You are here
Von Furstenberg's brand is left exposed by the pandemic
[NEW YORK] At the end of February, just as the coronavirus was beginning to cast its pall over Europe, an elite crowd that included the likes of Anna Wintour, Jeff Bezos and Seth Meyers gathered in the gilded 19th-century halls of the Ministry of Europe and Foreign Affairs in Paris to watch Diane von Furstenberg be awarded the Légion d'Honneur.
"The woman clothed by Diane von Furstenberg is free in her movement and free to take life in her own hands," said Christine Lagarde, president of the European Central Bank, who wore a red wrap DVF pantsuit while pinning the medal on von Furstenberg's velvet dress.
She noted that von Furstenberg, 73, deserved the honor for her service to women's liberation, for raising US$100 million for the renovation of the Statue of Liberty and for what she meant to fashion.
Within four months, the British and French operations of von Furstenberg's company had done the European equivalent of filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy. Just over 60 per cent of the corporate and retail staff in the United States, Britain and France was laid off, creditors were complaining vociferously about unpaid bills, and von Furstenberg was making plans to close 18 of her 19 remaining directly operated US stores. She was transforming her company from one rooted in bricks and mortar to a business focused on the intellectual property value of her brand name, which can be attached to products and e-commerce initiatives.
Her glamorous personal brand had masked the fact that her fashion line had been losing money for years. Her company, like many fashion brands, had been relying on an old business model. When the pandemic hit and stores were closed, there was nowhere to hide.
"Corona hits someone a lot worse if they have a precondition," von Furstenberg said in an interview.
The effects of the pandemic, which has forced retail chains such as Neiman Marcus and JC Penney as well as companies like J Crew into bankruptcy, have reached the designer sector. And von Furstenberg, who for decades had been the face of American fashion, both as the inventor of the wrap dress and as the 13-year head of the Council of Fashion Designers of America, is suddenly at risk of becoming the most recognizable example of its crisis.
The question is whether she can restructure her business while avoiding bankruptcy in the United States, keeping her name and getting through this period with enough of her reputation intact to become the face of the industry's recovery. She is trying to create a business model to pass on, as she has dreamed, to a new generation through her 21-year-old granddaughter, Talita von Furstenberg.
"There's no shame in admitting you are in trouble," Diane von Furstenberg said. "It kills me, but it kills everybody. Every designer is calling me. I want to tell people this happens to everybody."
But there are plenty of unhappy people, from employees who were let go without severance to unpaid vendors, for whom that explanation may not be enough.
According to von Furstenberg, the company's financial problems began around 2015 — just after the 40th anniversary of her wrap dress and the publication of her memoir, "The Woman I Wanted to Be." She had been thinking about her legacy and, she said, listened to advice that her goal should be "to build a big operating business" by following the luxury brand playbook developed by Gucci and Dior: Open flagship stores on important shopping streets in capitals around the world. Between 2013 and 2015, she nearly doubled her number of directly owned stores.
This move saddled the business with expensive rents and yearslong leases at a time when nimble digital brands were rising. The company was also in creative turmoil, with a revolving door of five designers — one of whom did two stints — in 10 years.
"There started to be a real inconsistency in creative direction, and that got very expensive, because we started losing customers," said Sandra Campos, the label's chief executive until she left last month.
The company was kept afloat by the wealth of von Furstenberg and her billionaire husband, Barry Diller. By 2016, von Furstenberg said, she realized she had made a mistake and began to pull back on retail, although it was not until 2018 that she hired Ms Campos as chief executive and a restructuring plan was created.
"This is an emotional business, and emotional decisions get made — and she's a great believer in all people," Ms Campos said of von Furstenberg. "It's both a strength and a weakness in terms of making decisions that are smart business for the long term."
They tried to renegotiate and surrender leases, gradually reducing the losses by 65 per cent. Although there was more of a focus on e-commerce, it was still only 20 per cent of the business. Sales, which had been about US$300 million before the 2008 recession, had shrunk to half that.
"I've lost an enormous amount of money in the last four years," von Furstenberg said.
Still, to most of the world, the privately held label, closely intertwined with von Furstenberg's enviable lifestyle and extraordinary biography — the daughter of a Holocaust survivor who married European royalty, a self-made design power who landed on the cover of Newsweek at 29 — appeared to be a success.
