You are here
South Korea dog meat campaigners accused of hypocrisy
[NAMYANGJU, South Korea] Barking at their rescuers, labradors, beagles and mongrels desperately scrambled out of rusty cages in South Korea: saved from the dinner plate by a deal with dog-meat farmer Kim Young-hwan.
In the face of falling demand, Mr Kim agreed to close his establishment in exchange for compensation from US-based Humane Society International (HSI). The dogs are bound for a new life in adoptive homes in the West.
He is the 10th canine-meat farmer to accept such an offer in three years. The exact sums are confidential, but each deal requires hundreds of thousands of dollars once adoption costs are included.
"This business is doomed... I wanted to quit before it's too late," Mr Kim said.
The 56-year-old had 170 dogs at his farm in Namyangju, north of Seoul.
"The price has plummeted in recent years," he told AFP. "I'm barely making ends meet these days. Plus I've been harassed by animal rights groups all the time. It's such a hassle."
The push by animal rights activists, including many overseas groups, to outlaw dog meat consumption in the South has sparked mixed reactions and accusations of Western hypocrisy.
South Koreans are believed to consume about one million dogs a year as a summertime delicacy, with the greasy red meat - which is invariably boiled for tenderness - believed to increase energy.
The tradition has declined as the nation increasingly embraces the idea of dogs as pets instead of livestock, with eating them now something of a taboo among young South Koreans.
Nevertheless, activists have stepped up campaigns to ban dog consumption, with online petitions urging boycotts of the 2018 Pyeongchang Winter Olympics over the issue and protests in Seoul.
Such lobbying has provoked angry debates over what many describe as cultural double standards.
"I don't eat dogs, but I am disgusted by those who preach that only animals deemed cuddly enough or friendly enough by Westerners deserve to live," read one online comment.
One fifth of the South's 50 million people own pets, mostly dogs and cats, said another netizen, but for many of the rest, dogs were "no more special than lambs or rabbits".
Similar debates have emerged in other Asian nations where dogs are eaten.
China's most notorious dog meat festival in the south-western town of Yulin has drawn crowds despite international outrage, with sellers saying the criticism has actually encouraged more people to eat canines.
Taiwan banned dog meat consumption in April to mixed reaction, with some deeming it unfair to single out certain species under what was mocked as the "cute animal protection law".
Polls show South Korean public opinion is divided.
According to a survey this year 70 per cent of South Koreans do not eat dogs, but far fewer - about 40 per cent - believe the practice should be banned.
It also found 65 per cent support raising and slaughtering dogs in more humane conditions.
There is no law on how to treat or slaughter canines in the meat trade in South Korea. But while farmers have urged Seoul to include dogs under livestock welfare regulations, animal rights groups oppose doing so, seeking complete abolition instead.
At Mr Kim's rundown farm, dogs sat behind tarnished brown rusty bars, their bowls filled with soupy scraps.
Housed in pairs, they spent up to a year in cages about two square metres and reeking of excrement before being sent to slaughterhouses.
Senior HSI director Kelly O'Meara said no animals should endure such awful conditions, and dogs in particular had "a special place" for people as they are often pets.
"That has certainly been the case in the West, but in Asia we see more and more people having dogs as companion animals too," she told AFP.
Each such farm closure - one of HSI's most expensive initiatives - is broadcast live online.
But Ahn Yong-geun, a food and nutrition professor at ChungCheong University in Cheongju, questioned whether such organisations would condemn larger-scale beef or pork industries - which have lobbying power and broad public support - "in the same angry, aggressive fashion".
"The activists won't get as much excitement from donors about a pig rescue project or a cow rescue project, although these animals have just as much capacity to suffer and love as dogs," said Prof Ahn, a vocal critic of the push to ban dog meat.
Wendy Higgins, director of international media at HSI, said the group encouraged people to "reduce and replace meat in their diet" but admitted rescue campaigns for animals such as cattle or pigs were not common.
Even so campaigns against cruelty in dog farming could "make people widen their circle of compassion for other animals in animal agriculture too", she added.
For his part farmer Mr Kim will not be raising any other animals for meat - he is banned from doing so under the deal with HSI.
"The social atmosphere has changed," he said, adding: "Eating dog is seen as if it's a crime these days."