Working from home won't level the playing field for women

Annabeth Leow
Published Mon, Jun 28, 2021 · 09:50 PM

    Singapore

    THE rise of flexi-work might sound like good news for women workers, who culturally bear a heavier share of household caregiving duties.

    The share of bosses offering formal flexible work arrangements (FWAs) was 78 per cent in 2020, up sharply from 53 per cent pre-pandemic, the Ministry of Manpower (MOM) has reported. The top three prevailing FWAs were flexible hours (59 per cent), telecommuting (46 per cent) and part-time work (44 per cent).

    But a local researcher recently found that women have a higher preference for working from the office (WFO). Most notably, working women are concerned that the blurred boundaries between work and family could penalise their career progression.

    So, amid the growing adoption of working from home (WFH), watchers told The Business Times that women's workforce participation still depends on having men shoulder more of the caregiving burden - with a greater use of flexi-work, not limited by gender.

    To be sure, KPMG Singapore partner Ram Lakshminarayanan, who heads the firm's people and change advisory services, told BT: "Covid-19 has provided an opportunity for women to balance these (caregiving) demands better, since working from home gives them access to both family and work in the same space."

    Yet, despite greater FWA availability, women have a higher preference for WFO, NUS Business School professor of management and organisation Vivien Lim found in a recent survey.

    In an ideal work week, women respondents wanted to WFO for an average of 2.2 days and WFH for the remaining 2.8 days. In contrast, men aimed to WFO for 1.7 days and WFH for the other 3.3 days.

    "One major challenge related to WFH is that work creeps into the family; there is also no demarcation between work and life and the workday gets prolonged," Prof Lim told BT.

    "Having to juggle domestic and work responsibilities, being interrupted by others while trying to work, and having to share physical space to work with other family members when they WFH are other reasons cited."

    Similarly, Lewis Garrad, career business leader at human resources firm Mercer, told BT: "While the pandemic has helped boost acceptance of flexible and remote work and helped women to juggle household responsibilities with work, we've also seen how it has created more stress."

    He cited a global survey from Mercer where women "reported experiencing a double-double shift" - juggling day job and housework - which led to "higher levels of cumulative stress".

    Female managers thus ranked their sense of being "balanced and healthy" at 3.42 on a five-point scale last August, compared with 3.63 for female employees, 3.66 for male managers and 3.71 for male employees.

    Yet women have shown a higher demand than men for FWAs.

    Some 40 per cent of Singapore women expect their employers to offer FWAs such as WFH, compared with 35 per cent of Singapore men, according to a January survey commissioned by human resources website LinkedIn.

    "In fact, many (women) have also come to expect such flexibility programmes from their organisations as they seek to better balance their work and family responsibilities," said Feon Ang, vice-president of LinkedIn Talent Solutions for the Asia-Pacific.

    A separate poll from consultancy Boston Consulting Group (BCG) also found in late 2020 that 92 per cent of Singapore women wanted to WFH at least twice a week - slightly higher than the 88 per cent of men.

    On the other hand, 71 per cent of women wanted flexible working hours, against 77 per cent of men.

    Still, the gender difference in flexi-work preferences may not be statistically significant, BCG suggested.

    Instead, observers urged a universal approach to flexi-work, to lift the unequal burden on working women.

    When done right, FWAs could be a key enabler for women's careers.

    Former Manpower Ministry divisional director of planning and policy Terence Ho, now an associate professor in practice at the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy, told BT: "Besides increasing the female labour force participation rate, FWA adoption can also help to narrow the gender pay gap if it widens the range of job roles, including traditionally male-dominated, higher-paying jobs, accessible to women with caregiving responsibilities; or helps them to remain in the workforce."

    Women's labour force participation rate stood at 61.2 per cent in 2020, inching up from 61.1 per cent the year before - but it still trailed the 75.4 per cent for men in both years.

    Meanwhile, full-time female employees aged 25 to 54 years old earned 16.3 per cent less in median income than men in 2018, the most recent data available from the MOM.

    Sim Gim Guan, executive director of the Singapore National Employers Federation, said: "Work-life harmony practices started as family-friendly employment practices when more women joined the workforce a few decades ago. This may have given rise to the misconception that work-life harmony applies to women only."

    As such, workplace watchers stressed that FWAs should be implemented with an eye to gender equity.

    Mercer's Mr Garrad outlined some steps to avoid reinforcing the disadvantages to working women.

    "Employers must ensure opportunities for engagement so women who choose to work remotely will not see their careers suffer as a result," he told BT. "They should also redesign performance and career management processes to eliminate any bias toward in-office work."

    BCG partner and managing director Kong Ming Teck added: "Sharing of caring responsibilities and its impact on pay need to continue to be addressed; measures such as parental leave and flexible roles will also need to be emphasised."

    Said Mr Sim: "Regardless of whether an employee used any of the work-life benefits, including FWAs, their performance and career should still be based on objective criteria and merit... Employers who recognise such needs and allow employees to manage their career more flexibly would be able to better attract and retain talent."

    But Peter Bentley, global chief commercial officer and future of work leader for human capital solutions, Aon, rebuffed concerns that flexi-work will negatively affect women's salary gaps and career progression.

    Pay and performance structures rarely focus on the setting where the work is being done, he said.

    "While we are seeing questions on career progression become more prevalent, at the moment it is more positively biased", such as towards promoting upskilling and diversity in the workplace, Mr Bentley remarked.

    Indeed, Yeo Wan Ling, director for the women and family and small and medium-sized enterprise units at the National Trades Union Congress, told BT that work-life harmony and FWAs, "combined with more men shouldering caregiving burdens, will go a long way to improve female labour force participation rate and giving women real choices when it comes to their careers and home responsibilities".

    In that vein, Prof Lim said: "In a work environment where everyone adopts flexi-work, the playing field will be more levelled. I expect the career penalty associated with flexi-work for women to diminish over time."