have publicly ruled out talks with the opposition, contacts are likely taking place behind the scenes, according to analysts in Moscow.
"Today Maduro is in control of the country but with every day he has less leverage as his legitimacy is contested," said Dmitry Rozental, an expert on Venezuela at Moscow's state-funded Institute for Latin American Studies. "His chances of hanging on to power are fading."
Mr Guaido reached out to China with a pledge to uphold agreements signed under laws approved by the National Assembly, whose powers Mr Maduro stripped in 2017, in an interview with Bloomberg News. A democratic Venezuela would be a better bet for protecting Russian and Chinese investments, he said last week.
The opposition-controlled National Assembly has criticised the growing role of Rosneft, headed by a powerful Putin ally, Igor Sechin, which has stakes in five Venezuelan oil ventures. The company said on Tuesday that Venezuela's state oil producer, PDVSA, paid off half of its outstanding debt to Rosneft last year, owing US$2.3 billion at the end of 2018.
Rosneft took a 49.9 per cent stake in PDVSA's US-based subsidiary, Citgo Petroleum, as collateral for a US$1.5 billion loan in 2016, and signed a deal in 2017 to operate two offshore natural gas fields. While those deals could be cancelled because they weren't endorsed by lawmakers, Russia may negotiate a compromise, said Mr Rozental.
With Venezuelan oil exports already at a 28-year low and due to slide further as US sanctions banning PDVSA's crude sales take effect, Russia knows the real culprit is mismanagement of the world's largest proven reserves, said Andres Landabaso Angulo, a professor at Moscow's Ple khanov University of Economics. BLOOMBERG