In 2010, von Furstenberg and her family created the DVF Awards to honor the achievements of women like Anita Hill and Misty Copeland, and last year, she started an initiative called In Charge with the aim of creating a networking hub for women.
On Instagram, where von Furstenberg has 232,000 followers, she posted luxurious travel scenes, advice and motivational mantras, along with pictures of herself as a young woman and as a doting grandmother. A succession plan came into focus with the introduction of a capsule collection last year from her granddaughter Talita. Called "TVF for DVF," it was celebrated at a young-socialite-studded October luncheon in New York's SoHo neighborhood.
But as the pandemic began to hit the retail sector, DVF's problems morphed into a crisis. In January, as the virus forced a lockdown in China, the company began to postpone payments to vendors, struggling with a major loss of revenue from Chinese consumers, who accounted for 20 per cent of the brand's global sales. As the virus crept across Europe, things worsened. By early June, DVF reportedly owed more than US$10 million in store rent and millions more to vendors. The company declined to comment on the matter.
"A turnaround in the best of times takes three to five years, patience and consistency of design and strategy," Ms Campos said. "Then Covid hits in the middle of it. You may have to make decisions you would not otherwise have made."
The company started furloughing most of its U.S. employees in March after closing its offices in the meatpacking district of Manhattan, where Diane von Furstenberg also maintains a pied-à-terre that overlooks the High Line, the city park she was instrumental in creating.
"Every single thing was considered," said von Furstenberg, from Chapter 7 liquidations to Chapter 11 bankruptcy to a sale to a company such as Authentic Brands Group, which specializes in stripping valuable brands of their physical dead weight and applying their names to mass-market products.
However, in the end, von Furstenberg said, she felt only the family could ensure the brand's legacy.
Von Furstenberg, Diller and von Furstenberg's son, Alex, and daughter, Tatiana — the majority of the company's six-person board — decided to "shrink everything down and go back to the core," Diane von Furstenberg said. They would effectively pare the company to its bones and preserve the brand name until DVF could grow again or Talita took over. More than half the employees have been laid off, many without severance.
DVF struck a deal with a Chinese partner, ZBT Ltd, to not only operate all 38 franchise stores in that country but also to handle production, fabric sourcing and development, and manage the relationship with DVF's longtime manufacturer in China. The remaining stores outside the United States are all franchises. Ms Campos became a part-time consultant after resigning last month.
"I couldn't afford her," von Furstenberg said.
DVF's physical existence in the United States will be limited to the ground floor of its headquarters in the meatpacking district.
If her plan works, it will mark the third iteration of the company, which began in 1972 when von Furstenberg arrived in New York with her husband at the time, Prince Egon von Furstenberg. Overzealous licensing deals on everything from eyeglasses to luggage marked the end of the original era of DVF. Von Furstenberg distanced herself from the brand, but in 1992, she was lured back to fashion by QVC, and five years later the next stage of DVF began.
Now the layoffs and issues with vendors have put von Furstenberg in a delicate position.
On April 13, von Furstenberg posted a photo of herself on Instagram captioned: "This forced pause is giving us time to think…take advantage of it, to eventually reset…Have a good week and be safe."
Someone responded in a now-deleted comment that circulated via screenshot among current and former staff: "During this forced thoughtful pause did you come up with any ideas on how your @DVF employees (who were put on furlough with ZERO salary) take advantage of this downtime? Some of us are struggling to pay bills, feed our families and enjoy this time of resetting you speak of."
Some of the brand's vendors are still waiting on payments from the fall. Emily Thompson, who owns a flower design company in Manhattan, said she was owed more than US$20,000 for the October luncheon held for Talita von Furstenberg's collection.
Diane von Furstenberg said she did not blame Ms Thompson for being upset and had every intention of paying what was owed — or at least as much as she could — both to her vendors and her staff.
"We will be as fair as we possibly can," she said. "The smaller people will definitely be handled. I own it — of course I do."
She had to, she noted; she is writing a new book, called "Own It."
She added that what she was doing with the brand was "what I should probably have done a while back," and that she was feeling increasingly positive about the future.
"I can see the light at the end of the tunnel," von Furstenberg said. "But things change from morning to night. So who knows? A big wave could come and we would be swamped again."